Tom Shepstone
Natural Gas NOW
…
…
The Washington County Observer-Reporter shows what’s wrong with journalism today; it’s biased, speculative and now radioactive for those seeking the truth.
The Washington County Observer-Reporter put out a story last month that should be the poster child for how not to do journalism. It used a reporter from PublicSource, funded by several special interest foundations dedicated to opposing natural gas development in Pennsylvania, to speculate gas drilling could be the source of radioactivity in Ten Mile Creek, while it ignored the overwhelming evidence to the contrary from the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection (DEP).
The story, entitled, “DEP to investigate Ten Mile Creek for radioactivity,” started out fine by stating the basic facts but, then, quickly descended into pure speculation that attempted to link gas drilling to higher levels of radioactivity in this stream based on nothing more than the suppositions of fractivist “experts” from the likes of the Center for Coalfield Justice, an advocacy group funded by the same Heinz Endowments that underwrites Public Source. It’s a pitiful exercise in journalism and, for readers, simply interested in learning the facts – the truth – it’s an example of why so much of the media has itself turned radioactive for them. Their news isn’t news at alls but, rather, repackaged advocacy.

Ten Mile Creek – Notice Large Surface Mine Next to It, Source: Google Earth
Here’s a sampling of problematic excerpts from the Observer-Reporter/PublicSource (emphasis added):
The DEP’s Bureau of Radiation Protection will investigate to see if there is a possible link between the radioactivity in the creek and shale gas drilling, Poister said.
If so, it could confirm suspicions scientists and residents have about wastewater from shale gas drilling creeping into Pennsylvania waterways…
Ken Dufalla, the [Isaac Walton League] chapter president, said the wastewater could have been dumped in mine shafts or leaked into mines through shoddy well casings. He also said it’s possible the radioactivity is a remnant of when the shale gas industry used to take its wastewater to treatment plants, which treated it and released it into rivers and streams…
A couple more “ifs” and another “possible” or two and we’re into urban legend territory – a myth with real honest-to-goodness staying power albeit without the honesty. Such is the nature of this Observer-Reporter story, but it’s what’s left out that’s even more dishonest. Consider the fact the story barely mentions the DEP’s TENORM study, except to generically describe it and pull out a largely irrelevant and out-of-context statement about spills. What DEP actually said about its study was this (emphasis added):
“(the DEP’s) TENORM study, analyzed the naturally occurring levels of radioactivity associated with oil and natural gas development in Pennsylvania. While the study outlines recommendations for further study, it concluded there is little potential for harm to workers or the public from radiation exposure due to oil and gas development.” – DEP Study Shows There is Little Potential for Radiation Exposure from Oil and Gas Development. (January 15, 2015).
Notice the “or the public” part of the statement. Also, consider what others have observed about this radioactivity issue, which helps to put things in perspective. Here’s what the AP reported way back in 2011, for example:
PA: No red flags over radioactivity in 7 rivers: Tests of water in Pennsylvania downriver from sewage treatment plants that handle wastewater from natural gas drilling raised no red flags for radioactivity, the state Department of Environmental Protection said Monday. All of the samples, taken in November and December, showed levels at or below the normal naturally occurring background levels of radioactivity, the agency said. All samples also showed levels below the federal drinking water standard for Radium 226 and 228, it said.
Then, there is this from KDKA:
At Tervita’s Westmoreland Landfill in Belle Vernon, the operators say the loads are rarely above the level of radioactivity present in our surroundings at all times. “We understand that people are concerned when they hear radioactivity. But, what people need to know is there is background radiation everywhere from your countertop to your banana peel,” Cam Hantiuk said.
And, from the Youngstown Vindicator:
The average chest X-ray emits 4,000 microrem, according to the Environmental Protection Agency, which is 600 times the radiation found in the drill cuttings.
Plus, this from the Columbus Dispatch:
In Pennsylvania, where the state does keep track, more than 9.3 million tons of cuttings and sludge were dumped at 24 landfills in 2013.The waste had acceptable, low levels of radioactivity, said Lisa Kasianowitz, an Ohio Department of Environmental Protection spokeswoman. … “There’s radon in granite countertops,” said former Ohio EPA Director Scott Nally.
And, finally, this from the Paleontological Research Institution:
Radiation levels in the Marcellus shale itself are sufficiently low that they are not expected to affect the public or drill site workers…Overall, it is unlikely that the general public will ever come into contact with NORM in any significant concentrations.
None of this perspective made it into the Observer-Reporter story, of course. Instead, we got this from Patrick Grenter, a director of Center for Coalfield Justice:
“The community deserves a full accounting of what exactly is causing elevated radiation levels and what the risk is to public health and the environment. Anything less than that is unacceptable and potentially putting lives at risk,” he said.
Giving voice to this sort of irresponsible hysteric speculation by an advocacy group tied to the funders of the reporter, to the exclusion of facts and honest perspective, is anything but good journalism. It is simply the enabling of the fractivist echo chamber, where extremely wealthy special interest foundations such as the Heinz Endowments and Colcom Foundation (two funders of multiple fractivist activities) fund the instigators, fund the reporting on the instigators, fund the groups acting on the reporting and then fund the reporting of the action taken by the activist groups.

