John Dunham
John Dunham & Associates, GuerrillaEconomics
The Keystone XL pipeline has not happened for the same reason fracking hasn’t happened in New York – crony capitalism by big business and big green.
Train train, comin’ ’round, ’round the bend. Train train, comin’ ’round, ’round the bend. Well it took my baby, but it never will again – Never will again. The 1953 Junior Parker song was written by Mr. Parker and Sun Studios founder, Sam Phillips and recorded on the label in Memphis Tennessee. This blues standard has been recorded by everyone from Elvis to Grace Potter and was even performed by The Band in the Last Waltz documentary. Today there is a new mystery train, one operated by billionaire investor Warren Buffett that competes with pipelines like the proposed Keystone XL recently rejected by the Democratic majority in the Senate.
Billed as a means to ship so-called dirty oil from oil sand fields in Alberta to refineries on the US Gulf Coast, the Keystone XL is designed to be one of many pipelines carrying crude oil from fields across the country to oil refineries located in specific areas. Most importantly, the Keystone XL will traverse the area of eastern Montana and western North Dakota where the Bakken shale oil fields are located. This region is home to some of America’s key oil producing fields, and where the growth in the US petroleum industry is concentrated.

Unfortunately, it is also a sparsely populated area with no major oil refining operations. The closest refineries to the Bakken fields are actually located in Minneapolis and Denver, and only the Denver refineries are connected by pipelines to North Dakota. To get oil from wells in North Dakota to refineries, one must generally use rail cars, and the railroad of choice is Buffet’s Burlington Northern.
According to a recent article published by Sandy Fielden at RBN energy it costs upwards of $10 more per barrel of crude to ship oil out of the Bakken by rail rather than pipeline (to Cushing Oklahoma) and shipments to refineries in Minnesota are costing about $15 per barrel (again about $10 more than pipelines would cost). These costs work their way through the production process and make everything from driving, to flying to heating homes more expensive.
In addition to this, the demand for rail cars to move oil has hampered the ability of other industries to receive reliable freight rail service. Across the economy, in industries as varied as steel production to wheat and soybean farming, the inability to receive reasonable and timely rail service has led to increased operating costs and lower profitability.
Keystone is not the only reason why this has happened. In fact, the nation’s infrastructure just was not ready to deal with the massive growth in petroleum production over the past decade. It is faster and less expensive to create new rail terminals and use rail-as-pipeline shipping options in the short term. Pipelines have been developed to move more oil out of the Bakken to refineries in Denver and on the West Coast, and new refining capacity has been added in Wyoming, Montana and North Dakota. Still, the stalled Keystone pipeline – which would directly serve the large fields in western North Dakota – would greatly help alleviate the existing bottlenecks.
What does the country receive for this increased cost? Not much. While the President and certain environmental fronts have suggested that the pipeline might lead to environmental damage, the fact is that existing pipelines already criss-cross the areas where Keystone would be built. In addition, it is dramatically safer and more environmentally friendly to move oil by pipe than by rail.
The bottom line is that in politics it is always important to follow the money. While the construction of more pipelines, including Keystone XL will benefit consumers, agriculture, and manufacturing, it will cost the BNSF railroad a large captive market. While Mr. Buffett feigns support for the pipeline, he is really the one who benefits most from its delay. He is also one of the Administration’s largest campaign contributors. It’s not a mystery why Keystone is being delayed nor is a mystery why American’s do not trust the government.
Editor’s Note: Readers of this blog will identify with the crony capitalism that stands as an obstacle to the Keystone XL, because it’s the same sort of thing the NRDC is practicing in New York State and the Delaware River basin and why it fights fracking. No, the NRDC is not a capitalist group per se, but its leadership consists of some very greedy folks who like their ostentatious lifestyle in the Catskills and the sweetheart land deals they regularly enter into with the State of New York, allowing them to profit in myriad ways, not the least of which is to expand their very private exclusive domain at low cost.

Kim Elliman – the $450,000 CEO of the Open Space Institute
They also earn some great salaries, Christopher “Kim” Elliman, the Rockefeller descendant who runs the NRDC sister entity, the Open Space Institute, and who, together with the OSI’s ally, the William Penn Foundation, helps fund the Delaware Riverkeeper’s dirty tricks, earned a cool $450,188 according to the organization’s 990 return for 2013. That represented 9.4% of OSI’s revenue and was up almost $67,000 over 2012, a whopping 17.4% increase. He’s also associated with the Doris Duke Charitable Foundation, one of Josh Fox’s funders.
OSI expenses totaled $6.8 million, which was $2.0 million more than revenues, so it wasn’t a great year. Nonetheless, the “Charity Navigator 2014 Charity CEO Compensation Study” indicates charities of $3.5 to $13.5 million paid a median of only $148,659 in CEO compensation, so Kim earns three times the average doing crony Buffett-like deals in New York. Higher land prices from fracking would threaten all of that, just as the Keystone XL threatens Warren’s trains.
Imagine what pressure and influence these people bring to bear on Andrew Cuomo and you have a good idea why fracking has made so little progress in the Empire State. It is a crony capitalist empire, but, to make matters worse, the emperors wear green non-profit hats that hide what’s happening.
Check out what else is new at NaturalGasNow today!
While you’re at it, follow us on Facebook, Twitter and Linked-In!



Pingback: Keystone XL Faces Crony Capitalist Opposition | ShaleNOW
I was in fact listening to Mystery Train from the Band a few minutes before I read your post! In addition to The Band, Paul Butterfield was featured. They use they version “rollin’ round, round’ around the bend” As to WB, when he bought eight trains two years ago for the Bakken enterprise, it was obvious that he called Obama and told him that he needs to amortize his purchases, so don’t let the pipeline through, even though it is akin to slapping one of our oldest and dearest allies in the face. I have lost most all respect for ‘ol Warren when I read about this particularly mendacious move against America and its energy infrastructure all for crony capitalism at its finest.
Same here. I can’t stand the guy. He tries to come off as this mild-mannered middle of the road guy when he’s just a huge crony capitalist (and I’m a fan of real capitalism). His position on the estate tax is also self-serving but that’s a story for another day.
What an astute businessman Warren Buffett is, he has learned the easy way, just pick up the phone and call the “fixer.” Business he is not, shyster is more like it.