Jim Willis
Editor & Publisher, Marcellus Drilling News (MDN)
The all too predictable veto of the Port Ambrose LNG import terminal proposed by Liberty Natural Gas is a lesson in precisely how not to fight fractivists.
A rather abrupt end for an issue that was just getting started. Liberty Natural Gas filed a plan back in 2010, prior to the real Marcellus Shale revolution, to construct an off-shore LNG import (not export) facility off the coast of New York and New Jersey – in the ocean. A floating LNG facility called the Port Ambrose project. A pipeline would run from the off-shore terminal to Jones Beach, NY and from there would connect to a Transco pipeline lateral. The U.S. Coast Guard recently gave their blessing to the project (see Coast Guard Approves Port Ambrose LNG Import Terminal Near NYC/NJ) but it has died, nonetheless, and there are powerful lessons here about how not to fight frcativists.
Liberty Natural Gas tried to sell their project to New York and New Jersey fractivists by saying the gas would come from Trinidad and wouldn’t be that nasty, fracked gas loaded with radon (see Liberty Says “Non-Fracked” Trinidad Gas Better than Marcellus Gas). Needless to say, that was a whopping error on Liberty’s part – to smear the entire drilling industry in a vain attempt to garner favor with Kool Aid drinking fractivists, just to make a buck.
Liberty’s “it’s not fracked gas” rationale didn’t stop the antis – they were just beginning to organize with protests and rallies – their version of a tailgate party at an NFL game. And now New York Gov. Cuomo has gone and ruined it for them. Cuomo, with the stroke of a pen, has vetoed the project. It’s dead. Done. Finished. Won’t happen.
Now, what will all of those insane fractivists do? What events will they go to? Cuomo has just taken away their raison d’être. Cuomo should have waited a year and a half like he did with his frack ban – so the antis could rally and protest and chain themselves to things (or each other) and bleat and blat in front of the cameras. We call Cuomo’s rushed veto a premature inkulation – the ink came out of Cuomo’s veto pen too soon.
Here’s what our esteemed governor said via a press release (and letter) in vetoing the project:
Governor Andrew M. Cuomo today vetoed the Port Ambrose Liquefied Natural Gas Deepwater Port, citing security and economic concerns along with the potential to negatively impact off-shore wind development. The project, which had been proposed by Liberty Natural Gas, LLC, required approval from both Governor Cuomo and New Jersey Governor Christie under the federal Deepwater Port Act. Governor Cuomo detailed his full position in a letter sent today to the U.S. Maritime Administration.
“My administration carefully reviewed this project from all angles, and we have determined that the security and economic risks far outweigh any potential benefits,” said Governor Cuomo. “Superstorm Sandy taught us how quickly things can go from bad to worse when major infrastructure fails – and the potential for disaster with this project during extreme weather or amid other security risks is simply unacceptable. Port Ambrose would also hinder the local maritime economy in a way that negatively impacts businesses throughout Long Island, and that is simply unacceptable. This is a common-sense decision, because vetoing this project is in the best interests of New Yorkers.”
The Deepwater Port Act requires approval from the governor of each adjacent coastal state before a deepwater port license is issued. For the Port Ambrose project, both New York and New Jersey are adjacent coastal states.
The Governor’s review found that the project posed inherent and unanswered security risks to the region. The potential for catastrophic impacts during extreme weather events was also found to be unacceptable. Additionally, the project posed significant disruptions to commercial and recreational maritime activities, and would also have interfered with a critical off-shore wind power project proposed by the New York Power Authority.
“We are disappointed and very surprised with Gov. Cuomo’s decision today to not allow a cleaner, more affordable energy supply to reach New York consumers,” said Liberty Natural Gas CEO Roger Whelan. “We had hoped that the safety and environmental concerns raised by the governor this afternoon had been thoroughly addressed and dismissed in the final environmental impact statement.”
A predictable end for this issue. Liberty not only won’t build the terminal, they’ve alienated the upstream shale community as well. A bitter lesson learned for them.
