Gone With The Wind: Wind Energy Runs Dry?

CELDF - report on Mora countyTom Shepstone
Shepstone Management Company, Inc.

 

The best laid plans of utopians always founder on the unexpected and wind energy investors are now reaping the whirlwind of their fatally conceited plans.

There is no word used more often than “unexpected” to explain the collapse of the comprehensive plans and utopian schemes human beings, in their fatal conceit, repeatedly attempt to foist upon their own kind. The excuse when things go awry is always the same – something “unexpected” happened. We here it a lot lately, of course, and readers can fill in their own examples, but shale gas was clearly the big “unexpected” to thwart the plans of renewables schemers to dismantle the oil and gas industry and that’s why they hate it it so much despite the evidence renewables advocates will actually develop a more sustainable foundation together with gas than in opposing it.

Now, another “unexpected” broadside threatens the renewables purists who suppose there’s no reason they can’t just substitute their product for natural gas rather than partner with it – the wind has stopped blowing so hard. Their rhetoric is gone with the wind.

wind energy

Wind Energy Faces the Unexpected

This story is a few days old now but picks up on some data gathered by the Energy Information Administration (EIA) and analyzed by the Financial Times. CNBC provides a nice summary, noting the following (emphasis added):

A lack of wind is making the US clean energy sector sweat, with consequences for investors from yield-hungry pensioners to Goldman Sachs.

Electricity generated by US wind farms fell 6 per cent in the first half of the year even as the nation expanded wind generation capacity by 9 per cent, Energy Information Administration records show.

The reason was some of the softest air currents in 40 years, cutting power sales from wind farms to utilities. The feeble breezes come as the White House is promoting renewable energy, including wind, as part of its Clean Power Plan to counter greenhouse gas emissions…

“We never anticipated a drop-off in the wind resource as we have witnessed over the past six months,” David Crane, chief executive of power producer NRG Energy, told analysts last month.

The situation is likely to intensify into the first quarter of 2016 as the El Niño weather phenomenon holds back wind speeds around much of the US, according to Vaisala, a Helsinki-based weather measurement company…

Wall Street banks are passive investors in wind farms, often through tax-advantaged financing structures. Goldman Sachs’s holdings include a stake in Cabazon Wind Partners in California, where generation fell by 16 per cent in the first half, EIA data show. JPMorgan Chase recently acquired an interest in California’s Alta Wind X facility, which suffered an 18 per cent decline in electricity output…

Wind generated 4.4 per cent of US electricity last year, up from 0.4 per cent a decade earlier. But this year US wind plants’ “capacity factor” has averaged just a third of their total generating capacity, down from 38 per cent in 2014. EIA noted that slightly slower wind speeds can reduce output by a disproportionately large amount.

There are several lessons to draw from all this.

The first is what I have referred to above as the fatal conceit, which Nobel winning economist Friedrich Hayek summarized by observing “The curious task of economics is to demonstrate to men how little they really know about what they imagine they can design.” It was a castigation of the arrogance of the intelligent in supposing they know enough to design complex systems that can only arise from human experience. Bill Buckley explained it by famously saying ““I’d rather be governed by the first 2,000 names in the Boston telephone directory than by the faculty of Harvard.”

That goes for most of us, I expect, and it’s what we see here – the design of a utopian wind energy scheme involving all sorts of subsidies and complex financing arrangements that fail to take into account the fact winds come and winds go. Wind, like climate as a whole, is ever changing in patterns of seconds, minutes, hours, days, months, years, decades and eons. Relying upon consistent wind patterns as the basis for an energy policy where wind is anything but supplemental energy (supplemental to oil, gas, nuclear and other on-demand sources) is a fool’s errand.

Kamaoa_wind_farm_258089172_431b470d25_o

Abandoned Kamaoa Wind Farm in Hawaii

The second lesson is found in the role of Goldman Sachs, et al. It was seven years ago we bailed out Goldman Sachs (and AIG to save Goldman Sachs) for having invested in other government entwined financing schemes. Those schemes, too, were intended to generate profits for Wall Street in the pursuit of the uneconomic only possible through government cronyism. Now we’re seeing a repeat with wind energy, demonstrating yet again so much of the “clean energy” scam is just another sub-prime lending crisis in the making. What could go wrong? Everything, if 2008 is any guide.

Thirdly, how much more data do we need to demonstrate renewables are only going to succeed hand in hand with natural gas? They have a role to play, for sure, but pretending they are substitutes for on-demand sources of energy is something only a true believer who suspends the facts in favor of blind faith can possibly accept. This is not to disparage those of faith, as I am one of them, but to point out there are many false secular religions out there and environmentalism (as opposed to good old fashioned conservation or wise use) is one of them today. Renewables will advance steadily if treated as the supplemental energy sources they are and if they are not made to depend on subsidies and Goldman Sachs or JP Morgan funding schemes built on those subsidies to survive. Competition in the marketplace is what will offer deliverance for renewables.

Finally, it is worth repeating a last point – wind energy’s capacity factor, at roughly one-third of theoretical generation capacity, is only about half what a combined cycle natural gas plant will deliver, according to EIA. Need we say more?

Please share this post and get the word out everywhere!

5 thoughts on “Gone With The Wind: Wind Energy Runs Dry?”

  1. Pingback: Solar Energy Solutions Don't Even Rise to Half-Baked

    • That’s not exactly true. Worldwide gas reserves have been growing for decades as technological advances open up new resources. And, win is exhaustible as recent declines in wind speeds have demonstrated plus the equipment definitely has a half-life.

  2. People:
    Look on the other side a little, solar works and will get better, wind works and could get better. Nukes are ok, expensive and dangerous, also could be improve. So many new ideals coming on the market that are clean.

    But in reality – We will need all of them to carry on and supplement the wonderful natural gas plus the carbon fuels.

    What we really lack is people thinking smart in the creation and consumption of our resources. Lack of understanding, Gov. corruption, combined with corporations. and personal greed is the true problem. (take latest Oklahoma anti personal solar law – paid off by power company)

    Center Point here in Texas are great to work with over the 14 years of doing solar. I don’t see the advantage of solar farms (waste of land) But with smart use, it will grid supplement peak usage. Saves the power company money.

    As it goes, easy to reduce a load of consumption without giving up the comfort, it is a personal choice. Need education of cost saving advantage and methods. The greenies are no better at this.. all BS

    As and old oil/gas person – I believe in proper use of all resources and I walk the talk. So don’t knock the failures, done with out thought.

    Red Johnson
    Chevron DSC Houston

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *