Daniel B. Markind, Esq.
Weir and Partners, LLP
Shale development continues to impact everything, from the economies of states to the balance of international power. It’s a new world built of shale.
As 2014 closes, intense pressure is building on countries that use oil as a primary source of revenue. For the fifth time this year, Russia increased its benchmark interest rate to try to stem the depreciation of the ruble. It didn’t work. Even with a base rate of 10.5% per annum, the ruble dropped over 1.5%. Just this year the Russian currency has fallen 41% in value, and according to Bloomberg is the second-worst performing among the 170 global currencies that it tracks.
Shale Development Impacts the International Scene
“Harsh” coordinated measures announced last week by Russian President Vladimir Putin to deter speculators and steady the ruble have been equally ineffective. The Russian Central Bank now predicts 2015-6 economic growth to be “close to zero,” with inflation about 10% by year end 2014. The Russian bear is lethargic, to say the least.

If anything, Venezuela is in even worse shape. Swaps traders now predict the probability of a Venezuelan debt default at 93%, raising the cost of upfront insurance to 59%. Again according to Bloomberg, the South American nation has reserves of only $21.5 billion, which is barely enough to cover 40% of its total debt due over the next five years.
Unlike Russia, Venezuela has a weak leader in Nicolas Maduro, who won a closely contested election following the death of Hugo Chavez. Should he falter, there is no telling what would come next. A large period of instability which causes a disruption in the oil supply from Venezuela might raise prices, as the US imports large quantities from Venezuela (approximately 750,000 barrels/day in 2013). In addition, many of the US refineries are calibrated to handle that country’s high-sulfur content crude.
Then there’s Iran, which naturally is blaming the price decrease on “treachery.” Whether President Hassan Rouhani was blaming the price cut on Saudi Arabia for refusing a production cut at the recent OPEC summit, American shale producers for their increased production or its traditional bogeyman Israel for who-knows-what, Rouhani told a Cabinet meeting that the price fall was “politically motivated” and “a conspiracy against the interests of the region, the Muslim people and the Muslim world.” CNBC quoted an official at Iran’s oil ministry as saying that prices could drop to $40/barrel if there is no production cut.
While much of the conversation in the press has been about the effect of lower oil prices on shale oil, and analysts are developing graphs and charts showing the break-even points for different shale plays, the more important breakeven point will be the budgets of foreign countries. Even if the price of oil stabilizes and shale oil production slows, the fact that shale production is viable means that the days of foreign control over our oil prices should be over.
The US Picture on Shale Development
For natural gas, the issues are similar but not identical. Much is riding on US infrastructure development, with the key being pipeline construction and capacity. Geopolitically, investing in refining and exporting facilities would, in and of itself, send a powerful signal that the political power of gas in the hands of countries like Russia is rapidly diminishing. Even if we start now, little real export of natural gas will take place until 2017 or 18. The mere fact that these export facilities and capability will exist, however, will impact the markets.

In this country, the EPA published in the Federal Register on Tuesday a proposed rule that will require companies that are hydrofracking and have oil or gas wells to report their greenhouse gas emissions. The public has 60 days to comment.
Interestingly, this comes as two new studies published the same day in the Journal Environmental Science and Technology showed methane leakage rates at far below the threshold for natural gas to retain environmental and climate change benefits. As the Washington Examiner pointed out, “…while natural gas is half as carbon dense as coal, methane is at least 20 times more potent at trapping heat. Environmentalists say a leakage rate of 3 percent could erase the climate benefits of natural gas.” The joint Environmental Defense Fund and University of Texas-Austin study, however, shows leakage rates far below 3 percent, putting them in line with EPA estimates.
Locally, the change in administrations in Pennsylvania and Maryland will affect shale gas development in those states, but no one is yet sure how. Numerous articles are being written about whether Pennsylvania Governor-Elect Tom Wolf’s billion dollar estimate of receipts from a 5% natural gas severance tax unrealistic in the face of falling commodity prices, but Mr. Wolf’s transition team insists he still plans to introduce it. Whatever is introduced, it will need to pass a Republican-controlled legislature.
In Maryland, outgoing Governor Martin O’Malley ordered the drafting of regulations to cover hydraulic fracturing in that state, with large shale gas deposits in Western Garrett and Allegany Counties. In Maryland, the adoption of these regulations is an executive function, although the regulations will be submitted to the Joint Committee on Administrative, Executive and Legislative Review. As such, it will be incoming Republican Governor Larry Hogan who will implement them, something few would have predicted in this bluer-than-blue state when Governor O’Malley started this process in 2011.
In New York, rumors continue to swirl that governor Andrew Cuomo finally will lift the horizontal drilling moratorium, but nothing has happened so far. Clearly, his first weeks after reelection were consumed by the snows in Buffalo, but since then all remains quiet from Albany on shale.
Further west in Colorado, re-elected Governor John Hickenlooper’s Oil and Gas Task Force met Tuesday and Wednesday to discuss land regulation issues. The meetings highlight the “West Slope Way”, which is an unofficial partnership between the oil and gas companies and the communities they interact with. Last night’s meeting in Rifle, Colorado was packed, showing just how much interest there is in this commission agreed-upon to keep the issue off November’s ballot.
As interesting as 2014 was, 2015 will be just as interesting.
Check out what else is new at NaturalGasNow today!
While you’re at it, follow us on Facebook, Twitter and Linked-In!


Pingback: Shale Development Is Changing Everything | ShaleNOW
Is that map the latest available ? I see it is from Jan. 2006 ? Great article !
There undoubtedly are and, in retrospect, I should have looked for one. The same facilities are still in the possible mix, however, except that they are likely to be export rather than import.
In regards to Canada I can report that Nova Scotia has three proposed LNG export terminals in the works . Goldsboro , Bears Head and Melford are in the mix. Bears head was to be an import terminal with the construction going so far to pour the concrete footings for the storage tanks and support buildings . The Australian company LNG bought the bear head project and have applied for a US export license . Goldsboro,s promoters have q commitment for half of their export capacity from the German electric utility Eon . The Melford proposal is by East India company H Energy and they have half of their proposed 5 million ton per year capacity spoken for in India . In Quebec there is a LNG project proposal that I believe is about 8 million tons of LNG per year . They had applied for their export permits for both Canada and the US. My money is generally on Bear head as the company LNG seems highly capitalized being in the last part of opening an LNG facility in Louisanna I believe . LNG has an in house technology for generating the electricity for liqiufying Natural Gas that apparently makes their process more cost effective . H energy of India are virgins in this business and the Goldsboro people seem to be a group of veteran Alberta Energy executives whom I certainly would not discount. On the West coast of Canada the project proposals are too many to count .
Wow , you cant turn the news on without seeing something about all this ? Talking about how much Wall street is losing ! It looks as though they were caught off guard ? How could that be ? This all proves my theory on how much they have been sucking from us US consumers all along ! Now we will see who gets caught with their pants down ? Instead of messin with US energy they should have ditched those bum foreign energy investments ! To think , they are the ones taking care of hard working folks retirement funds? Gee wiz i hope there is enough of your funds left to pay for their year end bonuses ! Maybe there will be some affordable housing on Park ave next year ? WE NEED PERMITS NOT PIPES-ALL NEW YORK OR NONE!