Fracking and Tourism Growing Together in Bradford County

Fracking and tourism - Tom Shepstone ReportsTom Shepstone
Natural Gas NOW

 

Fracking and tourism, contrary to the speculation of fractivists, can and do grow together. Bradford County, Pennsylvania tourism numbers prove it.

The President visited Cooperstown a couple of weeks ago and the usual crowd of fractivists turned out to repeat the same old canards. The Catskill Mountainkeeper’s Wes Gillingham was there and used the opportunity to pontificate on the subject of fracking and tourism:

“Instead of saying if you build it they will come, what people are talking about today is if you frack it they won’t come. The president is coming here to talk about promoting tourism, and you can’t have fracking and tourism in the same region. It will ruin the economy of tourism and ruin the farming economy,” said Wes Gillingham, the program director of Catskill Mountainkeeper.

Like most fractivists, Wes feels no compulsion to offer anything in the way of argument beyond his own baseless speculation. Facts are strictly optional. Unfortunately for Wes, though, there are facts–plenty of facts–and they show the exact opposite of what he speculates.

Fracking and Tourism in Bradford County – The Real Story

Bradford County is the heart of the Endless Mountains region of Pennsylvania, a five-county area of spectacular scenery in the northeast corner of the Commonwealth. Whether it’s the Pickering Winery (or one of three others in the county), the River Barge Brewery, the French Azilum, the Troy Fair, Alpine Meadow Lakes Campground or any number of other distinctly bucolic attractions, Bradford County provides visitors with a unique tourism experience.

Fracking and Tourism BradfordCountyCampground

It’s also has more producing Marcellus Shale gas wells than any other county in the Commonwealth, some 1,086 wells in total as of the end of 2013. No county has so benefitted from its natural gas industry. The county is booming with jobs and opportunity (especially as compared to neighboring New York State) and there is even a new power plant being developed there to take advantage of the natural gas resource.

Wes Gillingham’s mindless speculation would have us believe this killed off tourism, as if a county couldn’t possibly attract visitors or have a tourism industry if it was to have natural gas development. Like most speculators, the Catskill tale spinner is full of it. He doesn’t have a clue. Rather, he’s making it up as he goes along in his efforts to deliver the land on the cheap to the wealthy scions for whom he works.

The facts, for those interested in delving into them, may be found in a report titled The Economic Impact of Travel and Tourism in Pennsylvania, prepared by Oxford Economics, which is affiliated with Oxford University. It is one of a very long series of similar reports conducted on Pennsylvania’s tourism economy to help the Commonwealth in spending its tourist promotion dollars. It evaluates tourism’s contributions to the state, regional and county economies.

Oxford Economics measured Bradford County’s tourism performance along with that of the rest of Pennsylvania using an IMPLAN model compiled for the State of Pennsylvania. This model “traces the flow of visitor-related expenditures through the local economy and their effects on employment, wages, and taxes. IMPLAN also quantifies the indirect (supplier) and induced (income) impacts of tourism.” Basic inputs come from the US Bureau of Labor Statistics and Bureau of Economic Analysis (employment and wages by industry) as well as the US Census (business sales by industry).

Here is some of what Wes might have learned had he bothered to research things before pontificating on the relationship of fracking (natural gas development for purposes of this post) and tourism.

First, Bradford County tourism took a major upswing on the advent of gas drilling. This table provides the data:

Fracking Tourism 1

We can plot the tourism spending easily to demonstrate:

Fracking Tourism 2

Yes, tourism spending is up 65% in Bradford since shale gas development began in earnest in 2009. That compares to 23% for the Commonwealth as a whole. Likewise, tourism related employment was up 31% in Bradford County as compared to 7% statewide.

When we look at where the increased spending came from based on patterns for 2011-2012, we see the growth in tourism spending in Bradford County was also across the board, throughout every category of spending, from food and beverage sales to lodging to recreation:

Fracking and Tourism 3

We also learn this tourism spending yielded an estimated $67,800,000 in labor income for Bradford County, $19,100,000 in State and local taxes and $17,400,000 in Federal taxes in 2012. Not bad for a tourism economy being “ruined” by fracking according to Wes Gillingham. Clearly, fracking and tourism can grow together, contrary to everything he said.

A Voice of Reason in an Ocean of Emotion?

Perhaps that’s why our good friend and contributor, Inge Grafe-Kieklak, reported the following when she visited Cooperstown that same day to support fracking:

We were in Cooperstown, known far and wide as an anti-fracking town, to send a pro-drilling message to Governor Coumo and the President. It did not happen in the end because the politicians came very late, after we had left, but on our way to the event, we saw a lot of support for us, even though the other side, as always, was louder (they have such big mouths). We were told by a real estate lawyer, who has clients from all walks of life buying property there, that 80% are for it. Only the trust-funders and their useful idiots are against it, he said.

A funny thing happened to me suggesting he was correct. Right near the Baseball Hall of Fame, on the steps of a business was a man with a dog. I wanted to pet this little dog and the owner said: “show me your sign, so I can tell you whether you can pet my dog and not give him a sickness.” After he saw I was pro-drilling, he said “okay, you can pet the dog.” I felt like we were the voice of reason in an ocean of emotion.

Well, that about sums it up, doesn’t it? Wes was there stirring up troops with nonsense about which he knew not a thing, making as big a wave as he could in that ocean of emotion, yet right there in Cooperstown, a hotbed of fractivism, were voices of reason who knew none of it was true, that fracking and tourism could grow side by side and that farms were being saved by shale gas development, not destroyed, as Wes would have his trust-fund allies believe. Meanwhile, gas drilling continues in Bradford County and the tourism keeps growing. Fracking and tourism…yes.

follow-us-on-twitter  like-us-on-facebook  follow-us-on-linkedin

Please share this post and get the word out everywhere!

6 thoughts on “Fracking and Tourism Growing Together in Bradford County”

  1. Dear Wes, what part of Manhattan do you come from? With the exception of Danny’s Restaurant in Walton, there are only a handful of halfway descent restaurants in all of Delaware County. For your information, there is no economy in the Southern Tier period!. Wake up and smell the GAS.

  2. This article misses a very important point about Bradford County, our tourism, and our natural gas development (fracking):

    Tourism here in Bradford County is seriously threatened today, but NOT by natural gas development. Visit the western portion of Bradford County and view the once-gorgeous Armenia Ridge. Today that former attraction is plastered with more than fifty ugly windmills, the kind so favored by the foolish fractivists. At night the red lights on those windmills, visible up to thirty miles distant, flash in unison. It’s very much akin to a mammoth, ten mile long, bordello!

    Our gas well development here, once completed, lies mostly underground. The (very) few above-ground gas lines you see are only a few feet high. They cannot be sighted at all from a distance, and they serve primarily as a resting place for passing birds.

    The ugly and unnatural windmills are hundreds of feet high and are visible to all from great distance. Far from being friendly to birds, they mutilate and destroy our beautiful Bradford County raptors, and smaller birds as well. Yet such unattractive and despicable instruments of torture as these are the choice of fractivists nearly everywhere.

    It gets worse. Because of fractivist pressure for so-called “renewable” energy sources, the windmill horror of western Bradford County today threatens to infect and destroy ridge lines all across what’s left of this beautiful county, killing still more of our raptors in the process. It’s all no big deal to the fractivist fools. The dead wildlife and the destruction of our remaining natural beauty, for them, is merely “collateral damage” as they pursue their insane goals.

    So I take some issue with this article because it is not complete. Fractivist depravity is not only about the natural gas development they oppose; it is ALSO about the ugly, unnatural, asinine, highly visible windmills they all support!!!

  3. I would like for someone smarter than me to test this hypothesis: Fracking actually drives tourism. Could it be that people from other parts of the state and country are find out how beautiful our area is because they are coming here first on business, then returning with family and friends for the fun and beauty they know is here?

  4. Pingback: Shale Markets, LLC / Fracking and Tourism Growing Together in Bradford County

  5. Amen Ben, not to mention the ugly and unsightly solar panels that cover thousands of acres of land and destroy wildlife habitat in the process.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *