NED Pipeline Opponents Employ Fear & Demons Tactics

NEPA Energy - Johnny Williams Johnny Williams
Freelance Journalist

 

Three speakers used a FERC hearing as a platform for criticizing the proposed NED pipeline expansion and it was ugly – nothing but fear and demons tactics.

Last week, there was a public hearing held at the Towanda High School that I regretfully missed. I say regretfully not just because it concerned Kinder Morgan’s Northeast Energy Direct or NED pipeline project, a proposed expansion to the Tennessee Gas transmission line to transport Marcellus gas to the northeast, but also because there was a grand display of misinformation spread throughout the hearing.

The public hearing, which was covered here by The Daily Review, was hosted by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) and sought public input on the project. According to The Daily Review, the project was “blasted” by three speakers, but the main perpetrator was Standing Stone Township resident Diane Ward.

natural gas

Ward has a history of fractivism and blowing up perceived issues. Four years ago she made headlines in stating that Chesapeake Energy mortgaging mineral rights was preventing local residents from taking a mortgage out on their homes, a case that was quickly disproved by the Rocket-Courier.

Her fractivist tendencies were on full display yet again during the public hearing, stating that gas companies have “drilled irresponsibly, cutting corners, polluting land and water, defiling our culture and ruining many lives.”

Now these are the common anti-fracking scare tactics, a method of attack that has documented many times on this blog, and, ever since the EPA’s study stating that fracking does not cause widespread issues, it is a method that is, quite frankly, dead. Thus, I won’t dwell on that portion of Ward’s comments beyond using them to establish her agenda.

Getting into the meat of her words, she stated the need for Kinder Morgan’s NED is not driven by the needs of natural gas customers, but by “greed on the part of the gas industry.”

“The oversupply situation and the current low gas price problem are of their own doing,” she said. “Gas industry economic health is the need behind this project, not customer need. The gas industry desires that this project come to fruition so that it can reap the rewards that it envisioned when it decided to drill with gusto, with reckless abandon.”

Now a portion of this is true. John Augustine of the Marcellus Shale Coalition admitted as much during a recent Wyoming County luncheon when he said, “We are victims of our own success. The Marcellus has exceeded everyone’s expectations in terms of how much and how slow the decline has been.”

But this is economics; when there is an oversupply, prices will fall. In the case of Pennsylvania, those prices have reached record lows, which is great news for natural gas customers, but has been bad news for operators, as evidenced by Consol Energy’s recent employment cuts. I’m typically not one to speculate, but if pipeline capacity was enough to deliver Marcellus gas into the more expensive northeast market, which is the purpose of the NED project, I’m willing to bet some, if not all, of those jobs would’ve been saved.

natural gas

Transporting natural gas to the northeast is a win-win. It will lower and stabilize the volatile markets of New England while simultaneously seeing companies get more for their product (which in reality is simply called “good business”), which will ensure Pennsylvanians keep working.

Ward went on to say the NED project does not end in Massachusetts as Kinder Morgan has said, but is only part of a larger, more sinister plot to export natural gas to Canada.

” ‘They plan the first phase to be as acceptable as possible, (so that they can) obtain approval, and construct,’ she said.

She said that Phase 2 of the project would extend ‘from Dracut to Canada, and further beyond by means of LNG exports from Canada.’

‘Phase 2 cannot be stated (by Tennessee Gas), because it would eliminate the possibility of a positive outcome from the basic decision that FERC needs to make, that of public convenience and necessity,’ Ward said. ‘Phase 2 work has already begun, but this work is being ignored by FERC. Pieridae Energy has filed a federal application to send domestic natural gas from Massachusetts to Nova Scotia, where it would be converted to liquefied natural gas (LNG) and exported.’”

In reality, this “Phase 2” cannot be stated by Kinder Morgan because it is Pieridae’s project, and let’s be honest, a company has no business speaking on behalf of another company’s project. The Marcellus Shale is huge, and exporting LNG is certainly a much better option than importing it.

Finally, Ward, along with Binghamton, NY, resident William Huston attacked FERC, the very agency deciding whether or not to approve the project, directly, stating that FERC is not “an objective decision-making agency” nor “funded by an appropriation of Congress”.

Natural gas

However, according to FERC’s latest Strategic Plan “Congress assigned these responsibilities to FERC in various laws enacted over nearly 100 years, such as the Federal Power Act, Public Utility Regulatory Policies Act, Natural Gas Act, and Interstate Commerce Act. More recently, as part of the Energy Policy Act of 2005, Congress gave FERC additional responsibility to protect the reliability and cybersecurity of the bulk power system through the establishment and enforcement of mandatory standards, as well as additional authority to enforce FERC regulatory requirements through the imposition of civil penalties and other means.”

In other words, FERC is empowered by Congress and is not an agency that energy companies can simply refuse to play ball with if they don’t get approved.

But then it’s hard to play ball when there’s always someone that cries foul.

Please share this post and get the word out everywhere!

4 thoughts on “NED Pipeline Opponents Employ Fear & Demons Tactics”

  1. http://williamahuston.blogspot.com/2015/07/people-often-ask-why-civil-disobedience.html

    Bill Huston belongs to the FERC doesn’t work for the people, FERC is a rogue agency camp or as he says” those of us who have looked into it realize this may be THE MOST CORRUPT quasi-governmental organization ever.” camp. (capital letters his.. I might have put QUASI in capital letter for emphasis)

    https://www.facebook.com/permalink.php?story_fbid=1559617690945142&id=1484209761819269 The FERC is a rogue agency camp is apparantly pretty cool as this post from Gary Wockner celebrates Bobby Kennedy for saying it. “Go Bobby”. Yay for Waterkeeper Alliance says Gary Wockner and then Go Bill McKibben for this:

    http://grist.org/politics/mckibben-to-clinton-here-are-7-things-you-need-to-do-to-clean-up-your-climate-act/ For what exactly? This specific advice from Bill McKibben, climate guru to Hillary Cinton..” Fall out of love with fracking. You backed it to the hilt, obviously — but you could argue you weren’t alone, that the former executive director of the Sierra Club used to tour the country touting its virtues. Now that the science is in, the Sierra Club, and the rest of the environmental community, are staunch opponents. That’s because everybody now understands that it represents not a bridge to the future but a bridge to nowhere — it’s a way to tie ourselves into our fossil fuel infrastructure for decades to come, instead of moving with vigor toward renewables.”

    http://www.timesjournalonline.com/details.asp?id=95530 Interesting statements here as well about FERC. Lucky for you there are transcripts of public meetings and also dockets on pipeline projects so if you miss a meeting, the tone of the hearing is captured officially somewhere. Course it is also likely videotaped or available on line or covered somewhere as well.

    Journalists don’t appear to be interested in any of this, the nature of these hearings. However this seems like a pretty important topic to me, perhaps one of the more important ones in the country right now. There are no environmentalists that support fracking or natural gas in the United States right now? We understand that it is a “bridge to nowhere”? I disagree.

  2. https://www.facebook.com/SystemChangeNotClimateChange/photos/a.197271330425426.1073741827.197250393760853/303465583139333/?type=1&theater

    Here is a tip. Activists (such as one in that photo) also consider themselves “freelance journalists” which is very interesting.

    http://www.vice.com/read/meet-the-insurgents-in-americas-fracking-war-456

    So lets consider that perhaps Peter Rugh, who may not be the most “objective” reporter because of his own ecosocialism or other kinds of activism, has written an interesting article for Vice about the “insurgents in America’s fracking war.” Why he had to leave NYC or the area to meet Craig Stevens when Craig Stevens had driven to the downstate NY area to testify that a proposed LNG import project was likely a ruse to export natural gas who knows?

    http://www.longislandpress.com/2013/07/31/long-islands-offshore-lng-port-proposals-critics/

    http://socialistworker.org/2012/08/21/unwelcoming-spectra-to-nyc

    http://www.vice.com/read/new-yorks-silent-but-deadly-fracking-problem

    What can you learn from reading Peter’s articles? That NY has a silent but deadly fracking problem (pipelines or infrackstructure)? Maybe what the activists say or what they are against or who they are and how they are connected?

  3. Hi, Johnny. The first rule of being a real journalist is that you should always attend the meeting that you are reporting on. There were certainly plenty of seats available for you and all of your friends. Your article is a second hand reinterpretation of a legitimate journalist’s work. The Daily Review’s reporter was present at the meeting and did a fine job in interpreting the event as he saw and heard it. He spoke to the presenters personally and obtained available documents. You are merely trying to piggyback on his work, rehashing it and putting a respin on it without knowing anything about what went on the meeting or what was said other than his already quoted quotes.

    I would like to set the record straight. I am not a fractivist. I have as many, if not more concerns about gas drilling as I do about fracking. If you must apply a label, than I would recommend calling me an anti-drilling environmentalist, since I have environmental and other concerns not only about drilling but also fracking, compressing, transporting, etc. I never mentioned the words fracking in my presentation, and my concerns for the environment are much less focused than the specific concern about the impacts of fracking. The area of concern that I addressed with FERC that day was the issue of roadside rubbish thrown by pipeline contractors. My recommendation was for the requirement for solid waste plans associated with the building of pipelines to be extended to the areas off of the ROW, and specifically to the roadsides in the areas traveled by the pipeline workers. I am sick and tired of seeing our roadsides trashed by gas workers on the go. Now, I am sure you didn’t know that, since the Daily Review reporter chose not to include that in his article. I understand that entirely, since roadside rubbish is not perceived as newsworthy by newspapers or readers.

    By not attending yourself, you missed out on the opportunity to report on some of the real issues that some of us who live in the Marcellus have. You missed out on the opportunity to speak to me and to the other presenters yourself. And now you will have to wait to read the other comments that I had that day for FERC, both presented and not, due to the 5 minute time limit. I will be filing them with FERC, where you can read them online.

    In the future, you may want to telephone interview persons you are reporting on when you miss their presentations. It’ll give you a new angle on the comments made which will make you stand out from the other journalists. But don’t bother calling me, I only do interviews with legitimate journalists at responsible papers such as The Daily Review.

    Thanks for the covering some of my other anti-gas work, but you missed a lot so you may want to do a little more research to fill out my dossier. I expect to remain somewhat active in the environmental field and I imagine you’ll be hearing about more of my work in the future.

    Until next time…

  4. Pingback: Just Say No to NED Pipeline Opponents and Their Tactics

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *