Has Upstate New York Been Heard?

Upstate New York - Dana KnowlesDana Knowles
Steuben County Land Owners Coalition

The Upstate New York election results tell us more than anything else just how supportive the Marcellus Shale region of the state is of gas drilling.

I live in Upstate New York, in Steuben County, which is part of the Southern Tier region. The last few months I have traveled many of the back roads from Binghamton to Rochester to Jamestown. I saw thousands of signs for Astorino, Repeal the Safe Act and Friends of Natural Gas. I saw less than five Cuomo signs. I really got my false hopes up that maybe upstate NY was going to have a say in this year’s election. Then reality set in. Cuomo won 54.0% to Astorino’s 40.6%.

Needless to say, I was very disappointed. I had thought Astorino would do much better then the Sienna Poll was saying. Then, when the actual results came in I thought I must have been mislead by all the signs I had been seeing. That was until I looked at this site and the map below.

Upstate New York

Astorino won 46 out of 62 counties in New York State (red) and Cuomo took 16, only three of which were rural (some North Country counties bordering Vermont – no further explanation needed). Significantly Cuomo “received 8 percentage points fewer than in 2010” and “Republicans picked up three congressional seats in New York and regained sole control of the state Senate.”

Really, the end result may not be as bad as we thought.

There were three major candidates for Governor, Rob Astorino, Andrew Cuomo and Howie Hawkins (the greenie in the race). On the issue of natural gas drilling, Astorino supported it and would have reopened drilling in Upstate New York immediately. Cuomo has been a fence rider. Hawkins would have banned all drilling.

If you look at the map above, it is better then any of the polls we see regularly for gauging opinions on drilling, because the people who were concerned with this issue actually got out and voted. The results speak for themselves, as Upstate New York is overwhelmingly red, New York City and some other urban areas (Albany, Binghamton, Buffalo and Syracuse) plus Planet Ithaca are blue. Howie Hawkins won nothing, garnering less than 5% of the vote. Here are the primary counties with actual Marcellus Shale gas to develop (other counties have other resources) and their vote tallies:

Upstate New YorkAstorino won 55.3% the votes of the shale gas region of Upstate New York and if non-drillable Planet Ithaca (30% of Tompkins County) and the City of Binghamton (24% of Broome County) are deducted, he easily won over 60% of the votes. The Cuomo base was an urban one that lives off of natural gas, has no potential for drilling itself but, yet, wants to prevent drilling in neighboring areas that could supply the gas they use while building their economies. Makes you wonder what these urban voters are thinking doesn’t it?

The antis have tried to make us all believe drilling is bad and have falsely suggested Upstate New York is frightened by it. Well, either something got better or it really isn’t that bad because anyone could have voted for Hawkins and that would have guaranteed no drilling. This map should speak loud and clear to Cuomo what the people of upstate NY want. I would really like to see Cuomo stick to NYC where he is well liked and let Astorino run upstate where he is well liked. That could be a real win-win for all of New York. In the end I think that upstate did have their say. Now, we just have to wait again and see if anyone is listening.

Check out what else is new at NaturalGasNow today!

NGNlogoNew

While you’re at it, follow us on Facebook, Twitter and Linked-In!

Please share this post and get the word out everywhere!

11 thoughts on “Has Upstate New York Been Heard?”

  1. Pingback: Has Upstate New York Been Heard? | ShaleNOW

  2. Hopeful Cuomo gets it like Obama should in regards to states that would have keystone XL cross over. All states and counties with the proposed pipeline voted in republicans. It is time to get America to work by all means

  3. Well, Cuomo would DEFINITELY be a better fit for Mayor of NYC than the incompetent one in office now-in addition, the people of upstate would have THEIR choice of Governor. I am a disgusted NYC resident who is disheartened, to say the least, that Cuomo won. I say he would be better as Mayor simply because he caters to the downstaters and ANYONE is better than the bozo voted in as mayor now! In fairness, I have property bordering Broome/Chenengo County and has impatiently been awaiting approval for drilling. I noticed my taxes had gone up SIGNIFICANTLY-IMMEDIATELY when the initial information came out on Marcellus/Utica Shale; however I there is still NO STRUCTURE on my land and the taxes continue to increase! ! !

  4. Rather than moaning about how Cuomo got in, you should ask why so few voters, both Republican and Democrats, stayed home. The numbers in the chart show that less than half, and in several cases, less than a third of the voting age population bothered to vote. If our cause doesn’t resonate with upstate voters, you are going to have to rethink the methods you’ve used for the last several years.

  5. I’m only counting 13 counties for Cuomo. The problem is in that New York City cluster there’s over 10 million voters that could give a damn up state New York. Just like Cuomo.

  6. Deaf ears cant hear ! The only reason Broome co. went Cuomo is SUNY. They have been teaching anti classes for many years. They want research money for energy. Their plan is to think our energy needs away. The brain trust we should not trust ! A large percentage of staff and student body come from NYC. They want their cut of the profit !

  7. Hi Karen, we all know that you are one of the good ones, and we wish there were more like you. We’re all glad to have you on board. Thank you for all that you do.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *