Jerry Russell
Binghamton Area Landowner
Alternative energy sources aren’t going to experience widespread development in New York State without the funding help natural gas development would provide.
I know NaturalGasNOW.org is not the place you would expect to find an article about alternative energy sources; that is to say energy derived from something other than fossil fuels. The truth, however, is I have always been interested in sources of energy other than those that I have to buy on the commodities market. The reality is that here in New York State many alternative energy sources are difficult to use and are not cost effective.
Let me explain, starting with some background. I live on the edge of New York and my small farm borders the Pennsylvania state line. I heat my home solely with wood and have done so for the past 20 years. I harvest the wood from my own property so that I don’t have to buy fuel. I reclaim waste vegetable oil from a local restaurant to fuel my tractors and equipment. I once built a solar photovoltaic system for a motor home that I had. It worked well and, in fact, I used it to power my home freezer for 32 hours when the power was out.

PV, solar hot water and passive solar work together in this home (Credit: David Parsons, NREL)
Like many New York landowners, I would love to have a solar power system for my home but many things stand in the way. The first thing to stand in the way is cost. I had a solar energy company come out and give an estimate for a solar photovoltaic (PV) system for my home. The cost came out to around $20,000. That may not seem like much to some people, but personally that is stretching the budget a little.
The helpful guy at the solar company was quick to point out that New York provides a tax credit that will help pay for it. The truth is that New York will give an income tax credit of 25% of the cost up to $5,000. Aren’t the people of New York great! Take note that if you pay less than $5,000 in income tax in a year, you can spread this out for up to 5 years, but this will only benefit you if you pay Income tax to New York. If you live on Social Security for instance you are not eligible for any incentive.
Many people get the impression the electric company will pay you for any electricity that you produce and don’t use. This is not entirely true. They don’t buy the electricity from you, they provide you with net metering which is credit applied to your electric bill. At the end of the year if you have produced more electricity than you have used they will roll a credit over to the next year’s electricity bill.
I really love the Idea of solar (PV) power and I think every house should have solar panels on their roof, but the truth is if it was easily affordable then everyone would have it. This is how the system stacked up for me. I’d have to $20,000 put down for a system. This is more than what I usually spend for a car and I would have to get a second mortgage and spread it out for 10 years. Hopefully, I wouldn’t need a new car for 10 years.
The $5,000 tax credit would be nice but, thanks to my income level and New York’s generous child tax credit, I would have to stretch this out for 5 years in hopes of benefitting from all of the credit. Net metering is great. but since I am notoriously thrifty, my electric bill has traditionally been less than $200. a month. At this rate, if I produced all of the power I needed, I could recoup my money at about the same time I paid off the second mortgage.
Oh, did I mention that the other thing standing in my way is Russell Mountain. My house is at the bottom of a steep north facing slope and doesn’t get sun on the roof from mid-December to mid-January, so it may take longer than ten years for net metering to pay me back.
Despite the drawbacks, I am still in love with solar power and the truth is that if gas companies leased my land, a solar power system is the first thing I would add to my property. I am sure there are other New York farmers and land owners who feel the same. Natural gas development could, in fact, be the best thing to happen for solar power in New York if I’m correct and experience suggests I am. Unfortunately, the climate for alternative energy in New York State, like that for natural gas, is not so good, and I’m not just talking about the weather. I hope that changes, and soon.
Check out what else is new at NaturalGasNow today!
While you’re at it, follow us on Facebook, Twitter and Linked-In!



Pingback: Alternative Energy Development in NY Needs Help from Gas | ShaleNOW
This is one of the best,if not the best explanations of solar i have seen! PV is also in my eyes one of the most promising alternatives to fossil fuel out there today! Sadly it is a long ways away from achieving the lofty goals it professes to already have? A stand alone PV system with ample battery storage is at least a decade,likely two away . I see suny B has an intense program going to rectify this shortfall for storage . Sadly that ,when a success will solve only half the problem . Like i have posted on this and other sites before, the notion the electric co. will be sending you a check for all the magic juice you make for them is a farce.Try to tell a solar salesman that.They miss-lead and lie like a used car salesman in a flooded area after a severe storm . My view on this issue has been skewed by the memory of the look on ole Adam,s face just before he tried to run myself and family into a sign abutment on rt. 17! The desperation of this industry to present itself in a logical light is sad and demented! Most of those employed in this industry are fine hard working people,some are just greedy crooks .The local pv folks need to clean house . ps. Adam ,what do you suppose will happen to you now that Matt has fallen from grace? Good luck,you are going to need it! I hear lately pv panels are detrimental to lizards too?
Great article.
Perhaps this may work well for new construction or if you are going to replace your roof entirely because it is failing, then fine. However most folks are in the early to middle of their roofs typical lifecycle and a re-roofing is needed in a few years after that. Placing panels on top now is not a good idea anyway. It is much cheaper and smarter to just to place an overlay of shingles (provided you have a conventional home) for the duration. Is it worth taking the panels down? Are you allowed to since they are usually not yours? Is there a contract that requires you to keep them producing electricity and supplying the grid since the rest of the consumers in the territory are counting on you to contribute to the power pool?
If someone has some information on those scenarios, it would be appreciated.
CE ,That is another problem with solar panels. You will have to depend on the skills of the installation crew to prevent leaks under the panels. As posted on this site, a lot of the local installations are done by students learning pv tech. As great as that sounds,a lot of folks choose the stand alone set up away from their homes. If you think about it ,the panels are not sealed against water ,only the mounting brackets. You would be wise to install a new roof before you install panels on it to help reduce the chance of pesky little leaks that can destroy your home. As you have seen i am not a big fan of pv because of many aspects of the performance and safety.I and many others feel this system has not been vetted for effect on it,s surroundings? It has been proven to kill birds and insects in mid flight.Reptiles are also killed by ground mounted systems. Much the same as wind generators ,it needs more research to be proven safe? I read a post recently that solar may cause cancer in mice? In all the rush to get this industry into use a lot of the big questions remain big questions? In the mean while maybe those who already have solar on their roofs should consider investing in tinfoil lined hats coats and blankets?Just to be safe!! And remember feed a gas pipe with proven safe by countless studies NG and starve a A rab, most of them hate your guts anyway. As for contracts ,I get the feeling if you have 20-50 grand they will work with you?Maybe Tom and his staff can find some solid info on that part of it so we can all debate it right here on this site? It might get interesting?Vic how did the radio show go? Can you provide a link to us so we can listen to it?Thanks again,keep fighting the good fight !!