Fractivist outrages seem to know no end and NaturalGasNOW starts a new regular feature called Shale Gas Stories to expose some of them.
Environment America, one the sleaziest of all fractivist organizations, has apparently used some of the $2 million in dark money it gets directly and indirectly from the Sea Change Foundation to fund a slick document entitled Shalefield Stories, which attacks the shale gas industry with what it calls “human stories.” It is collection of anecdotes and tales from individuals who make all sorts of fantastic claims about shale gas ruining their lives, none of which are backed up by anything other the words of the storytellers. The whole thing is a sham document and it occurred to us that maybe we should start telling our own shale gas stories of outrages committed by fractivists, with one significant difference; we’ll supply the evidence.
This, therefore, is the first of what we hope and expect will the first in a continuing series of short exposes on some of the fractivist outrages with which we contend every day. We’ll tell one or two stories each time. We invite you to nominate candidates and contribute your own stories if you’d like.
Trespassgate’s Vera Scroggins – The Missing Video
We have covered the shale gas stories connected with “trespassgate” in depth, pointing out serial protestor Vera Scroggins is no lovable Golden Girl, but a very guilty trespasser who loves to bully landowners and shale gas supporters around while claiming victimhood. We haven’t yet shared some of the most incriminating videos, though, or the latest legal move by Scroggins, which reveals some astonishing hypocrisy.
Scroggins has posted some 431 videos on her YouTube channel. We know, from past experience and her role in Sautnergate, that she edits them to highlight certain things and hide others. It turns out the two first videos she posted on her channel were edited in a similar fashion. They can be found here and here and include a combined 16 minutes of video taken on September 20, 2009 of a Cabot Oil & Gas development site on the Grimsley property in Susquehanna County, Pennsylvania. Vera (on left in pic) and some friends trespassed on the property to take video of a “Bentonite spill.”
Bentonite is a type of clay used as a pond sealant in the case of public water supplies, in drilling mud, in winemaking and as a cosmetic base, among other things, but Vera was there, of course, to hype the incident as part of her anti-gas schtick. She and her friends entered the property from the back, rather than the access road, and proceeded to do their “investigation” independent of the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection (DEP). She compiled the two video segments of their little unauthorized tour and posted them online. They document extensive trespassing on the site, not to mention the ignorance of those do the reporting, as they incorrectly describe conditions and processes, but that’s not the most interesting part.
No, the most interesting part is this; there’s another 38 minutes of video that’s been deleted. The longer version was made available by Shaleshock Media site for a time but, on April 9, 2012, Vera, who serves as a contributor on that site, posted the shorter version there. Why would she do that, almost three years later? Perhaps it was to avoid calling attention to some of the claims she made for posterity in that longer version–claims that she represented Susquehanna County and DEP, for example.
Here is the beginning of the Vera’s first posted video (Part 1) as she and her friend talk to one of the site workers:
And, here’s the full segment (in two pieces, as it was part of two videos in the original), with all the missing discussion. You can watch all four parts of the original video here, here, here and here.
The construction worker approaches Vera and the gang to tell them they’re not permitted on the work site unless authorized by Cabot. He explains why. She says she understands that. Vera then offers to sign “liability papers,” tells the worker “you’re off liability, don’t worry about it.” He tells her she has to leave and she arrogantly says “well, we’ll leave when we’re finished looking at it.” Then and her friends pepper him with questions, which he politely answers, that being the only part of the discussion Vera chose, for some reason, to reveal in the video posted in 2012.
But, there was much more. Notice how, at 16:46 in the first full video, Vera and her friend first tell the contractor’s representative they’re there to “serve as the eyes and ears of DEP.” Vera then can’t resist going further and actually tells the worker “We’re representing DEP plus citizen groups.” Her friend then says something about being authorized to “go any place we need to go and literally take photographs and document things,” followed by Vera repeating “We’re DEP.” Vera then tells the worker “You can tell your supervisor we’re here to represent the county and the interest of the citizens of the county.”
All of this was edited out of Vera’s video. It’s not hard to imagine why in light of subsequent events, is it? Is it a crime to impersonate a DEP officer? I’m not sure, but I do know it’s anything but ethical.
Trespassgate’s Vera Scroggins – The Stunning Arrogance and Hypocrisy
Could there be a more stunning case of fractivist arrogance and deceit? Well, probably not in the deceit category, but, sadly, there’s more on the arrogance front and, yet again, it’s one of those shale gas stories from Vera. This one, too, has to do with Trespassgate and it’s not only a matter of arrogance, but also of incredible hypocrisy. It, too, has to with videos, but not Vera’s. Rather, it has to do with video Cabot’s attorney demanded of Vera’s deposition in the Trespassgate case. It turns out Vera doesn’t much like what she does to other people.
Yes, Vera Scroggins had her attorneys file a motion last month to avoid being videoed. The motion specifically argued “there is no compelling judicial need to videotape” saying “It is believed that because of the close working relationship between Cabot Oil and certain pro-tracking organizations in the Susquehanna County area that these videotaped depositions will be revealed to those organizations to be used to enhance the pro-tracking point of view.”
The queen of fractivist videoing is afraid her actions might be preserved on video for the use of her opponents? Say it ain’t so. But, of course, it is so. The woman is a hypocrite, to no one’s surprise on this side of the aisle. Still, it ought to raise some alarm bells among her supporters. Can you trust an individual who edits videos to take out damaging information about herself? An individual who is afraid to submit herself to the same treatment she gives others? An individual whose ethics somehow allow her to illegally secure and publish video of anything and everything, but don’t permit those of a different opinion to legally video her, might be said to have a fatal credibility gap, don’t you think?
That’s the latest of numerous shale gas stories surrounding Vera Scroggins, but it probably won’t be the last. Regardless, we’ll be here to tell them. We’ll also be sharing many other shale gas stories of similar shenanigans by fractivists. There seems to be no end to the outrage. Next, we’ll go to New York and profile the leader of anti-development group in the Finger Lakes. Stay tuned.


Please, no more about Vera Scroggins. You’re obsessed.
And this entry could use some editing – typos galore.
Well, not galore, but there were a few, now corrected. Unfortunately, Vera keeps generating material that must be countered. Blame her and a few fawning members of the media for that. The folks in Susquehanna County want the truth told about her. Still, I must admit she is dreadfully tiring.
why do you fear her so ??If she is wrong just ignore her !!
Unfortunately, the media does not ignore her. We’re not afraid – just determined to get the truth out.
you want truth that’s what she tries to bring out !Why does the NG industry (Cabot) want her silenced so.Because she shows the public what really goes on ! Something the NG industry doesn’t want to happen .I seen this near me too .If they have nothing to hide why the security and non transparency on the whole process .
Fear VEra? Hardly. She is merely a bully to be stood up to and told that she can’t continue to spread her lies and obnoxious, divisive, and irresponsible actions in the community anymore. Taht is waht Tom is doing and that is a makr of courage, not fear.
A child would no be allowed to act as Vera does, and the First Amendment does not give her the right to do as she is anymore than it would allow her to go into a theater and yell fire. She is being just as irresponsible sprading unrest based on factless lies and fearmingering. Just because she thinks she has the right doesn’t make her right.
Tom, time to take off the gloves and really let her have it. I and others will pitch in as best we can!
you do Fear and hate her because she brings out what really goes on !!
Exactly, the man, Shepstone, is obsessed; I wonder why?? and he’s twisted the information intensely as usual to make me look bad and all of it can be contested in a court of law….I have important things to do, like continue to expose and reveal the latest contamination and pollution and harm to my fellow residents, who reside in a gas developed county and not like Shepstone, who does not reside in a gas developed county. Wonder why??
I’m praying my lease gets activiated, Vera. Notice, you challenge no facts.
Tom I hope your dream comes true so you can see what it does to a community and the lies that come with lease signing ,interpretation ,and NG development .Quality of life is so much more important than money .your area will never be the same .just stating what I have experienced here.
Bill, you are showing anger today and after meeting you in person I really don’t think you’re that kind of guy. I know you’re going to say “if you lived here, you’d be angry too…” but, honestly, I don’t think so. We have very different perspectives. That’s why we should keep talking.
I have a question – if fossil fuels are so evil why do you continue to use them?
why dont you go AMish?
why do you use oil and electricity that comes from natural gas and oil?
since you make up about 50% of the people if you stopped using fossil fuels you could destroy the fossil fuel market in the northeast –
so go ahead and quit using them –
put your actions where your mouth is . Start living like the Amish
YOu remind me of the fat kid in the corner of the candy store – stuffing as much as he can into his mouth while all along preaching how bad it is
Continuing to use fossil fuels then complaining about them qualifies for the definition of hyprocrite –
quit using fossil fuels – period – then some of us in the middle might listen – but right now all you remind me of is the young enthusiastic reporterette, freshly minted from the uniform mold of diversity who drove her car to the airport. There she boarded the 747 and promptly ignored the machine which spewed evil fumes filling her mind with thoughts of what a maganamous person was I.
In Fairbanks she boarded a piper cub which again spewed forth the evil fumes – after that she got on a snowmobile and went to ANWR. There she stood in her Kevlar coat spewing self righteous indignation at how we must preserve this for the “common person.” A young eskimo boy asked her “ If every person did what you just did they would use up all the fuel in ANWR”
She retorted – ‘fossil fuels are good for certain people but not others . Certain people deserve the benefits they bring yet at the same time can eschew them and prevent the general population from obtaining them – this is what socialistic environmentalism is all about. All are equal but some are more equal than others ”
worn out rap ! time to get a new line !
Tom is no more obsessed than a doctor trying to rid a patient of cancer over the course of many months and years is obsessed. It is merely due diligence. Tom is the doctor saving the community patient from the cancer that is Vera and her malignant, festering lies and fear mongering. Thank you, Tom, for standing up for the truth and responsibility.
NG is the best thing that can happen for our energy situation personally, community wise, state wise, nationally, and internationally. Drill Baby Drill!
As for you Vera, once it becomes obvious that American NG development will not be stopped maybe Putin or Chavez will let you defect to their countries for the service you have done for them and their agendas. But just remember their agendas are pro-gas too, as long as it their own gas they’re promoting. Your lies and lunacy would have earned you a long visit to very inhospitable places in their countries! Just remember that just because you have the right to say something, doesn’t make it right to say it.
AND YOU’RE VERY WRONG!!!
So now go ahead Vera, call me names. I’m half Irish. Go ahead, call me half drunk. Just like Phellam. That really made you look good you know. The mark of true desperation there.
Did the court actually approve Vera’s request not to be videotaped? That could actually help a lot of people in the area. If the court agreed with Vera’s lawyers, people can now start demanding that she stop videotaping and use her own words against her. Do you have a copy of the transcript or any more information?
It was videotaped but that is not yet part of the public record. Therefore, I don’t have it.
It looks like this pair should be turned out to pasture.
Bilbo Scroggins crawled out of the shire
over a fence and soon got mired
no fracking she was heard to scream
then she pleaded it was all a dream
she jumped into her car and pressed the pedal
consuming fossil fuels is why she meddles
she went into her warm hobbit home
heated by the very gas she wishes to condone
turned on her hobbit computer and TV
run by gas generated electricity
Bilbo Scroggins was a legend in her own mind
Bilbo Scroggins still has to pay the fine
such a creative idiotic post! You must have a personal interest to protect ?
So let me ask you
do you drive a car –
do you use electricity
do you heat your home
guess what this all comes form fossil fuels – so if I understand you correctly let me summarize
you believe that obtaining fossil fuels has risk that endangers the environment
Yet you continue to use fossil fuels.
YOu dont want that risk in your back yard
You expect someone else to take the risk that you purport exists –
All so you can continue to lead your pampered life style …
does that about sum it up
this is what the definition of a self centered hypocrite is –
It’s not energy or the NG it’s the process of extraction being used to obtain it .It will never be safe or predictable and there will always be people that get hurt by it .Just one of the many negatives connected to HVHF for NG .
Someone posts a creative thought and you impugn it as idiotic and based on personal motive rather than supporting a greater good. Then you must also impugn all the factless, emotinally based anti propaganda promlugated supposedly to save the rest of us from our own ignorance and greed. If you don’t then you too are a hypocrit on that count as well.
I base my posts on almost 5 yrs of living with NG drilling all around where I live !Nothing to lie about or hide .Plenty of issues that have hurt people .Hard for people with money on their minds to go beyond this !
Vera is bad news plain and simple. Despite her best efforts in bad mouthing Susquehanna County and others in PA., though, she has not driven land values down. She managed long before Cabot stepped in to got herself barred from many of the local businesses for bad mouthing them for supporting the industry that saved many of them “The Gas Industry.”
Vera has also demonstrated that even without gas drilling she is bad news. If you haven’t seen her dancing naked while a bunch of people are eating spit and tossing their cookies “deliberately” into a box your lucky. If you haven’t seen her photo’s she posted at a nudist camp with children, which is disturbing after reading her post on touching kids in the family, to “wake them up to their own sexuality” you’re even luckier. This women is a slap in the face to all Veteran’s as when at the Afton FERC Hearing she refused to stand up and respect our American Flag while the pledge of allegiance was being said. Even with all this proof of what she is she is still the darling of the anti movement which doesn’t speak well for what kind of folks they are.
Vera won’t have to drive land values down the NG industry will do it for her.No one in their right mind wants to move into a gas land .only locals are ignorant to accept it next to them .take a survey on people who want to move to the country .
Interesting … on a recent trip down to PA near BInghamton I picked up a real estate brochure – land use to go for about 700- 1000 per acre . Now its at 5000
ONce again a confused lib – carrying a torch while complaining about air pollution hilarious
NO…Ralphey …No one with a brain wants to live in an energy field .Yes property did go up for awhile due to mineral rights ,but now it is actually going back down and in the future once it’s all drilled one one will but next to NG land ! Only locals that don’t care much .Oh by the way I’m far from a liberal ! seems you pro people always use this connection ,but then I don’t expect much different .
Awesome!
Pingback: Shale Gas Stories – Vera Scroggins « ShaleMarkets.com – Oil and Gas (O&G) Shale Supply Chain
Pingback: Fractivism Takes Something from the World's Oldest ProfessionNatural Gas Now
Pingback: Why Are Fractivists Celebrating the Demise of Upstate New York?Natural Gas Now
Pingback: Marcellus Shale Gas Rally A Stunning Success | Natural Gas NowNatural Gas Now