New York Pre-emption Law Argued in Appeals Court

Pre-emption Law - Tom Shepstone ReportsTom Shepstone
Natural Gas NOW

 

New York State’s plain language pre-emption law underwent its most important test on June 3 as the case was argued before the NYS Court of Appeals.

A critical important junction in the history and future of oil and gas development in New York State was reached in Albany on June 3 when the New York State Court of Appeals (the equivalent of the Supreme Court in ordinary states) heard the combined appeal of the Dryden and Middlefield cases. A lot of ink has been spilled here and elsewhere on the subject, but now it’s all over. The destiny of Upstate New York landowners awaits a decision.

One can only guess as to the outcome. New York being that strange environment where political correctness, more often than not, trumps good policy as well as the law, only a fool would predict how the court will decide. Still, the debate before the court was certainly illuminating. Moreover, our side did very well in making our case. We have, at a minimum, reason to hope common sense, plain language and the law will prevail.

The best advice I can give to any reader looking for more than that is to watch the whole thing here and decide for themselves:

Let me also point out a few things that gave me hope.

First, my hat is off to Attorneys Tom West and Scott Kurkoski, who both handled themselves with a combination of grace (an absolute necessity when dealing with impatient judges prone to interrupt at will) and a thorough knowledge of their subject.

I’ve done expert witness testimony before all sorts of courts over the last 37 years. I’ve seen many lawyer performances that not only fell short, but were downright embarrassing. I’ve also seen brilliant performances that still didn’t get the job done because the client was unsympathetic or the judge didn’t have a clue. This was different, as West and Kurkoski professionally laid out the case on behalf of both landowners and the industry. Yes, one or two judges seemed not to get it at the outset, but others asked some very penetrating questions and were tough on both sides. That’s the way it should be.

Secondly, I was encouraged by the arguments our side managed to get out on the table in the give and take with the judges. Watch from 9:50 to 11:00, for instance, as Tom West deftly gets across the fact the state, in the case of oil and gas and contrary to mining, does regulate location through well spacing standards, something with which local zoning would clearly interfere.

West also drives home that “all means all,” referring to the pre-emption law language excluding all local laws and ordinances except for a specified few. Finally, he turns around the argument frequently used by antis by pointing out the obvious. They stretch things to argue the legislature would have said “including zoning” if it meant to apply pre-emption law to it. West properly comes back by saying it would have listed it among the exceptions if it had wanted “all” to mean something other than “all.”

pre-emption lawLikewise, Scott Kurkoski, took the opportunity, at 12:10, to insist on getting out a point often ignored; the fact the well Jennifer Huntington planned to drill on her farm in Middlefield was a conventional one already allowed under state regulations, that right having been taken away from her by a town ban that would exclude many other legal activities from the entire town as if they were nuisances even though they represent state policy.  That threw a monkey wrench into the idea the battle is somehow about hydraulic fracturing, forcing the judges to think a bit (I hope).

One of the judges was clearly thinking and at 14:09 he gave Kurkoski an opportunity to expand on West’s earlier argument about location vis-a-vis spacing standards. That was a good dialogue, too, and all the right points were expounded upon.

Listen, also, at 16:44 as Kurkoski makes an extremely important point; that no other state in the country has used mining law to interpret oil and gas policy and using the Frew Run case to do so in New York would make a horrible mess of things because mining and drilling are two different things requiring different pre-emption law. That was a great moment in the debate. The discussion continued for several minutes and was excellent.

My third reason for believing there is some hope of prevailing lies in the generally poor performance of the other side, starting at 23:40. Deborah Goldberg, counsel for the thoroughly disputable EarthJustice group (which tried and failed to stop the Marc-1 Pipeline with a petition signed by over 20,000 people from outside the affected area) was abysmal.

Goldberg was immediately challenged by the justices with questions about “what could could be more express than the plain language of the pre-emption law” and why the legislature didn’t mention zoning if it didn’t mean to exclude it. The judges queried her, too, as to why a ban wasn’t a regulation and offered many more fine challenges. She handled them poorly, I thought, and ended with a bizarre discussion about the ability to drill under towns that prohibited fracking. It couldn’t have made her clients happy. Watch it all, please.

pre-emption law DrydenAttorney John Henry represented the Town of Dryden (40:50). He comes from a great firm with whom I’m currently working on some other projects. Therefore, I’ll let others evaluate his performance, but it is worth noting his arguments (and Goldberg’s) were of an esoteric lecturing nature and by that I mean they stretched the suspenders of their arguments on pre-emption law so far they broke, dropping their pants to the floor and exposing what wasn’t there.

One of the justices was, in fact, moved to ask “does the plain language of the pre-emption law allow us to dig as far as we are here?” Exactly! The Henry and Goldberg argument may be summed up as “the plain language of the law means the opposite of what it says.” They want to convert a pre-emption law into an authorization of what it is pre-empted, by turning it inside out. It’s the maddening kind of reasoning that makes ordinary people hate lawyers until they want a loophole of their own, of course, and why we’re in so much trouble these days as laws are interpreted away one by one using such logic. Only judges can halt it.

That’s really the heart of the case. Does the pre-emption law mean what it says? We know our side put on an excellent case. We’d like to think it does mean what it says. I also have hope the judges will agree. Will they? Or, are they from the school of “it depends on what the mean of ‘is’ is”? You be the judge.

follow-us-on-twitter  like-us-on-facebook  follow-us-on-linkedin

Please share this post and get the word out everywhere!

3 thoughts on “New York Pre-emption Law Argued in Appeals Court”

  1. If or when this ends, can this go to the Supreme court? Though I have confidence in this state,s judges it seems likely this whole mess will drag on for a long time? And the anti bowl movement will not end until all coal is burnt and all the Pursion Gulf oil is pumped and shipped. Another thing i was wondering is can forever green include oil and gas? Any lawyers out there that have an opinion? It just makes sense to me that it would be a good way to keep these minerals out of the hands of those that paid to steal them ? Anyone out there have any ideas?

  2. Pingback: Shale Markets, LLC / New York Pre-emption Law Argued in Appeals Court

  3. Pingback: NY Home Rule Decision: All About the Meaning of "All"Natural Gas Now

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *