Fracking Hazards? Are You Kidding?

Fracking Hazards - Tom Shepstone ReportsTom Shepstone
Shepstone Management Company, Inc.

The recently issued sham health report out of New York was illustrative of much of what we here about fracking hazards – all speculative – but what the inconsistency?

Claims of fracking hazards invariably descend into speculation. Howard Zucker’s report was the pitch-perfect example, of course, with 82 “could,” 70 “maybe,” 31 “possible” and 9 “might” statements. It’s also the standard M.O. for all fractivists when they’re not just lying.

This speculation also produces some incredible inconsistencies in thinking, not to mention factual errors. A November letter to the Elmira Star-Gazette opposing Crestwood Midstream’s storage projects in Watkins Glen, described them as the storing of “explosive gases – the byproducts of fracking.” David Crea has already corrected the record to explain propane is not explosive, but there’s a much bigger issue; gasoline is explosive and we store it everywhere and some fractivists even ride rolling bombs powered by the stuff to protest rallies.

Most readers of this blog are already familiar with the phony protests of Crestwood Mistream’s projects and the stories of mostly out-of-town protesters getting arrested to attract some media attention for their opposition to both the propane and natural gas storage projects under consideration there.

Fracking Hazards - Schuyler Propane Use

What’s more than odd is that they’re trying to block a propane storage and distribution facility when propane is Schuyler County’s most used home winter fuel as the chart above (derived from Census data) demonstrates.

And, even odder, is the fact they aren’t also trying to block gasoline deliveries to gasoline storage facilities and gas stations. Gasoline is flammable and explosive, bad for the ground water if spilled, comes from hydrofractured wells and is a fossil fuel. (All the charges they level against propane.) What’s the difference? Why do they feel comfort driving gasoline powered vehicles to protests? Why re they tolerant of gasoline service stations? Why are there no protests of gasoline storage and use?

What’s even stranger is trying to stop the associated gas storage facility, when it allows winter heating demands for natural gas to be met by fewer wells and smaller pipelines. Otherwise, extra wells would be needed to access energy supplies when demand spikes. Storage facilities allow us to accumulate supply for heavy demand periods when we can then just pull the gas out of storage. So, the net effect of any success they may have stopping the gas storage facility there would ultimately be more gas wells being drilled – the opposite of what they claim to want. There’s no logic in that, either.

What is it that accounts for these logical inconsistencies? Why do fractivists fight natural gas and gas storage, but not gasoline, heating oil, jet fuel and their storage facilities and pipelines? Why do they engage in protests that, ultimately, serve no purpose in achieving their end goal? There are only two possible answers from a big picture perspective. Either they are disingenuous or they are uninformed.

It’s not hard to believe they are a lot of misinformed people out there. Most of us are intellectually lazy at heart, after all. We dig into subjects that interest us whether they be football, history, science or something else, but the mundane tends to produce a “whatever” attitude from us that blocks real thinking about things such as risks.

fracking hazards car2

We are prone to accepting what we’ve always done (e.g., drive around in vehicles powered by some of the most explosive stuff there is) while hyperbolizing about the danger of far safer things to which we aren’t so accustomed. We fear flying in airplanes but think nothing of hopping into vehicles that kill several times as many of us, relatively speaking, because we know and think we control circumstances in the one case and do not in the other.

Still, leaving aside the NIMBY problem, most of us are capable of being rational when the facts are presented. We are not, as a nation, so paralyzed by fear of risk that we cannot act (although New York State is a special case, it appears). That leaves us, then, with only the second explanation; that proponents of irrational fear in things such as propane and natural gas storage are disingenuous and motivated by other things and they are. As we’ve noted here many times, the relatively small group of protestors out there are financed, supported and manipulated by special interests who have larger objectives and would like nothing more than Upstate New Yorkers to remain in pastoral poverty as their serfs. Gas Free Seneca, Sandra Steingraber and Walter Hang are all tools of those entities.

It’s all about control, in other words, and the goal is to ensure Upstate New York is firmly under the direction of those who, well, want to set its direction for it. They have utopian ideas about ending fossil fuel use (except for their own use), crowding us all into cities, using the country as their own playground and directing it all from on high. The last thing they want is self-empowered upstaters with economic resources of their own.

Stopping natural gas development or anything that might interfere with the grand scheme, therefore, is crucial to them. They cannot openly advocate for such desires nor can they hope to convince everyone to halt all fossil fuel use, as that would set off alarm bells with rational commoners who realized what it meant. So, they focus on particular projects with an element of the unknown involved and an outside corporate face that can be painted evil. It’s a proven template that stunts progress and allows sidestepping of the logical inconsistencies.

Is this what’s happening in the case of the natural gas and propane storage projects in Watkins Glen? It appears so. There is no logical reason to fear the facilities but they offer a convenient target for special interests intent on shaping Upstate New York in their own image and there are plenty of willing dupes to do the dirty work. So, we hear about the fracking hazards that aren’t and the explosive propane that isn’t while everyone ignores the much greater risks we are willing to accept every day. Will it continue? For a while, it appears, but not too long because facts and progress are hard to suppress, which takes us back to 1830 and the birth of railroads in Victorian Britain:

Thundering along at previously unimaginable speeds, early steam locomotives were a frightening prospect for their Victorian passengers. Before the opening of the first major railway line, the Liverpool & Manchester in 1830, there were fears it would be impossible to breathe while travelling at such a velocity, or that the passengers’ eyes would be damaged by having to adjust to the motion.

Little more than 20 years later, their fears allayed, people flocked to this exciting new form of transport, and by mid-century, millions were dashing across the country on tracks stretching thousands of miles. From professional football and the Penny Post to suburban living and seaside excursions, the railways changed the face of Victorian Britain.

There have been similar fears over every conceivable new technology or economic improvement and the fear-mongerers have seldom won in the end. I don’t expect them to win this time either.

fracking hazards Manchester MOSI

Check out what else is new at NaturalGasNow today!

NGNlogoNew

While you’re at it, follow us on Facebook, Twitter and Linked-In!

Please share this post and get the word out everywhere!

6 thoughts on “Fracking Hazards? Are You Kidding?”

  1. Pingback: Fracking Hazards? Are You Kidding? | ShaleNOW

  2. Well the question of whether they are disingenuous or ingorant should also be framed additionally with Or Both ? If one had absolute power over what energy sources we used and the used the ones with the fewest deaths per Gigawatt we would not be using Wind or Solar . Counterintuitive to the environmentalists we would be using shale gas and nuclear. Annually an average of 140 wind turbine workers die in accidents on the work site globally . I believe workplace deaths in the mercellus annually does not even break ten.140 deaths annually in wind turbines dwarf s the entire Nuclear industry’s 50 year plus history where the only major multiple death incident at Chernobyl was in the tens of deaths.
    Frackivists forward impossible trial balloons which would require homicidal processes by Energy companies and Governments to occur in concert . This is why Gasers realize the other side has been successful to a degree in forwarding totally irrational fears to many irrational people . Remember we actually have those who believe september 11 2001 was an inside job and that Steel columns in skyscrapers cannot possibly melt !!!! The age of the internet video has actually made the proffering of the ridiculous easier to spread. If one is in fear of explosive gases you would also have to eliminate batteries for solar and wind energy storage as lead acid batteries have explosive energy potentials due to hydrogen build ups in the process. Where is the irrational fear mongering of Hydrogen in your part of the country considering the explosion of the Hndenberg in Lakehurst New Jersey is inblazened in our minds and on a Number of Led Zeppelin album covers .

  3. You’re right Tom. These self declared New York City “environmentalists” are the biggest users of everything that they are railing against. Ironically, none of them are Southern Tier Landowners yet, and none of them ever intend to be Southern Tier Landowners either. You would think that these concerned hi-rise apartment dwellers along with their mentor, Handy Andy Cuomo, would buy up all of that land in the Southern Tier and keep it forever green, wouldn’t you? When do you think they will be putting those environmentally friendly windmills on their environmentally friendly hi-rises, and stop using all of that dirty natural gas heat? What a bunch of phonies!

  4. Fracing hazards are real .Not for all but many .Nuisances are also very real.How can anyone think a heavy industrial operation can be “Safe ” done only a few hundred feet from people’s homes .They create fumes,silica dust,chemical spills ,venting of VOC’s,flaring ,CH4 leaks,and many more industrial hazards .No one in their right minds can or should think this is OK .It is industrial and far from safe.Zoning used to be the standard .PA is just greedy and looking the other way …..FOR NOW !!…worked in industrial conditions for about 45 yrs. and know quite well what is and is not safe !!!!!

  5. Here are some thoughts about dangerous precedents. Apparently the NY Times (and I presume other anti’s) finds it acceptable to legalize marijuana without any study of the impacts of highly marketed, highly potent, and universally available THC (tetrahydracannabinol), the active ingredient in marijuana. Colorado is the guinea pig. And we have from the NY Times, reliably reported facts of the permanent disabling of toddlers who have mistaken it as candy, the suicide of young people who have been exposed to doses beyond their body’s tolerance, and recently the ever more common exploding house, (over twenty structures last year alone) where amateur entrepreneurs are mixing butane with marijuana to extra the THC, and blowing up themselves and their apartments and houses as a consequence. Perhaps someone should compare this to all reported incidents of child deaths, suicides and explosions at fracked well sites in Colorado since hydraulic fracturing began there. I don’t know about Mr. Zucker, but if I lived in Colorado, I would be more worried for his non-existent kids and his non-existent wife about the very real and existing next door neighbor’s marijuana fracking than I would of fracked wells.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *