Fractivism Takes Something from the World’s Oldest Profession

Fractivism - Tom Shepstone ReportsTom Shepstone
Natural Gas NOW   

 

Fractivism is prone to outrageous activity and utterances but the latest accusations by a retired Bloomsburg University professor trying to sell books takes the cake, as he takes something from the world’s oldest profession.

Does taking a generous pension from a bankrupt state employee retirement fund, the economic salvage of which depends on oil and gas development, make you a prostitute? Walter Brasch’s logic suggests it does and he’s one of the pensioners.

Brasch, a retired journalism professor from Bloomsburg University, published a column and piece on his blog yesterday suggesting Lackawanna College was a prostitute for taking a $2.5 million endowment gift from Cabot Oil & Gas and donations from numerous other gas companies to help fund its School of Petroleum & Natural Gas. If there were ever a case to conclusively prove no good deed goes unpunished, this might be it.

“Award Winning” Fractivism

FractivismWalter Brasch, like Sandra Steingraber, is one of those folks who always identify themselves on their blogs and in their writings as “award-winning.” He is the classic holier than thou guy who imagines there is no form of social justice but his own and he’s determined to impose it. He’s also a good writer from a stylistic perspective, able to communicate in ordinary language, and has written several books. His most recent, which he’s obviously trying to sell by pulling a Lindsay Lohan and saying something outrageous to get attention, is Fracking Pennsylvania: Flirting with Disaster.

Now that I’ve done my part in selling the book, let’s focus on the outrageous comment a bit. Brasch says:

Lackawanna College, a two-year college in Scranton, Pa., has become a prostitute.

The administration doesn’t think of themselves or their college as a prostitute. They believe they are doing a public service. Of course, streetwalkers and call-girls also believe they are doing a public service.

Lackawanna College’s price is $2.5 million.

…

It’s the same company, fronted by four lawyers, that managed to keep a peaceful grandmother anti-fracking activist not only off its property, but away from Susquehanna County’s recycling center, a hospital, grocery stores, restaurants, and 40 percent of the county where Cabot has mineral-rights leases.

Several major gas and oil companies and suppliers–including Anadarko, BakerHughes, Chesapeake Energy, Halliburton, Noble Energy, Southwestern Energy, Williams Midstream, and others–have also contributed scholarships, equipment, and funding to the School. The School’s mission includes creating “a campus that is focused and dedicated to the oil and gas industry.”

…

Admission to the School’s rigorous academic programs “is highly competitive,” with students needing a strong science and math background prior to acceptance, says Marquardt. The students earn an associate in science degree upon completion of the two-year program. “It is focused on a very specific market,” says Marquardt, providing personnel at a level between the vocational training programs and the B.S. engineering programs. The placement rate is over 90 percent, says Marquardt.

In their fourth semester, students take a course in “Leadership, Ethics, & Regulations,” which explores “the holistic environment in which the Petroleum and Natural Gas industry operates, including the effect of corporate leadership on the company’s credibility and reputation; real world ethical issues … and the relationship of the industry to federal, state, and local governments, including regulatory agencies.”

…

An associate’s degree doesn’t mean the students, no matter how prepared they are to work in the shale-gas industry, will be exposed to the issues, reports, and scientific studies that suggest fracking causes significant environmental and health problems, major concerns of those who oppose the process of horizontal fracking. After all, Cabot wasn’t going to invest in a college program that presented all sides of the issues. Nor is Cabot likely to invest anything more if the college expands its program to require that students also take classes in renewable energy, and the health and environmental effects of fracking.

But, that really doesn’t matter. Cabot paid $2.5 million, and other gas supplier, extraction, and development companies donated scholarships, funds, and equipment to make sure the students receive what may be one of the nation’s best possible educations to be prepared to work in the gas fields. They didn’t put money and resources into a program that would ask some of the most important questions–“What are the major effects to the health and environment from what we are doing?”, “What should we be doing to develop new technology that doesn’t threaten the health and safety of the people?”, and “Is fossil fuel really the best way to assure the production of energy?”

Readers of this blog will probably want to gag at the description of Vera Scroggins as a “peaceful grandmother.” She is, rather, a foul-mouthed zealot who knew well, at the time she was pretending otherwise, that no one was trying to prohibit her from doing anything but dangerously trespass on construction sites.

The Hypocrisy of Fractivism

What is more disturbing, though, is the suggestion students aren’t learning precisely how to do things correctly. One wants to scream “that’s the whole point!” What Brasch wants, instead, is to indoctrinate the students in his alternative viewpoint.  No opinion, no fact, no learning that does not conform to his view of the world is acceptable. He’s the ultimate conformist and opposes any diversity of thought not in alignment with his own. He wants “Indoctrinate U.” But, if you accept private donations to teach students what they need to know to secure a rewarding career, doing things correctly by any book but one of his, you’re a prostitute.

fractivism - Indoctrinate_U_poster

Such is the culture of the extremist and Brasch is an extremist, as any objective look at his writing will reveal. He also, apparently, lives off a public pension paid out to him for teaching students his views, a pension turning to oil and gas investments as a way of to financially recover, which is apparently just fine with him. More on that in a moment, but let’s first look at what Brasch says about fracking in his book.

The misinformation starts with his cover depicting a flaming faucet. How many times do we have to explain flaming faucets don’t come from hydraulic fracturing but, rather methane migration, which can happen naturally or from drilling a gas well, a water well or a geothermal well? Yet, Brasch’s book would have one believe it does, by combining a title with a picture suggesting it is so, when it is not – shades of Gasland.

Brasch also makes a point of using footnotes after almost every sentence in his introduction to suggest everything is carefully sourced, but good sourcing is a matter of quality not the quantity. Citing Sandra Steingraber, a biologist, as an expert on the fracturing of rock (she actually says fracking breaks bedrock up into “broken shards”) doesn’t qualify.

Likewise, quoting the pathetic RFK, Jr. to the effect “the industry now acknowledges it absolutely cannot afford to pay localities the costs of road damages” when that is exactly what it’s doing (in advance in most cases), doesn’t do much for your credibility either. Nor does using Tony Ingraffea’s debunked casing failures assertions, or quoting Yvonne Taylor, the propane user who is leading a battle against Inergy’s proposed propane storage facility. Brasch even went on this radio program to discuss his book and, at 5:21, made the astonishing statement that vertical fracking (meaning development in his incorrect vernacular) is less impactful than horizontal, when it’s clear the latter reduces disturbance by a factor of 16 or more.

Brasch goes on and on, in fact, using one discredited source after another in his radio interview and book.  It’s as if the President of Bloomsburg University used the Three Stooges as a source to defend his annual budget. The book is simply a polemic intended to rally the radical troops, nothing more. This is what Brasch would like Lackawanna College to teach. It would prepare them for careers as trash journalists, community organizers and tenured college professors, but it wouldn’t do much for them or the rest of us.

fractivism pensionsBrasch, though, is living off a nice pension. He was a member of Pennsylvania’s public employee $100,000 club in 2007, before he retired, so he’s ok. His pension fund is probably not, because of some extraordinarily dumb policy decisions made by Pennsylvania’s elected officials a decade ago.  Retirement funds that were overfunded in 2001 are now a third below where they should be. Until the legislature corrects the the problem, the only way out is to pursue more profitable investments such as oil and gas. These include an Oil and Gas Co-Investment Fund managed by Denham Capital Management, for example. They’re a good bet because they produce financial returns between two and three times their share of the portfolio.

Interesting, huh? Brasch, unless he chose to direct his own investments, secures the pension that allows him to write drivel attacking the gas industry and call colleges prostitutes for accepting gas industry money, via investments in that very industry. There’s gotta be a name for that.

follow-us-on-twitter  like-us-on-facebook  follow-us-on-linkedin

 

Please share this post and get the word out everywhere!

6 thoughts on “Fractivism Takes Something from the World’s Oldest Profession”

  1. The absolute worst part about this is the manipulation Brasch undertakes. He is supposedly a learned person, but he cites fake experts and fails to provide all the information that would allow his readers to make up their own minds. Why? Because if he told people that Sandra Steingraber’s assertions about fracking are not supported by facts or that Tony Ingraffea’s casing research was done entirely on off-shore casings, he could not manipulate people into agreeing with him. So why is he worried about providing all the information? Because he MUST manipulate his readers to get them to agree with him. In getting them to agree, he can become even more “award-winning” and grow his ego. But our society cannot exist based on this kind of manipulation and our elected officials cannot make good decisions without accurate assessments of the issues. Brasch clearly cares less about that than his own ego.

  2. hmm lets see the professor worked 3 hours a day 150 days a year having 3 mos off in the summer ( oh wait maybe he sat in a cottage on a lake and wrote something) every weekend every holiday off 6 weeks off at Christmas and he’s calling who a what ?!

  3. Speaking of Bloomsburg University professors, let’s not forget a certain CURRENT one whom I recently tried to engage in debate, only to be blocked by. I don’t usually promote the articles of landman outfits such as yours, Mr. Shepstone, but I must say that many of THESE tellings-off of her by your side https://energyindepth.org/marcellus/wendy-lynne-lee-activist-philosophy-professor-and-now-a-fiction-story-teller/ (that’s from a year before I tried to engage her in debate myself), are spot-on.

    “Basking in her Vainglory” is the latest title that I’ve been thinking about for if I get around to writing an ad hominem book about her in my old age sometime.

  4. Pingback: Fractivism Takes Something from the Worlds Oldest Profession « ShaleMarkets.com – Oil and Gas (O&G) Shale Supply Chain

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *