Johnny Williams
Freelance Journalist
Pennsylvania Governor Tom Wolf’s “Jobs That Pay” promise is being undermined by regulations and proposed taxes that are destroying existing “jobs that pay.”
Pennsylvania Governor Tom Wolf seems to be developing a rather unsettling habit as his term gets further underway. It’s been touched on before how Wolf seems to view the economic benefits of the shale gas industry as an enemy to education and how the industry doesn’t pay its “fair share,” despite its actual devotion to education, but what is becoming more disconcerting is Wolf’s handling of issues from the state budget to business development.
For starters, Wolf is already perturbing lawmakers with how he sets up campaign-like events at schools, making kids look like victims, to promote his budget, instead of actually meeting with them to make real progress. State Representative Warren Kampf told the Times Herald this:
“I’m disappointed that the governor used Phoenixville Middle School as a backdrop while he spoke in platitudes about education without explaining what the actual costs of his massive proposed tax hikes would be on the people of Phoenixville”
Granted, there are several big issues that are involved with the state budget, but perhaps none affects businesses across rural Pennsylvania as much as the severance tax, and as an extension, Wolf’s stance towards the natural gas industry. While he’s not trying to ban natural gas per se and give flat “no” to any of the economic benefits of the industry, his policies are effectively serving to chase it out, bringing into question his “Jobs That Pay” shtick.
Among the businesses that Wolf’s position is laying doubts on is Shell’s proposed ethane cracker plant in Beaver County, according to this TribLive post. The plant represents thousands of jobs for western Pennsylvania and would attract new businesses. Here’s Marcellus Shale Coalition President David Spigelmyer:
“I sat in a meeting with Gov. Wolf in August, where leadership from Shell looked the now-governor directly in the eye and said, ‘If you jeopardize the ethane supply, we likely don’t invest here,’ ”
Wolf keeps assuring us he “wants the industry to succeed,” according to his spokesperson in the article, yet he continues to deny the industry will leave the state because of a severance tax, despite several natural gas companies such as CONSOL Energy, Range Resources, and Shell cutting jobs already amid low prices. Companies don’t cut jobs in an attempt to bluff. Here’s the reality:

Among other things that brings Wolf’s supposed support of the industry into question is the Task Force on Pipeline Infrastructure Development, which already had to rescind an invitation that it had sent to a known fractivist. This doesn’t really help much considering acting DEP secretary John Quigley is the task force’s chairman, who has a history as an environmental activist.
To take it further, now Wolf’s former Chief of Staff, Kathleen McGinty, is running for the Senate. McGinty has an extensive environmental history throughout her career, serving as Chair of the White House Council on Environmental Quality and later as VP for Asset Management for Natsource LLC, an environmental asset manager. She also led the Pennsylvania DEP under former governor Ed Rendell. After that, she worked for several renewable energy companies as well as a geothermal company before serving as an “expert” on President Obama’s shale gas advisory task force.
As such, energy has almost always been present in McGinty’s career, which might explain why fractivists don’t like her very much. Still, her support of Wolf’s severance tax raises some red flags based on the earlier points of this post. If it gets passed, it would likely serve to strengthen her cause to unseat the more pro-energy Senator Pat Toomey by appealing to the areas of her hometown in northeast Philadelphia, which would be among the main beneficiaries of a severance tax while driving out funds and jobs brought to the majority of Pennsylvania by the natural gas industry.
Couple McGinty’s renewable energy career with Wolf’s endorsement of the EPA Clean Power Plan, for which a plan is being developed by none other than the Quigley-led DEP, and Pennsylvania’s status as a booming natural gas producing state looks to be in jeopardy. It’s about to turn into a money pit for costly renewables that put out a fraction of the energy needed.
While it is certainly not lost on me that some see natural gas a big winner under the Clean Power Plan, and by all means I hope that assessment is correct, it is beginning to not look that way for Pennsylvania, as the NRDC seems to be quite happy (here and here) with giving away “incentives” in exchange for the jobs from the evil natural gas industry. Never mind how much cleaner natural gas is compared to other fossil fuels and how much energy is generated from a much lesser environmental footprint compared to renewables.
And, all of this is on top of Wolf’s proposed severance tax which earmarks part of the tax to fund solar and wind projects; essentially taking money from energy companies and giving it to their competitors. One has to wonder how he can support “Jobs That Pay” while driving out one of the biggest job creators in the state in the natural gas industry.


Johny, as a freelance reporter how about doing a peice on how many other energy rich nations are letting their production be pressured by importing energy?
Another thing that might make a good article would be how much import tax is being collected on that imported NG and crude oil?
Maybe you could look into the pipe infrastructure designs of other nations too?
Tom wheres Racheal? I miss her articles, how about everyone else?
ALL NY OR NONE-Only Wall Street benefits from turning NY into a big energy import hub!
Sadly, Rachael’s mother recently passed away. I am hoping we’ll be able to get her back to writing for us in the future.