Jim Willis
Editor & Publisher, Marcellus Drilling News (MDN)
The Delaware Riverkeeper is funded by the William Penn Foundation and its wealthy allies to deny middle class Pennsylvania landowners and New Jersey homeowners the benefits of natural gas so they can claim Upper Delaware land for themselves.
Even though Kinder Morgan’s Tennessee Gas Pipeline is thousands of miles long, and even though upgrades to a 200-mile section in the northeast are now complete, a federal appeals court last Friday faulted the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission’s (FERC) oversight of those upgrades. It’s yet another example of how the Delaware Riverkeeper works everyday against the interests of ordinary Delaware River basin residents, whether they be Upper Delaware landholders with the potential to rescue themselves from pastoral poverty with natural gas development, or New Jersey homeowners trying to offset the costs of higher taxes with lower heating bills. It’s a war against the middle class.
Delaware Riverkeeper Opposition to Pipelines
In 2012 FERC approved construction of five pipeline “loop” (or extra lines laid near existing lines) segments in Pennsylvania and New Jersey. The projects included upgrades at two PA compressor stations. The total project cost was $500 million and the projects together were/are badly needed to boost pipeline capacity for new quantities of Marcellus Shale gas.
But, that makes no difference to the ideologues at the petulant Delaware Riverkeeper, the New Jersey Highlands Coalition and the New Jersey Sierra Club. They sued when FERC wouldn’t re-hear their bleating and blatting. So the enviro groups took it to federal court and judges ruled last week that FERC should not have treated the projects individually when considering an approval.
Frankly, it doesn’t matter for this group of projects. All of Kinder Morgan’s northeast projects are already done and now in service. And, the decision was hardly the end of the legal wrangling.
What this decision does is send a message to other midstream companies that before they consider risking billions on pipeline projects, they need to factor in frivolous lawsuit costs and delays too–because the enviro left is willing to spend big money to force private companies to spend big money in court. An elaborate scheme to stick it to legitimate companies.

Maya Van Rossum – The always angry face of the Delaware Riverkeeper funded by the William Penn Foundation and its wealthy special interest allies at the OSI (an NRDC stepchild).
The enviros argued in federal court that the smaller Kinder Morgan projects are all part of one, big master plan perpetrated by Dr. Evil. Kinder Morgan said the projects are discrete, individual projects. The judges (a three judge panel of the US Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia) sided with the wackos and said:
“FERC’s position cannot be squared with the record, which shows that by May 2012, when FERC issued the certificate for the Northeast Project, it was clear that the entire Eastern Leg was included in a complete overhaul and upgrade that was physically, functionally, and financially connected and interdependent.”
“Given the self-evident interrelatedness of the projects as well as their temporal overlap, the Commission was obliged to consider the other three … Tennessee Gas pipeline projects when it conducted its NEPA review of the Northeast Project.”
So what happens to FERC now? Nothing. This is an empty victory for the enviros. It gives them another press release for fundraising, and that’s about it. Big whoop.
If the decision and media reaction to it interests you, MDN has assembled a “best of” selection of resources to read:
- FindLaw (Jun 6, 2014) – Copy of decison: Delaware Riverkeeper Network v Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
- Platts (Jun 6, 2014) – US FERC review of Tennessee’s Northeast Project violated NEPA: DC Circuit ruling
- NorthJersey.com (Jun 7, 2014) – Federal court faults regulators for not appraising full effect of Tennesse Gas pipeline project on N.J. Highlands
- Scranton (PA) Times-Tribune (Jun 10, 2014) – Appeals court rules regulators must reconsider Tennessee pipeline project
- Harrisburg & Philadelphia (PA) StateImpact Pennsylvania (Jun 6, 2014) – Court rules federal regulators must consider cumulative impacts of pipeline project
Disclaimer: StateImpact Pennsylvania is an anti-drilling PBS advocacy website, not a real news site.
The Feigned Anger of the Delaware Riverkeeper
Editors Note: Jim nails it as to the way the Delaware Riverkeeper operates. Their lawsuit had nothing to do with the pipeline project per se, the health of the Delaware River or even the environment. After all, this pipeline had very little impact on the river corridor and those impacts were substantially worsened by earlier Riverkeeper opposition that forced a new routing and river crossing rather than using an old one. If they had cared about the river, the scenery or the environment they would have worked to ensure the crossing was at the same and not a new location. Rather, it was all about intimidation related to future projects that might deliver more natural gas to New Jersey or New York metro area landowners.
And, why does the Riverkeeper care so much about natural gas development that would help so many? Because, it would raise land prices in the Upper Delaware River corridor where the Riverkeeper’s sugar daddy funders at the William Penn Foundation and Geraldine Rockefeller Dodge Foundation and their allies at the Open Space Conservancy, Open Space Institute (OSI) and NRDC have major designs on that land. They want that land for themselves to add to their already considerable holdings in that area at low cost and to make profitable deals with states. Higher land prices associated with natural gas development are a direct threat to those plans. These groups all have overlapping leadership and relationships, with connections back to OSI, from which New York DEC Commissioner Joe Martens hails.

OSI leader Kim Elliman (L) and former leader Joe Martens (R). The OSI is a partner with the William Penn Foundation that underwrites the Riverkeeper. Elliman is a Rockefeller family member and heads the Geraldine R. Dodge Foundation, another funder, giving him multiple ties to the Delaware Riverkeeper.
It’s a very tangled web and we have attempted to explain it several times, but it needs to be repeated often. The Delaware Riverkeeper would not exist but for the financial support of these extremely wealthy special interests. They are the ones it seeks to please and whose dirty work they do. Pennsylvania landowners and New Jersey homeowners are simply collateral damage in their war against middle class Pennsylvania landowners and New Jersey homeowners to grab as much land as possible before the prices go up from inevitable natural gas development. It’s that simple. Slowing down development of pipeline projects that make the inevitable possible is part of that strategy. It’s also what the battle over New York is all about.
For more great articles on the subject of natural gas development every single day, subscribe to Marcellus Drilling News using this convenient link.

Too bad the NY city voters fail to see how bad this is for their finances! Just imagine the prices they will be paying for energy in the future . This is a fantastic article ,too bad more consumers will not see it. I,m so fed up with all this I think I,ll go out and kill some of my trees!
freegas… I chop down 2 trees everytime I see a rerun on Bill Huston Presents…
Pingback: Shale Markets, LLC / Delaware Riverkeeper vs. the Middle Class