Enough of this echo-journalism already!

http://www.cbsnews.com/news/recession-proved-key-to-u-s-reducing-its-emissions/
“If the study’s methodology proves to be rigorous and reliable, the results would be interesting, but not revolutionary,” he said. “The fact that emissions fell because of decreased economic activity is not particularly informative for public policy purposes, unless of course one thinks that retarding economic growth is a sensible climate policy.” said? Robert N. Stavins, the Albert Pratt Professor of Business & Government at Harvard University’s John F. Kennedy School of Government, who in that article “disagreed with the assertion on the role natural gas played in the past and will play in the decades to come.”
Headline of this amazing piece of journalism? “Surprising ecological upside to the economic downturn”. Is this story making the rounds in some fashion? Of course. Why? Likely to counter things like this: http://www.usatoday.com/story/opinion/2015/07/16/natural-gas-renewable-fuels-fracking-column/27089397/
and maybe this:
http://www.nytimes.com/2015/07/14/opinion/joe-nocera-shale-gas-and-climate-change.html?_r=0
“We’re talking about huge swaths of the country being made unlivable.” says award winning political cartoonist about “pro-fracking pundits” and “natural gasbags” like Joe Nocero, who don’t actually have to live near fracking as if let’s see there aren’t actually pro-fracking people in the country, just pundits? Aren’t there people who write for this blog who live near fracking or want to?
http://fusion.net/comic/170358/what-if-pro-fracking-pundits-actually-had-to-live-near-fracking/
On the one hand there are lots of people, including democrats and environmentalists like say the current president or the EPA head, who see the benefits of natural gas for the environment including climate benefits. On the other hand there are the people who deserve the credit for NY’s fracking ban, ( and they all have names) and along with it the idea that they have sold which is that natural gas is worse for the environment (people, health etc) and climate than coal. Who are they? They are “fractivists”, certain “environmentalists” and certain “climate activists” or “leaders”.
http://switchboard.nrdc.org/blogs/ksinding/historic_victory_for_public_he.html
http://www.motherjones.com/environment/2014/09/methane-fracking-obama-climate-change-bill-mckibben
http://thehill.com/policy/energy-environment/155101-report-gas-from-fracking-worse-than-coal-on-climate
The Washington County Observer-Reporter shows what’s wrong with journalism today; it’s biased, speculative and now radioactive for those seeking the truth.
aka, “The journalists that couldn’t shoot straight”.
Pingback: Who Is PublicSource, Inc. and What Game Are They Playing?Natural Gas Now
Pingback: Energy in Depth | Testing of Tenmile Creek Shows No Elevated Radioactivity
Pingback: Energy in Depth | *Update* Ten Mile Creek Testing Results Show Very Low Radiation Levels