Tom Shepstone
Shepstone Management Company, Inc.
Another Slottje drafted natural gas moratorium has bit the dust, this one in Sidney, New York, where Judge Lambert just ruled landowners have rights after all.
David and Helen Slottje, the dollar story lawyers from Ithaca, are perhaps two of the most arrogant individuals out there among the natural gas opposition. They have been shilling for the Park Foundation over the past two years in their special interest campaign to subvert natural gas development in upstate New York, while parading as public servants of a sort. I have written about them numerous times, including their outrageous bullying tactics and their dubious legal theories on process, which were dispensed with in short order in the Binghamton case.
Now, they’ve lost again in Sidney, New York, where, once again, their advice on how to short-cut procedure to enact a moratorium was just shredded by a judge who didn’t buy their creative thinking.
The Sidney Lawsuit Over A Slottje Moratorium
Readers will recall a guest post on this blog by Inge Grafe-Kieklak, a Delaware and Sullivan County, New York, landowner who brought suit against a Slottje engineered moratorium enacted by the Sidney, New York, Town Board. The suit included a number of complaints alleging the moratorium was:
”jurisdictionally defective because the Sidney Town Board failed to perform non-discretionary duties under… the General Municipal Law (§239-m), the Town Law (§265), and the Town of Sidney Zoning Ordinance (§1600)” – in other words, it did not follow prescribed procedures for legal adoption, including the legal requirement of passage by a “supermajority” vote (in this case, by four of the five members of the town board), where, as here, the county planning board recommended disapproval and a “protest petition” was signed by owners of more than 20 percent of town landowners;
Judge Lambert found the requirements of the General Municipal Law (§239-m) had been met because the Delaware County Planning Board failed to provide its disapproval letter within the prescribed time period. He sustained the other two challenges and one of these, the Town Law (§265) one, is absolutely fundamental to the whole debate over moratoriums.
As Inga noted, Town Law § 265 says the following (emphasis added):
Such regulations, restrictions and boundaries may from time to time be amended. Such amendment shall be effected by a simple majority vote of the town board, except that any such amendment shall require the approval of at least three-fourths of the members of the town board in the event such amendment is the subject of a written protest, presented to the town board and signed by:
(a) the owners of twenty percent or more of the area of land included in such proposed change; or
(b) the owners of twenty percent or more of the area of land immediately adjacent to that land included in such proposed change, extending one hundred feet therefrom; or
(c) the owners of twenty percent or more of the area of land directly opposite thereto, extending one hundred feet from the street frontage of such opposite land.
The provisions of the previous section relative to public hearings and official notice shall apply equally to all proposed amendments.
A three-fourths vote (four members of the board) is demanded to overrule a protest petition under Section 265. This was the first time a local gas drilling moratorium or ban hab been challenged under the Town Law 265 “protest petition” procedure and here is how Judge Lambert ruled (emphasis added):
Petitioners assert that Everett J. Wood presented a Town Law §265 protest petition on February 14, 2013 to the Town Board thereby invoking the super-majority provisions of Town Law § 265. The protest petition contained the signatures of 107 owners of record of property in the Town of Sidney (excluding the Village) collectively accounting for 8,069.07 acres – 26.1 percent of the total land acreage of the Town (excluding the Village). This is in excess of the twenty percent or more of the land acreage (6, 186.2 acres) required to trigger the super-majority override requirement of Town Law §265. Accordingly, the super-majority provisions of Town Law § 265 were properly invoked by Everett J. Wood’s act of filing the protest petition before the Town Board prior to the vote on Local Law Number 1 of 2013. Given that the Town Board only approved this law by a bare majority vote, said law was not properly enacted (see Matter of Eadie v. Town Bd. of Town of N.Greenbush, 7 NY3d 306 [2006]; Van Patten v. La Porta, 148 AD2d 858 [3d Dep’t 1989]).
Lambert also ruled the Town of Sidney had failed to follow its own Zoning Ordinance in adopting the moratorium, having not referred the matter to the Town Planning Board as required under §1600 of that Zoning Ordinance.
Some Justice for Landowners
The referral decision is not nearly as important, however, for the Town Board could easily correct that error be reenacting the moratorium after referral. It cannot correct the §265 problem, though, because the petition that was filed was determined valid and, after that, the law speaks for itself; four votes were required and the Town Board didn’t have four votes. It’s as simple as that, Judge Lambert being a Joe Friday, “just the facts” sort of guy.
The implications of Lambert’s decision, nonetheless, are nothing less than huge. They insert a dose of justice into a process that has been corrupted by the insertion of special interest politics into what should be objective policy making. The rights of landowners have, too often, been sacrificed on the altar of political correctness with Park Foundation funded lawyers performing the ritual removal of the beating hearts from those unlucky enough to possess property. Section 265 of the Town Law is intended to ensure the rights of property owners who might be a minority are not trampled upon by a mob that happens to be in the majority at any given time. It says, as a practical matter, that something greater than a simple majority is required if the common law rights of the minority are to be taken away from them.
The successful deployment of §265 against the tyranny of municipal boards captured by special interests provides a powerful tool with which to fight bans and moratoriums and that is the big news from Judge Lambert’s decision. If you live in a town considering a ban or moratorium on natural gas development, then organize your landowners against it. You can prevail. That is the lesson.
It wasn’t necessary for Lambert to rule on the other challenges made to Sidney’s law after finding it had been enacted improperly and he didn’t but the §265 decision was more than enough to cheer about. It’s also a reminder of what happened in Binghamton when Judge Lebous ruled the Slottje strategy was all but subterfuge. David Slottje, prior to that decision, had bragged “nobody here has met anybody who can draft as well as we can” and referred to his then expected success with his Binghamton handiwork a “no-brainer.” Judge Lebous thought so, too, on both counts, but for far different reasons. The decision, which was an embarrassment for Slottje, was appealed but that appeal has now been withdrawn, meaning the Binghamton decision is now law and numerous similar moratoriums are vulnerable.
Slottje has similar visions of grandeur in the Sidney case, telling Town Board members he was “very confident that both the law and the facts are on the Town’s side, and so fully expect that the Town will prevail in this matter.” Just to further reassure the Town he said “If for any reason the Town does not prevail (that is at the trial court level) we are rock-solid that it will prevail upon appeal.” Well, that’s basically what he told Binghamton and everyone else between Binghamton and Sidney, but two judges have now said Slottje seems to know not nearly as much as he would have us all believe about New York land use law. Twice, his recommendations on process have been thrown back in his face and, twice, his interpretations have been proven faulty.
How much longer will municipalities take this guy seriously? One hopes it’s not long. Thank goodness, there are people like Inga who aren’t intimidated by the Slottje “lawyer up, big guy” threats; people who have been willing to challenge his bad advice. It has been very bad advice, indeed, for Binghamton and Sidney. That advice has been bought and paid for by the Park Foundation, which has always had its own agenda. Now, perhaps, some who have foolishly accepted their “free” help will finally understand that selling your soul to these people can be very costly. That’s the other lesson of Sidney.



Slottje’s
Isn’t that the guy selling hotdogs from his backyard fundraisers to raise “GAS MONEY” HOW FRACKING IRONIC !!!!
Congratulations Inge!
We beat Slottja in the town of Oxford. Now he has gotten his ass kicked in Sidney. Binghamton finally has a mayor with a brain.
Slottja is everything EID has exposed. The true meaning of bottom dweller. This crew actual elevated ambulance chasers.
I will give him credit for scamming a foundation of elite that needs a lesson on better use and over site of their funds.. You would think those in charge of the foundation would be knowledgeable enough to not fall for dime store hoods. Any foundation that has supported and endorsed this sad act should fire the committee that approves funding.
Think about the amount of money that could have gone to something useful like St Judes. At the very least creating habitat for the northeastern Box Turtles.
Pingback: Another Slottje drafted natural gas moratorium has bit the dust in New York - ShaleNOW
So who paid this guy? If it was taxpayers, do they get their money back? If it was the Park Foundation or any other non-profit, can they be forced to pay the court costs taxpayers incurredfighting for their lawful rights?
I have not seen the actual decision, but I’m sorry that Judge Lambert did not rule on the Commerce Clause challenge. Perhaps that’s too hot a topic and may be out of his area of expertise, but an affirmation that such moratoria violate the US Constitution would have been a very welcome decision. Still, between this decision and the end of the Binghamton moratorium it’s a good day for landowners.
Helen Holden, aka, Helen Slottje will be on the Bob Josepth Show tomarow at 9:15 an She will no dobt say they didn’t lose … Lisen in on 1290am radio and call in to voice your opinion 606- 772-1290
Say what you want about Slottje, but he helped Butternuts get a ban on fracking….so he’s good in my book.
And, it’s probably not defensible if you are challenged. That’s the cost of “free” advice from special interests.
I’m happy to rely on the attorney’s expertise over the gas industry’s
public relation’s expertise.
I don’t think I’d bet on a “free” lawyer bought and paid for by special interests.
Aren’t you, as an employee of a gas lobbying company, “bought and paid for” by “Gas Interests?”
I am not an employee of anyone but myself and I do not do lobbying. I do consult with the industry and consider myself an advocate. I was also an advocate long before I was paid by anyone and I didn’t pretend to be doing pro bono work while advocating.
He’s from Butternuts… Butternuts, A place Homer Simpson would laugh at forever mentioned
The Slottje’s and all those who support them (Park Foundation) are nothing more than money grubbers. Inspection of Slottje’s website http://www.cedclaw.org/ indicates that these two have not one, but TWO places dedicated to making donations to him and his wife in the upper right corner of the homepage! Pro Bono my eye! They had both better shed some pounds as I’ve heard that the ambulances in the area move pretty fast!
Pingback: No Joy In Fracking Mudville! - Natural Gas Now
Well, Tom, excuse me for the misstatement. I should have said that your company is contracted by the gas industry and that your pay is dependent on your ability to rabble rouse the “little guy” – keep him fighting for the gas companies, keep him fighting his neighbors, keep him introducing turmoil into his communities. On the surface,it appears that Slottje is a gentleman in comparison since his efforts are centered in the courtroom.
David Slottje is the gentleman? Anyone who has read this knows otherwise:
https://energyindepth.org/marcellus/a-tree-falls-in-lumberland/
By the way, why don’t you identify yourself, so we evaluate your connections and interests, Butternuts?
I am one of those little guys; a small landowner who, even if gas drilling comes to NY will never make the ‘fortunes’ that so many of those opposed to drilling claim that I am after. I don’t fight against my neighbor, I fight FOR myself and my rights that have been granted me by the US and NY State constitutions. I fight AGAINST our dithering, bigoted supposed governor, who is so constipated by fear of not winning re-election by a landslide that he cannot make a decision either for or against drilling. I find his inability to make a decision reflective of a major character flaw that renders him unfit for any public office. As to Slottje, he is no gentleman; search for his “Lawyer up” comments that have been well-publicised. He’s a grandstanding, self-serving pompous shill for the Park Foundation (by his own admission). Indeed, I believe he is skating on the edge of ethical violations with some of his unprofessional comments and actions.