Jeff Heller
Steuben County, New York, Landowner
President, Steuben County Land Owners Coalition
The logic applied by Andrew King Cuomo to stop fracking in New York could just as easily and perhaps better be applied to vineyards, but we don’t want to go there, do we?
Andrew King Cuomo recently committed an act so flagrantly unconstitutional that we can be sure the founding fathers are turning over in their graves. He took away the landowners right to harvest their minerals on their property. This has largely gone unreported, or at best under reported. For the landowners, after the anger and extreme resentment recede (it will never leave ), we should try to imagine if the reaction would be the same if such a ban were applied to another group – say the vineyard owners and grape growers of the Finger Lakes, Hudson Valley and Long Island.
Imagine, if you even can, that the governor decreed no farmer could harvest a crop that contributed to the production of wine. In reality, the scientific, environmental, and health evidence would support that decree much more than it does the ban on hydraulic fracturing (or “fracking” in the now accepted vocabulary of my left wing friends).

You could make the argument that the production of grapes requires the use of all kinds of toxic chemicals – herbicides, pesticides, fertilizers, diesel fuel, etc.. In fact, more and nastier chemicals than are used in fracking. It would be beyond debate that those chemicals always run off into our streams and lakes – especially the Finger Lakes, home of my next five pound smallmouth!
There are no “pads” to contain them, and no regulations that require them to be contained on a pad. And, no regulations to collect and treat them. When it rains on a pad the water has to be contained and treated. When it rains on a vineyard the water runs off and directly into my fishing area – which no doubt explains why I catch so few five pound smallmouth!
Certainly wine causes more deaths, in fact far more deaths, than fracking. Try comparing the number of Americans killed as a result of wine drinking to the number killed by fracking. You really don’t want to go there.
You could make an argument that grape production has no positive effect on the environment (other than its CO2 sink), whereas gas production and consumption has huge positive effects. It has already taken us past our goals set in Kyoto – even though we never approved our involvement in that la la land agreement. And, burning the gas from a well produces well over twice the water that was used in the drilling process – and most of that is now recycled and reused!
We can certainly all agree that drinking wine while driving can cause serious injuries, sometimes short of death, especially when those pesky trees jump out in front of you after you have enjoyed some of the bubbly.
We can all theoretically agree then that a ban on harvesting grapes might be a good idea, using the logic of King Cuomo and his jester Howard Zucker (who apparently lives in a city where natural gas conversions have saved thousands of lives by reducing air pollution). However, it’s time for a little truth disclaimer. Having spent four years in the navy, roughly two years of that in the Western Pacific, studying the proper techniques of drinking, I have to admit that I should be the last one to oppose the production of wine.
But, then again, that’s not really what this missive is all about…is it ?
Check out what else is new at NaturalGasNow today!
While you’re at it, follow us on Facebook, Twitter and Linked-In!



Pingback: Let’s Ban Vineyards? Will King Cuomo Go There Next? | ShaleNOW
Thanks for your nice article Jeff, but you’re being far too kind to Cuomo referring to him as “King Cuomo”. He’s actually only the “Court Jester”. It’s now obvious that Sheldon Silver is Cuomo’s real handler and boss. Hopefully they both get to share a prison cell together, the sooner the better. They’d make such a cute couple!
Great take on this subject Jeff ! We need some solid research in those areas most affected by wine growers ?I get the feeling they are so phobic of NG production because they fear testing? At least we have extra time on our hands now to check some of those areas out ? The same goes for radiation levols around and under solar panels ? Maybe bird kill rates from windmills ? Just imagine the lives we can save by taking a good hard look at these industries ? We owe it to all humanity and nature to step up and defend God,s creations !
Jeff is right on, indeed, this same ban mentality could be
applied to all of farming.
Farming cuts down or has cut down thousands of trees;
farming uses water; farming deposits thousand of lbs. of
chems. of different types on the surface, not a mile or more underground;
farming chems. are not as regulated as the o&g industry.