Vera Scroggins, Vice and One Very Bad Article

Vera Scroggins - Vic FurmanVictor Furman
Upstate New York Landowner Shale Gas Activist at NYRAD-R

Vera Scroggins is lionized again in another fawning VIce article that fails to tell the true story about who these fractivists really are or their many vices. 

Recently, I came across yet another of those articles holding up Vera Scroggins, and her trial lawyer huckster ally Craig Stevens, as heroes to the fractivist camp. Alex Lotorto, who is a paid Rockefeller flack, though he’s too obsessed with playing commie to realize it, is also thrown in for good measure. Entitled “Meet the Insurgents on the Front Line of America’s Fracking War,” the Vice story treats Scroggins like some sort of Amazon female warrior. She and any her friends are anything but.

Craig Stevens

Craig Stevens and Vera Scroggins

We know Lotorto is a paid professional protestor from his association with the Energy Justice Network, financed by Earth Island Institute, which gets its money from the Rockefeller Brothers Fund. It’s all a matter of record. We know Craig Stevens is an agent for some trial lawyers out of Luzerne County, Pennsylvania and Kansas City, Missouri who are looking to cash in on fracking lawsuits.

As for Vera Scroggins, we know all about her and her history and so do most of the people in Susquehanna County.  She pretends she is working for the environment, for poor dumb farmers who don’t know what’s good for them, and loves being outrageous as a way of drawing attention to herself. She loves to push the borders of everything to ensure the cameras turn toward her and she’ll do anything to make it happen whether it’s advocating bizarre theories of child sexuality or posing for an internet photo of herself at nudist camp with large groups of other people ranging from children too young to give consent to old age.

Vera is also proud to be a vicious xenophobe, as when she posted a video of herself badgering well known commentator and documentarian Phelim McAleer with the foulest of language, demonstrating her true character. Her video (to which a counter was added to highlight her insults) and another taken by McAleer’s cameraman tell the story, but be forewarned that you should YOU SHOULD NOT PLAY THE VIDEOS IF CHILDREN ARE IN THE ROOM OR IF VULGAR LANGUAGE OFFENDS YOU.

Then, of course, there’s a disturbing video where the “insurgent” dances naked in a film called “The Vomitorium,” which is exactly where the viewer will want to go after watching it.

Peter Rugh describes this not-so-innocent individual as if she was just some ordinary American determined to fight for justice against those big evil gas companies:

The retired nurse and longtime resident of Susquehanna County offered to give me a tour of the surrounding area so I hopped in her Prius.

Scroggins, actually hails from new Jersey and moved to Susquehanna County several years ago. She uses the alias of “Vera Duerga” from time to time and when Cabot Oil & Gas took her to court for repeated trespassing (she’s now in court again because a landowner in Dimock is also charging her with trespassing), she claimed to be indigent for purposes of getting free legal help but she now drives a Prius and has time and money to travel all over Pennsylvania and New York giving tours, including bus tours for which collects small fees.

Sadly, not only Peter Rugh, but also New York State Senators David Carlucci, Cecilia Tkaczyk, Bill Perkins, Senator Tony Avella, and many other downstate politicians have joined Vera Scroggins on those magical mystery bus tours to the drilling fields of Pennsylvania.

Personally, I wouldn’t want my constituents to know I had been in the company of this woman, but lets give these shallow politicians the benefit of doubt. I don’t think any politician of New York State, especially senators from the New York City area, would willingly take a bus tour with an individual of such sordid background, but the problem is that they didn’t take the time to learn anything about her. They took the word of organizers such as Food & Water Watch that this would be a good learning experience and they had no desire to hear the other side (which was offered to them). They closed their eyes as to the credibility of the tour guide, who does not know the difference between a water separator or a blow out preventer.

They didn’t care – there was a narrative they had already bought into and they didn’t want anything to disrupt it.  Likewise, they couldn’t care less about Upstate New York and people like me who live there. You’d think they would have reached out and involved us involved in their drilling discussion but apparently we just don’t matter. Proof of that, of course, came with a ban from Governor Cuomo on December 18, when he chose junk science, false information and the word of fractivists like Vera over us. He bought the narrative assembled by Peter Rugh.

It was a surreal moment in what Rugh calls the “Fracking War.” Cuomo’s Health Commissioner talked about children he didn’t have and basically announced he had no science indicating drilling was either unsafe or perfectly safe, equivocating throughout his report and relying upon reports he claimed showed  there is little evidence that this process can be done safely at this time. It was political garbage, a hack effort to cover the tracks for a highly political decision by Cuomo. We have already demonstrated there was no science involved whatsoever.

That is the kind of policy making Vera Scroggins and the other “insurgents” advocate and the kind that results when people who should no better rely upon them as the basis for taking political action they’ve already decided upon. That’s the true story Peter Rugh had no interest in covering because he was too busy drinking the Kool-Aid himself. His stories appear on the Park Foundation funded Truth-out site and, of course, in Vice, which is run by a guy named Shane Smith who likes getting his picture taken with terrorists and laughs all the way to the bank taking advantage of juveniles.

Please share this post and get the word out everywhere!

33 thoughts on “Vera Scroggins, Vice and One Very Bad Article”

  1. Pingback: Vera Scroggins, Vice and One Very Bad Article | ShaleNOW

  2. ya know I was trying to eat lunch ..and then …and then you mention bilbo scroggins at a nudist camp – I mean really …. there are limits of what people should have to endure in a civilized society

  3. Every time the photo of her with NY representatives is published, the video of her doing the naked (sorry I did not want to view) “oh look at me” thing, should be published along side the photo. Associates are associates!

  4. Gosh I don’t think even free porn sites would want that uploaded. The viewers would want then to pay them for emotion distress and damage to you cornias lol

  5. Compare Vic Furman’s answer to a question from the excellent article on a health care study (https://energyindepth.org/marcellus/study-no-definitive-link-between-marcellus-shale-development-and-health-impacts/) to his rant here. The first helps with information we can use to add supporters to the cause and the other is just pointless name calling.

    I don’t care that Scroggins is a “vicious xenophobe” that uses “the foulest of language”. Nor do I need the cute RED CAPITAL letters to warn me either. This is old news; I saw the McAleer video long ago and her crap I’ll pass on. I stood near a few foul mouthed xenophobes at the back of the room at the Holiday Inn rally on Monday, but I don’t think they represent me or most of the people in the movement.

    What I do care about is the picture of her with 4 state legislators, two carrying what appear to be identical briefing books and one degraded enough to be holding the “brown jug”. When was the last time we had a fact finding tour for legislators and local officials? What do our policy and briefing books look like? She spreads FUD (fear, uncertainty and doubt) among the people we will need to counter home rule zoning and we respond with ancient videos. To counter her, we must expose the weakness and inconsistencies of the anti’s positions with solid facts and figures, pictures and videos, PowerPoint presentations, etc. and actively win over the majority.

    • Fact-finding tours occur on a regular basis and those specific Senators were invited on them but wouldn’t even reply to the invites, similar to Cuomo. That’s the reality.

      This site and EID and numerous other site put out factual information all the time but that’s not enough to win the day. You must also address the total lack of credibility on the other side, which Vic has done because he’s courageous.

      We have provided a huge amount of information on health issues here (see https://naturalgasnow.org/health-benefits-shale-gas-development/) over time but political arguments are never, ever won by facts alone. Logic and facts are necessary but not sufficient to do so by themselves. The key ingredient, as Pascal noted long ago, is imagination or, put another way, the emotional side – the gut feeling, if you will.

      I wish it weren’t so, but then I wouldn’t want to live in a world run by Spock, either. For truth to prevail, therefore, one needs to offer facts, logic and science while also making it clear the other side lacks those things, which we agree is the case. Calling out Vera Scroggins and others for being the frauds they are is critical in that regard. Otherwise, they gain undeserved credibility with a media crowd largely sympathetic to their views.

      You seem to have a clear idea of the sort of information you’d like to see more of, Mark, so let me make two suggestions:

      1. Please provide a list of 4-5 topics you’d like more information on to be useful in combatting the other side, and

      2. Consider writing some posts for this site yourself. I’d love to have them.

      BTW, here is something you might like:

      https://naturalgasnow.org/new-york-health-stake-shale-gas/

    • Sorry there are No inconsistencies “HVHF will NEVER be SAFE or Predictable and causes multiple nuisances that are legal matters for those living around the operations .Very consistent !!!

  6. New Jersey’s gift to the Southern Tier, a frightfully obnoxious, Vera gives new meaning to the term “Jersey Girl”. Get back on the bus Vera! Your crudeness is very embarrassing.

  7. quote from Engelder about the Gas Industry interest in your gas:
    “Even if the ban were lifted right now, I doubt you’d see very much activity,” said Penn State University geologist Terry Engelder, a widely acknowledged expert who has studied the Appalachian shales for decades. “The industry has committed so much capital in other states that they want to see that those investments are made good first.”; from :http://www.chron.com/business/energy/article/NY-fracking-ban-seen-as-having-little-impact-on-6006366.php

    • Vera, Engelder’s un-sourced numbers do not hold up to a few facts. I know you don’t care about facts, but some of the rest of us do. According to the US Energy Information Agency, New York’s dry production of natural gas in 2013 was 23,458 million cubic feet of natural gas. https://www.eia.gov/dnav/ng/ng_sum_snd_a_EPG0_FPD_Mmcf_a.htm

      Using the same source, let’s compare New York and PA production of dry natural gas (million cubic feet):

      year : ____NY________PA
      2008:___50,320____197,287
      2009:___44,849____272,574
      2010:___35,813____568,324
      2011:___31,124___1,301,661
      2012:___26,424___2,244,693
      2013:___23,458___3,232,290

      EIA data indicates (https://www.eia.gov/dnav/ng/ng_enr_dry_a_EPG0_r11_bcf_a.htm) that in 2008 the PA estimated dry natural gas contained in total natural gas proved reserves was 3,577 billion cubic feet.

      After all the gas produced in PA, the EIA 2013 estimate of proven reserves in PA is 49,674 billion cubic feet. Once PA started production, and after five years of steady increases in production, PA has (49,674/3,577) almost 14 times the proven reserves than it did in 2008.

      Tell me again why when “pipeline constraints, winter spikes in demand and other factors mean that residential customers in New York and New England pay among the highest rates in the country for natural gas” we shouldn’t develop our own resources?

      “Without fracking, New York will remain a state that consumes great quantities of natural gas but produces very little.” Sad, but true.

      And with fracking . . . . .why don’t we give it a try? Why not generate jobs, lease payments, royalties, and a major hike in local, state, and federal tax revenue?

  8. Vic so tell me who we really are ! Do you thing you can tell me I haven’t experienced and documented many issues I have seen here for the past 5 yrs .Do you deny the complaints to our useless PA DEP I have made I have never let foolish people try to stop me before so why should I let it happen now .Profiting is a good thing unless it is done by those that don’t really care about how it affects their neighbors (Dimock ,PA is an example ) .HVHF will never be a Safe or Predictable process .It is heavy industrial and bring with it industrial procedures that should be zoned only .

    • Joint Landowners Coalition of NY had their chance to make some money off their land and resources years ago and Joint Landowners Coalition proudly states they represent one million acres and over 70,000 landowners and none are leased? and how did happen? On whose advice did this whole coalition hem and haw and not accept thousands per acre and wanted more and then the market and interest closed down and they are left holding an empty bag. Meanwhile, most of my county is leased and Pa. Shale counties …..NY landowners in this coalition could have had at least the up-front money for leasing even if there would not be any drilling….and now the interest is gone…..! are you sure you still want JLCNY to represent you and inform you about what to do next…!

      • Oh Vera, each post you do only proves that the depths of your ignorance know no bounds.

        The JLCNY never existed to lease land or to negotiate leases for landowners. Look at the mission statement. It says nothing about leasing But even within the bounds of the mission statement your question as to how it could be that no JLCNY acreage are leased is one that is good to answer simply to show how irrelevant you and your insinuating question are.

        The NY landowner coalitions started forming in late 2007. As they did the leaders of those local coalitions met informally to share knowledge and ideas. One common realization at that time was that NYS was not prepared to handle what was coming and so strong leases needed to be drafted to provide the protections that NYS could not. In early summer 2008 a committee of coalition leaders representing all the other leaders met with the DEC to point out their environmental concerns. Meanwhile all leaders worked with their attorneys to draft protective and rewarding leases hoping to complete them before the gas companies completed their PA leasing and started leasing in NY. A few early land men were trolling in the area looking for easy pickings offered low ball offers and un-protective boiler plate leases. Realizing the threat these represented the coalition leaders and landowners closed ranks and for the most part refused those leases. They all agreed and planned to wait until they could counter offer with their leases and solicit competitive lease offers like the coalitions in Texas were doing in order to gain leverage. The JLCNY was not even an idea in anyone’s mind at that point, much less a formed entity that you can attempt to discredit.

        When the short sighted Governor Patterson initiated his moratorium in August 2008 gas companies were still focused on PA, not NY. Seeing this a golden opportunity the local coalitions sought to inform the DEC’s development of strong protections and proposed many of the safeguards eventually incorporated into the dSGEIS. The leaders continued to meet informally throughout 2009 with no suggestion of forming anything like the JLCNY. While no leasing was taking place landowners and coalition leaders alike appreciated the opportunity to see strong protections enacted in NY and to fine tune their leases for the day when a responsible and professional governor would approve the efforts and lift the moratorium.

        It wasn’t until December 2009 and January 2010 that the idea of transforming the informal meetings of the local coalition leaders into an actual incorporated entity quickly took hold and in early 2010 the JLCNY was formally created. It was created not to take over the local coalitions’ function of negotiating and deciding on leasing in the local areas, but rather to serve as the educational and advocacy group that no one local coalition could be on its own.

        So your pathetic attempts to cast doubt on the JLCNY is, like ALL of your anti-gas claims, baseless and laughable. Without the resources of a wealthy Park Foundation to back them they have forestalled and discredited the anti’s efforts, including yours. They are a true grass roots organization of steward landowners and REAL environmentalists. They have stood up against the wealthy progressive liberal elite that your are a useful idiot for and stood up to the Governor and his political gamesmanship influenced by those elites.

        And when the politically motivated Cuomo is either deposed or realizes the folly of his ways the moratorium will be lifted, and it will be, allowing the local coalitions to resume their efforts to secure strong, rewarding leases for their members.

        The JLCNY will fill an even greater need to educate and advocate for the safety and security of landowners. Eventually the efforts of the JLCNY will be judged by historians to be the triumph of truth and integrity over lies, fear mongering, political dysfunction, and ignorance.

        If anyone worthy of the scrutiny of failure it is you and yours. As you state yourself, most of your county is leased. To that I add it is being developed, safely and successfully. You have not been able to stop this progress. The courts have recognized the nuisance you are and ruled against you. Most of your “neighbors” detest you. Even most anti-gas activists avoid you and the few extremists (like Craig S. and Bill H.) you associated with. You live in the midst of the proof that your words and work are fraudulent and failed. But you are too stubborn and close minded to see the reality that is right outside your front door.

        It is almost ironic that you speculate about why anyone would follow the JLCNY in spite of the fact that they obviously do when instead you should be considering why no one follows you when you think they do. Your level of rationalization and denial are almost as extreme and out of balance as you are.

    • The time for giving quarter to public liars and those who ferment societal discord with baseless fear mongering is over. More people need to stand beside Vic and put people like Vera in their place. The antis deserve no respect for it is they who have disrespected their fellow citizens by lying to them in the first place. The time for misplaced civility and political correctness for bald faced liars like Vera is over. Learn this lesson fast Vera, the right of free speech does not give you the right to lie in public. What you are doing is no different than yelling “FIRE!” in a crowded theatre. Just because you think you have the right to do and say what you do doesn’t make it right Vera. Vic should be given a medal for exposing your rallies to the light of truth and facts.

    • But when you do it, its called “Cival Disobedence” and is applauded. But when it happens to you it ” interrupts “, Goes to show how you could care less about anyone other than Vera! And the double standrad that fuels your movement.

  9. Vera…. Do you think? Do you remember? Do you think you will tick people off because of me interrupting free flowing lies from Citizen’s Action which in itself is a lie. Go re read and look at the links of you in action before you begin to think any action I have done is anything as bad as your best day.

  10. It is seriously funny to see Vera trolling the Natural Gas Now boards with her manipulative twist on facts. But it is sad that the Vice article passes for journalism these days. If the slippery likes of Vera or Craig (and to a lesser extent, the cartoonish Lotorto) wanted to be a source for a story, I would first look into their background. A new Prius costs about $25k, which translates to a payment of more than $400 a month and that doesn’t include insurance (especially important for people like Vera who drive and film all the time). So how can someone who says they are a poor grandmother on a fixed income afford that? That’s one generous fixed income. Lastly, Vera has described her past life in various ways but “nurse” is a new one. If I was a reporter I would want to know why my “source” has more than one identity, where that source gets its bread buttered, and how loose is that person with facts. Apparently this Vice magazine doesn’t care about that.

    • It is a grand irony that in her attempt to be green by driving a Prius Vera is actually affecting the environment more adversely or being more hypocritical than as if she drove a traditionally gas powered auto.

      The electricity for Vera’s Prius comes from either a coal or oil burning generation plant (which depending on the plant creates emissions that are about the same as or worse than the emissions of a gas powered auto), a nuclear plant (I’m sure she’d approve of that) or a NG fired generating plant (which would make her a hypocrite).

      Of course there is the off chance she has residential wind or solar electrical generation capability. But then that exposes the poor grandmother lie even more.

      • Nothing more can be said to you all; All my exposures of Industry Harm in my county have been corroborated and seen by legislators, media, citizens by the hundreds and like good scouts they have come and seen and brought back the evidence and that is why NY is still closed to gas drilling.

        • NY didn’t ban drilling. They only banned high volume fracking. They are still allowed to drill and do low volume fracking.

    • the Team of Cabot Attorneys did a full Discovery on me and asked for all my financials and background and I showed them my fixed income of social security and divorce payments and small donations from appreciative folks who come on my tours and can see for themselves and check out whatever I say and Cabot never came back with finding anything other than what I said about my income sources; Cabot, I’m sure would have loved to find that some foundation or foreign country is supporting me. I shop mostly for myself at thrift stores and used furniture stores and I did work for about 15 years as a nurse’s aide in home health care in my county for the elderly; I do not support nuclear; I see that I must be very effective , since I get so much defamation, maligning, smearing from some of you pro-gassers who are so upset with my work of exposing the harm in my own county and community. Those who are the most effective in Pa. and throughout our country are defamed and libeled …..Stick with the facts about what why you believe gas drilling in your communities is a great thing and you don’t have to continue following me around wherever I make comments and smear me….Renewables are the way to go and will be the safest for all and affordable and green jobs wiill employ folks….I want what is the best for me and others and I see what the gas companies are hiding throughout our county and it needs to be revealed…sorry, if it upsets you….I get plenty of support and even in my county , folks call me and have to be mostly private because of their fears of being defamed by the pro-gassers…

      • Oh, Vera. What a tangled web you weave. Lets start with you finances, since you brought it up? I do believe you requested your income records to be sealed! Or are the court documents wrong? So its means nothing to tell us to look at them, when you know you already had a judge seal them!

        And speaking Judge, didn’t he recommend that both Cabot and your own lawyers, abide by their ethics code, and report any other criminal offences? No that is a VERY UNCOMMON thing for a judge to bring up at a hearing, Unless there is criminal activity!

        And third, another one of your lies exposed. You claim to be “Nurse” but then say you were a “Nurse’s Aid” which is a fancy word for behind wiper! It is a low skill, low pay, Job that people take after they have been fired form all the fast food joins in town!

        Long Island and New Jersey are now Frack Free. So please go! I will drive the bus! Real people from Susquehanna county are sick of and want you gone!

      • WHAT A CROCK OF SH_ T

        ONLY 14 OF YOUR PEOPLE SHOWED UP FOR YOUR WALK FOR CLEAN WATER AND 7 OF THEM WEWRE FROM NY. THE BADGE LIAR FITS YOU AS WELL AS YOUR OTHER TWO BADGES.

      • From Vera,”…I see that I must be very effective, since I get so much defamation, maligning, smearing from some of you pro-gassers who are so upset with my work of exposing the harm in my own county and community.”

        Don’t flatter yourself. People who work honestly and hard for what they have, like landowners, and people of truth and honor do not suffer lying fools like you readily. Your lies, like the one you included in your self-rationalization I quoted here, and the pride you take in lying are why you are not being maligned or smeared, but rather exposed for the frauds you are perpetrating.

        People who work hard to understand an issue do not readily suffer the sort of ignorance you demonstrate. For example if you really support renewables and understand what it will take for them to become reality (primarily wind and solar) you would support NG development. Transitioning from coal, oil, and nuclear will be the key to transitioning to wind and solar. You may be entitled to your own opinions, but you are not entitled to your own facts. So don’t take it as a sign of effectiveness when you are corrected for your ignorance. Unless of course the definition of effective has been revised to include “Annoying people with lies and ignorance until they no longer will tolerate such.”, for that is all you’re being effective at.

        A child who has a tantrum until his parents give a scolding is not being effective, only immature and annoying. You actions are nothing more than a tantrum and others are scolding you for your annoying immaturity, not for any effectiveness. Anecdotal tales of support from anonymous supporters doesn’t prove anything when spoken by a proven liar.

  11. Vic, believe it or not you left out a few things! Lets not forget she and her (cough, Cough) legal team asked to have her finances sealed.. Humm Wonder why? And Judge Ken also gave a cryptic reminder to lawyers on both sides to remember their obligations to report other crimes, Pertaining to some photo’s that were submitted to Cabot for evidence. And lets also not forget, her lawyer from the ACLU asked to be dismissed as her counsel. Now remember the ACLU has no problem representing the KKK, but want to distance themselves from Bilbo?

    But keep up the fight Vic! Even if your neighbors have thrown in the towel.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *