Renewables Industry Gets a Taste of the NIMBY World

NIMBY - Jim Willis reportsJim Willis
Editor & Publisher, Marcellus Drilling News (MDN)

 

The renewables industry, the advancement of which is the true objective of many shale gas opponents, gets a taste of the NIMBY world out there, providing a teaching moment on energy regulation and capitalism.

Yet another novel argument is being trotted out by the militant green left–natural gas gets an an “unfair” advantage. You see, it’s just too darn easy to build a pipeline–compared with putting up an electrical transmission line. That’s the cockamamie argument now being made by renewable energy zealots like Jaafar Rizvi, writing in Grist (a “nonprofit, independent green journalism” website) in an article titled Here’s Another Reason Why Renewables Are at An Unfair Disadvantage. The headline is more whiny than the article, but this one reveals just how out-of-touch many some shale gas opponents are with the NIMBY world they’ve helped create.

Grist for the NIMBY World

Grist is an on-line magazine of sorts that attacks fracking at every turn. Just do a Google search for “fracking” from their site and you can see for yourself. This site is no friend of natural gas development and views it as a threat to renewables. The Rizvi piece is part of a larger template. Although he doesn’t directly attack natural gas, his use of the Spectra Pipeline as an example is an appeal to its NIMBY opponents to get angry and help the renewables industry.

As MDN has shouted for years now–the shale drilling debate is not really about water contamination, truck traffic and “fugitive” methane–it’s really about a few misguided people who want to pick your energy source for you–and for everyone else too. They irrationally hate fossil fuels because fossil fuels, including natural gas, threaten to slow the adoption of so-called renewable sources of energy, like wind and solar, although hydro-electric is actually the biggest part of our renewables portfolio. How do wind and solar energy get to market? Via high voltage electricity transmission lines.

NIMBY - Power Line

According to Mr. Rizvi, it’s not a fair playing field between natgas pipelines and electric transmission lines…

Recently, a new pipeline started pumping fracked natural gas from the Marcellus Shale to Manhattan. It’s a critical reminder of the importance of infrastructure in determining our energy future — and of how lopsided our infrastructure policy is.

Burdensome regulations governing infrastructure are hampering renewable energy expansion, while natural gas is facing no such obstacles. If renewable energy is going to make up any significant portion of our nation’s electricity needs, we need to change our energy infrastructure regulations. And the time to make those changes is now.

Coal-fired power plants are retiring, leaving a demand for new electricity generation. The two most likely power sources to fill that void are renewable energy and natural gas. But right now, the competition between these two sources is not happening on a level playing field.

Building out infrastructure is critical to the growth of both of these power generation sources. But it takes a lot longer to put up transmission lines, which link remote wind and solar farms to population centers, than it does to build natural gas pipelines. And therein lies the problem.

From 2001 to 2010, the U.S. built roughly 13,000 miles of new interstate natural gas pipelines compared to just 748 miles of interstate high-voltage transmission lines. This gigantic mismatch is in part due to the fact that the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission lacks the authority to site transmission lines, but does have the ability to site pipelines. So FERC can approve a pipeline route, while a patchwork of local and regional regulators with competing interests must all agree on where an electric transmission line should be built. One broken link in that long and fragile chain of approvals can quash an entire project.

These regulations have real-world consequences. Take for example the Zephyr Power Transmission Project. This line, proposed in 2011, would take power from what could be the largest wind farm in the nation and perhaps the world, the Pathfinder Zephyr Wind project in Wyoming, and deliver it to Las Vegas, where it would be used and distributed to other cities in the Southwest.

NIMBY powerline_042313~0

This wind farm is expected to generate between 2,000 and 3,000 megawatts of inexpensive, renewable energy — enough to power a million homes. But the Zephyr line, which will take three years to build once approved, was proposed in 2011 and won’t be out of the regulatory weeds and ready to begin construction until 2017. That’s an almost comical six years of permitting and review. The process could go longer – six years is just what they’re expecting. And at any point, it could be rejected.

Natural gas pipelines, on the other hand, are getting fast-tracked, ensuring that gas is getting into our electricity system quickly. While the previously mentioned gas pipeline serving Manhattan will be used for heating, its size makes it a good example. The U.S. Energy Information Administration called it one of the biggest infrastructure expansions in the Northeast in decades. Here’s the kicker: Spectra Energy, the owner and operator of the pipeline, applied for a permit with FERC on Dec. 20, 2010. That’s less than three years from a formal proposal to bringing natural gas to Manhattan.

To give utility-scale renewable energy a chance to take advantage of the gap in electricity demand left by retiring coal-fired generation, we must change how we approve transmission lines. Congress should give FERC the authority to site transmission lines the way it can site natural gas pipelines. Without this kind of change, transmission will be doomed to a snail’s pace of production, leaving renewable electricity to wallow in nothing more than its potential.

In the EIA’s recently released 2014 Annual Energy Outlook, it predicts that natural gas will overtake coal as a fuel source for electricity generation by 2035, with each supplying about one third of our overall needs. Meanwhile, it predicts that renewable generation will increase from last year’s 12 percent to just 16 percent by 2040.

If we want to see renewable energy reach its true potential, we must make a change. New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo (D) recently proposed such a shift in his state, pushing for faster approval of new power lines. If implemented, the approval timeline for some in-state transmission lines will be compressed from four years to 10 months.

In this new year, I hope Congress will do a similar thing on a national scale and resolve to level the playing field when it comes to regulating our energy infrastructure.

Jaafar Rizvi is a former grassroots organizer who now consults for renewable energy and infrastructure companies.*

Tell Your NIMBY Story to Inergy and Other Pipeline Companies

It’s obvious the grassroots organizer (how did that ever become a job) Mr. Rizvi has never had the pleasure of attempting to get lease sign-offs for a new pipeline (which is like herding cats), arrange billion dollar financing for a pipeline project, find elusive customers who will commit to 10-20 years of using your pipeline, and have state and federal regulators watch every step you take along the way. Building pipelines is no walk in the park, Mr. Rizvi. The readers here at Natural Gas Now will be surprised to learn the natural gas industry is facing no “burdensome regulations governing infrastructure.” Tell that to Inergy, which has been trying for years to gain approval of additional natural gas storage in New York and had to deal with NIMBY and green orchestrated EPA opposition to its Marc-1 Pipeline.

The one great advantage gas pipelines do have is that they operate largely in the free market (you know, capitalism, anathema to many readers of the Grist). Why are high voltage electric lines so slowed to be approved? Because of over-regulation by the government, the same sort of over-regulation Grist readers would impose on natural gas development and fracking in order to kill it.

Editors Note: Jim makes a great point here. There is nothing wrong with renewables and nothing wrong with reducing the NIMBY obstacles to electric power lines, but it sure would be nice if Grist readers, now getting a taste of their own medicine, would stop attacking natural gas and focus on what we can do together to deliver safe clean energy to Americans. Natural gas could be the pathway to a world of renewables that doesn’t depend on government subsidies and throwing up obstacles to other energy sources, if only…

For more great articles on the subject of natural gas development every single day, subscribe to Marcellus Drilling News using this convenient link.

follow-us-on-twitter  like-us-on-facebook  follow-us-on-linkedin

Please share this post and get the word out everywhere!

8 thoughts on “Renewables Industry Gets a Taste of the NIMBY World”

  1. Just look at those high-powered lines in that photo. If you know Williamsport, you have seen the high-powered lines that have snaked across Bald Eagle Mountain for 60 or 70 years, creating a permanent scar on what would otherwise be what the anti-frackers claim is “pristine forest.” Gas pipeline is at least buried. My only hope is that Mr. Rizvi someday gets to prove his commitment to “clean energy” by hosting its infrastructure on his land or within view of his home.

  2. Aren’t these the same people who advocate that every little town and village should have veto power over gas development? If that same principle is applied to high power lines, none would ever be built. If it were applied to windmills and solar, far fewer would be constructed. And at any time that the local political wind changed, then existing facilities’ expansion could be blocked or phased out. Either we have a Statewide policy or we don’t. And what about the former scenic vista environmentalists? Power lines and windmill farms are uglier than a cityscape and far uglier than any temporary drilling rig. Nimbyism smacks of school yard intelligence. Aren’t there any adults anymore?

  3. Have you seen the maple syrup commercial where the farmer states global warming is the cause of his early success as the sap runs earlier…? Its true I saw him running to the bank with your money

  4. There is a solar farm in Middleboro, MA called Borrego Solar, in a cranberry bog, that has every neighbor on the street with “stop the evil solar farm” signs posted in their front yards. Another example is the wind farm on Saddleback Mountain in Carthage, Maine. The public was so receptive of the idea of having wind power generated in their back yards that the applicants had to have an armed gaurd present at an information presentation given at the behest of the MDEP. All the crap that extractive industries have had to endure for years is now being foisted on the treehuggers. Anyone that wants to fight any and all forms of energy production and transmission should feel free to start rubbing two sticks together for heat.

  5. i’m glad “grassroots organizer” Rizvi finds waiting 6 years so appalling. now he knows exactly how we landowners feel here in NY’s Southern Tier. and btw, the only way gas drilling is ever resuming in NY is if a court forces Cuomo to get the hell out of the way.

    we’ve all known for years now that the anti crowd is nothing but a bunch of NIMBY hypocrites. if they weren’t, Cayuga Heights would have 50 giant wind turbines by now, and every square foot of Cornell and Ithaca College would be covered with solar panels. that of course will never happen, because it’s impractical, and they certainly don’t want to look at it.

    polar vortex anyone? it was 10 below zero last night- imagine the furor from those self-righteous snobs had their gas supply been interrupted.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *