Cherie Messore
Public Relations Consultant
It was another day, another failed fractivist protest in Buffalo as a Facebook promoted event went flatter than the Howie Hawkins’ victory party balloons.
Nothing gets your well-worn 100% organic cotton knickers in a bunch more than feeling like you’re being lied to or challenged.
When the Park Foundation funded Food and Water Watch group in Buffalo got wind of IOGA of NY’s annual fall meeting, the group rallied its brethren and put out a social media plea for a protest. The target was the topic of the Wednesday dinner speaker, Jack Hubbard, a vice president at Berman and Co., a public relations firm behind the Biggreenradicals.org campaign in Colorado and Pennsylvania.
Hubbard’s talk, “Big Green Radicals: Winning Public Opinion, Undermining the Activist’s Credibility, and Changing the Debate” may indeed overview what his employer’s firm is doing in Pennsylvania and Colorado to do what public relations firms are paid to do: build awareness and advocate for their clients. Here’s an example of the firm’s work.
http://www.biggreenradicals.com/group/food-water-watch/
And here are some of the billboards in PA:

The Facebook invitation, which was sent by several allied forces to a few hundred frackivists and sympathizers, was indicative of the past six years’ ill-informed enviro-speak (with a few misspellings, grammar errors, and typos, too). Here’s the appeal:
The Independent Oil & Gas Association of NY (IOGA) is the chief oil and gas lobbying organization in New York, spending millions backing fracking and natural gas development in the state and opposing environmental safe-guards. IOGA will be holding their 2014 Annual Meeting in Buffalo from November 11th to 12th.
This year the keynote speaker is Jack Hubbard who lecture on “Big Green Radicals: Winning Public Opinion, Undermining the Activist’s Credibility and Changing the Debate.” Jack Hubbard works for a Washington D.C. law firm Berman & Co, who specializes in undermining the work of environmentalists. Their PR effort is entitled “Big Green Radicals.”
Last Friday the NY Times published a secretly recorded talk given by Hubbard’s colleague, Richard Berman. Besides being anti-environment, Berman is strongly anti-union.
The transcript of his talk is here:
http://tinyurl.com/BermanTalk
The NY Times article is here:
http://www.nytimes.com/2014/10/31/us/politics/pr-executives-western-energy-alliance-speech-taped.html
The oil and gas industry doesn’t have science behind them so they resort to lies and innuendo invented by highly paid law firms. Berman and Co seems to be the leader in this effort — getting millions of $$.
Our presence outside of their meeting will demand that our legislators not listen to gas industry lies! We’re calling on YOU to stand against the bull-dozing of the truth by joining us on November 12th.
Sponsors include PAUSE, the Renewable Energy Task Force of the WNY Peace Center, Western NY Drilling Defense, Food & Water Watch, and the New Yorkers Against Fracking coalition.
Key phrases to note: “The oil and gas industry doesn’t have science behind them (sic)…” Really? So what do you call studies conducted by academics from prestigious universities?
Then there’s “Bulldozing of the truth…” – Which ‘truth’ is meant, I wonder? The thousands of jobs created, the millions of dollars of royalties paid out to landowners, and the community reinvestment to significant parts of rural Pennsylvania? Perhaps it is how New York state’s enviro-politics have bulldozed its economic opportunity by a six-year delay in progress?
The other key phrase is in the title of the Hubbard’s talk: “Changing the Debate.” Other folks have been calling for a change in the dialogue for quite a while: the emphasis has been too heavy on scare tactics, emotions, and fear. Success stories aren’t headline grabbers. If we are to move away from the tradition of negative mindset, the source of the maligning needs to be exposed and a new conversation created.
As of this writing, Facebook (because if it’s on Facebook, it’s gospel of course) says a mighty force of 33 people were at the protest in the wind and rain and 38-degree temps of a Buffalo late afternoon in November. Perhaps it’s the same group that voiced its opinions at IOGA’s 2013 Annual Meeting when GOP Chairman Ed Cox was the keynote speaker. Here a few pictures of the weathered serial protestors yearning for the good old days and reliving the glory years:


Bless these passionate, if not open-minded, folks: they have their right to do this. A better use of this time, perhaps, would be to examine industry’s perspective with an open mind, and consider value benefits to landowners, business owners, and the community at large. Natural gas development is bigger than your personal opinion: the positive ramifications are much more enduring. Considering what our communities would look like without natural gas development (face it, folks, we are a dependent society now and in the foreseable future) paints a very real picture.
At the very least, for the writer of the Facebook post, ask the Park Foundation to buy you a copy of Strunk & White’s Elements of Style (Please shop at a locally-owned indie bookstore. Find one here: http://www.indiebound.org/indiesfirst), and learn the difference between “its” and “their.”
Check out what else is new at NaturalGasNow today!
While you’re at it, follow us on Facebook, Twitter and Linked-In!


Pingback: Another Day, Another Failed Fractivist Protest | ShaleNOW
One of them has it right. Cuomo listen to the science! and Just think how much lower our taxes would be if these stoners were paying taxes on their pot?
This crew is just a bunch of pot smoking burnouts from the 1960’s. Especially LoKo Ono who never complained at all when the radio active debris from Japans nuclear power plants washed up on U.S. soil. Hi-rise environmentalists is all they are.
Hillarious – “DOnt get your 100% organic cotton knickers in a bunch ‘! laughed so hard … thanks you made my morning
WOnder how those good protestors got there ? Hmm by driving CARS ? That run on … FOssil fuels !!! while wearing coats made of….oil byproducts !!!
“…from the woman who broke up the Beatles.”
Jack Hubbard, Berman and Co., and Biggreenradicals.org do themselves no favors by recycling this canard.
1) The surviving Beatles over the years have said repeatedly that Yoko had nothing to do with the breakup of the Beatles, that John and Paul were well on their way to going their separate ways quite a bit before she ever showed up. Paul has recently said that he and John were in fact planning on writing songs together again just before John was assassinated.
2) Berman and Co are wasting their clients’ money (not that the O+G industry doesn’t have tons of it to waste): based on my experience talking to local, rural people along the southern and northern tiers over 4 years, I’d say 90% of them don’t know who Yoko is anyway: somebody hasn’t been doing their market research.
“…from the woman who broke up the Beatles.”
I forgot to add: in other words, either Berman + Co are lazy, or they are willing to flat out lie in order to try to score some cheap points, which they will have trouble doing anyway because few people up there know who Yoko is.
Lying to get cheap points…… Humm sounds like another group i know.
I can help but notice, but is one of those “Concerned New Yorkers” Our resident trespasser? Second picture down holding the mic?
https://www.facebook.com/saneenergyproject/photos/a.198741756826503.50121.192933234074022/865052196862119/?type=1&theater
Something tells me that the PR wizards on the other side are way ahead on the memes. Take for instance the recent give the finger to FERC event, ahem I mean point the finger at FERC event.
http://www.eenews.net/stories/1060008360 Apparently it only takes like a week or so for some people to go from hello I never heard of the agency to I’m going to get arrested giving it the finger as I know it is a rubber stamp machine. (I’ve been hearing this for some time so yawn). Ferc is a rubber stamp machine.. like the fox guarding the hen house…inherently dangerous, all pipelines leak.. We don’t have a fracking problem, we have a democracy problem. blabbety blah.
http://www.nofrackingway.us/2014/09/29/fracking-collateral-damage-conference/ Apparently there is a very high level strategy session being held by the opposing army!! Something about collateral damage. As an Occupy puppet for directions to the session.
Have you seen any of these people wandering around holding up the You are Here google icons perhaps asking you for directions?
https://www.facebook.com/saneenergyproject/photos/pb.192933234074022.-2207520000.1415920996./864295170271155/?type=1&theater
http://www.nofrackingway.us/2014/11/04/total-of-125-arrested-protesting-infrackstructure/ As “The Chip” says it’s on. Why not get to know some of the fun folks who are like making all the magic happen!
How much longer do you think the state will be sort of held hostage by the scary threats of The David Braun for one?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AHL3gb84J7A
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nAyrYCDnBa0&index=33&list=UUbxqG2Xu0BB25_Aphkc0igQ
That is a failed fractivist protest from May 2013. This movement is a joke. How long is it going to take for people to wake up and figure this out?
Pingback: Fracking Reviews Share | Fracking Reviews Fracking – 2014-11-15 Update #4
In order to keep warm, I dare these folks to go and try burning camel dung in their respective high rise hovels this winter. Good luck with that!!!