Dr. Michael Morrongiello
Forensic Psychologist and Steuben County Landowner
The Marcellus Watch is nothing more than the latest compilation of half-truths and fear mongering propaganda by a natural gas industry hater.
Peter Mantius writes the “Marcellus Watch,” a feature in the Corning Leader in which he regularly attacks the gas industry. Who appointed him guardian of the upstate environment? That is a subject for an investigative journalist. Who pays him? What are his associations, his politics? Since no one has volunteered, I’ve appointed myself the Marcellus Watch Watcher. I want equal billing, a big picture and a bio.
Mantius says he’s a “freelance journalist” and “former reporter for the Atlanta Journal-Constitution,” which gives him the patina of objectivity and fairness. He has neither. He spreads propaganda, twisting facts, offering clever half-truths, and cherry-picking quotes. His latest article, which appeared in the Leader on 10/11/15, is a case in point.
It was about Painted Post’s agreement to sell water to a Shell subsidiary for gas drilling in Pennsylvania. The Sierra Club, along with just five of Painted Post’s 1,847 residents, sued to stop the sale; it was halted and then reinstated by the Fourth Judicial Department, a court of appeals. Mantius claimed the sale was reinstated because of a “leak in NY’s environmental law.”
Not true: the court ruled based on years of case law. Mantius selectively quoted the court to give the impression that the law was excluding people victimized by big, bad business, saying that “Anyone who can’t show ‘a direct harm or injury that is in some way different from that of the public at large’ is barred from court.” This is false. No one is barred from court, but people must show direct harm to have standing to sue – that is, for the suit to proceed, injury caused by the company must be shown.
Here’s what the court said about that:
“It is well established that standing requirements are not mere pleading requirements but are an indispensable part of the plaintiff’s case.”
The plaintiff must prove that he has been injured. One person who was granted standing which was then denied on appeal was John Marvin, whose “injury” was that the trains carrying the water were noisy and kept him awake nights.
Painted Post is like most upstate towns; its population is shrinking and aging, and as the population shrinks so does the tax base, meaning they will have trouble paying for basic services. The water sale is a boon for this tiny village. The $4 million realized from the water sale would be used to fix their water system, improve their infrastructure and maybe, in the future, cut taxes. The sale amounts to $2,166 per resident per year.
The mayor and the Town Board, acting on behalf of the people of Painted Post, decided to make the sale. They consulted the public servant who runs the water department. He determined that the aquifer produces enough water to meet residents’ needs and sell to the drilling company without diminishing water quality. This is representative democracy in action. Here’s what the court said, and Mantius ignored: “There is no dispute that courts surely do provide a forum for airing issues of vital public concern, but so do public hearings and publicly elected legislatures, both of which have functioned here.” The Sierra Club practices textbook environmental extremism; if you lose in the democratic process, sue.

As the self-appointed Marcellus Watch Watcher (see me at work above), I have two final observations. Mantius said a Sierra Club volunteer tested Painted Post water and, shockingly, found the water was substandard. Mantius includes a party to the suit in his article. What responsible journalist does this? He also said the Painted Post aquifer was “hardly inexhaustible.” Another quote, another distortion. All aquifers are finite, none is inexhaustible, but the Painted Post aquifer has enough water for the residents and for sale.
Mantius always leads the reader through a maze of minutia and then twists it to scare them. But, he didn’t scare Painted Post. They fought the enviro-bullies, providing an example for everyone upstate who just wants a chance to succeed.
Editor’s Note: Peter Mantius is a writer with the DC Bureau which is an enterprise of the Public Education Center, has a Rockefeller family “philanthropic advisor” on its board and has received some $265,000 since 2009 from the Park Foundation to wage war on natural gas drilling.