Editor’s Note: Whoever it was who advised Liberty Natural Gas on media and political strategy should be sent off to the asylum. The fact they were “surprised” is all the evidence of incompetence needed. Attempting to appease fractivists, who are engaged in a holy crusade against oil and gas, by suggesting this was the alternative to fracking was a strategy destined to fail from the moment it was conceived, not because it wasn’t correct (it was), but because it didn’t matter. Fractivists aren’t concerned about fracking – they’re anti-gas zealots, true believers in a mindless ideology and driven by a foolish utopian desire they suppose will empower their ilk to make decisions for everyone. They were anti-liberty (pun intended) from the outset. There was never any hope of success with such a cynical political strategy.
Not only did Liberty fail to grasp this essential fact, supposing instead that facts and logic might carry the day, but it also completely underestimated the ability of fractivist liars to perpetuate a myth and had no strategy whatsoever for confronting it. The big lie, of course, was that Port Ambrose was for export, not import. It wasn’t true and it wasn’t possible, as the Coast Guard data and other sources demonstrated for anyone who can read. It was strictly an import facility and couldn’t be anything else. The proof is Cuomo’s letter, which makes no mention of it being an export facility in disguise, despite that being almost the entire basis of the fractivist opposition, with one outrageous lie after another in that regard being pushed by the Catskill Mountainkeeper, Sane Energy, Food & Water Watch and every other radical group out there.
Liberty Natural Gas never took on the liars effectively and instead stupidly tried to co-opt them. Their project would have competed with Marcellus and Utica gas that is flowing into New York in bigger volumes than ever before and, while reasonable people could agree energy security for Long Island and the City would have been enhanced by it, its defeat strengthens the position of those proposing new pipelines into the area, which is good for those of us promoting natural gas development in Pennsylvania and elsewhere. So, weep not for Liberty Natural Gas; it got exactly what it deserved. One hopes, though, other energy companies will learn from this experience; learn that lies must be boldly confronted, fractivists are zealots who cannot be co-opted and corrupt politicians such as Cuomo don’t respond to facts and logic but, rather, very special interests.
There’s also one other lesson to be learned; most urban voters aren’t very smart when comes to how their energy is produced, just as we aren’t very smart about how the subway runs. They can be manipulated to accept almost any lie or crazy thought, which is why the demagoguery quotient among corrupt politicians in these places increases sharply. Read the minutes of the New York City Council if you have any doubt. Liberty Natural Gas assumed facts, logic and reason would triumph and failed miserably as a result. It doesn’t work that way. It’s all about emotion and imagination, especially in New York. Nevertheless, it’s a problem many places, and as a humorous way to illustrate my point and end this post, let me share this video put together by a North Dakota radio station of a call from a listener distressed at the placement of deer crossing signs.
I know. It has nothing to do with gas, but when reasonably intelligent and articulate people are this out of touch with reality, it tells you what we’re up against.
For more great articles on the subject of natural gas development every single day, subscribe to Marcellus Drilling News using this convenient link.



I don’t think it matters whether one had an opinion about the port ambrose project or not to say something extraordinarily perverse has occurred. I find it difficult to see how people could even form an opinion on the project at all when almost everything said about it is either inaccurate by accident or totally fraudelent and deliberately so.
So first off libertys prior application was submitted in 2010. It was vetoed prior to environmental review by governor christie and at that time was twice the size and in a different location. That application was amended but according to uscg and marad never processed and the amended application from late 2011/early 2012 looks strikingly like the current application which was submitted in september of 2012. (See even now the date and history isn’t correct and one can read the project is 7 years old in a new jersey paper right now.)
How a project that in early 2012 was known as an import project correctly became a secret export project in 2013 is something most reporters in new york refuse to report. But in 2013 in the wall street journal port ambrose was described as a proxy fight over fracking and even the ny times featured the conspiratorial export theory via source Bruce Ferguson of the antifracking groups catskills citizens for safe energy.
Was the export conspiracy theory deliberate misinformation by antifracking groups and allies? The answer is yes. The fact is that libertys proposal became known via the ferc docket on the rockaway project (cp13-36) in feb 2013. The army corps of engineers asked about it and liberty intervened in the docket. Some of the same activists saying the port ambrose project was for export were intervenors in the rockaway project. How do I know this? Well I was an intervenor in the rockaway docket and know the groups who concocted the conspiracy theory. Were they told a bajillion times that the project was for import? Yes. Could average people understand when the dimensions of the existing pipe, the rockawa expansion and the port ambrose proposed pipe that the rockaway expansion would enable libertys project do deliver supplemental supply as the final eis on port ambrose now says? Yes.
So the port ambrose project is now vetoed. And if you opposed the project likely you are simply happy and don’t care how it happened. Since the project was only a proposal for delivering more supply as the draft eis stated an alternate such as a different interstate pipeline poject may come to be.
Some questions to ask if one wanted to really explore what is going on are: 1. Why did liberty and williams mislead reporters (the few who asked) about the infrastructure? The rockaway project and port ambrose were under review at the same time and the question was asked repeatedly in the ferc docket, was raised with many federal and state agencies involved in both projects? And two: why have multiple news organizations published the export scenario concocted by fractivists groups with no fact checking even when asked? And three: why did publications like newsday and reporter ellen yan for instance refuse to cover that the antifracking groups were lying to the public? Because ultimately its the press that is the biggest failure if you asked me. And it doesn’t matter whether one is or was for the project or not. You ought to be able to pick up a newspaper and at least read something close to reality there. I think the whole thing is scandalous. The fact that you are writing about fractivists because they dominated most press coverage and talking points on the topic and this was the singular project not even remotely about fracking in the area speaks volumes. The antifracking movement was able to hijack nearly the whole narrative of this project, totally mislead the public for years and the media has nothing to say about this? That is dumbfounding.
Brilliant observations!
Brilliant I don’t know. Eyes open, yes. Here’s the thing and its simple.. ferc has just released an eis for an LNG export project : http://www.ferc.gov/industries/gas/enviro/eis/2015/11-13-15-eis.asp I know none of the details. But since I can read I could find them out if I was interested yes? The information is available via the ferc’s website.
Now how ridiculous would it be if I just said that project was actually secretly a planned import project? Think a reporter and politicians and the public would buy it?
Well that’s no different than the new york antifracking movement and allies claims that the port ambrose project was the opposite of what it was. And yet a pulitzer prize winning climate news org just recently after a final eis and years of review and tons of publically available information that says otherwise that port ambrose was an import/export project. And some publications published the export thing for years and even when provided fact based evidence flat out refused to retract or change their reporting. That is ludicrous.
And then there are new york city papers like the daily news which I think may never have even done one story on this highly “controversial” project at all? Come on.
Karen …doesn’t take a genius to realize exporting LNG will increase NG drilling using an unSafe process that is done next to our homes .My knowledge of this operation is so far beyond you people here that sometimes you all make me laugh at how little you all know about NG co’s and how they operate and what really goes on .
Yes. You have certainly showcased your brilliance with that comment.
Exporting is exporting. Importing is importing. I think this is what we call opposites. And perhaps we are in grammer school when we learn the concept of opposites but perhaps younger. So clearly you are demonstrating something Bill. On the east coast an LNG export project is under construction. Its name isn’t port ambrose.
http://abcnews.go.com/US/wireStory/ny-gov-andrew-cuomo-rejects-proposed-gas-terminal-35152612
Michael Balsamo for one, the associated press…just one reporter of many flatout refusing to actually cover the port ambrose proposal and activists accurately. The list of reporters and publications covering up the export miinformation campaign that was widespread is long. Whether they are covering for their own publications prior errors or for the politicians and activists involved in the misinformation campaign who knows? It could be they simply can not accept their own gullability and failures to see things for what they are. The scandal involving the media is perhaps the only thing greater than environmental groups who the public likely doesn’t expect would be lying to them totally bamboozling the public for years.
http://www.wnyc.org/story/fight-over-floating-buoy-20-miles-out-ocean/ Here for example is WNYC “reporting” and one would have to call the reporting favorable to liberty as it reads like a hit job against any opposition. I mean the title says it all..much ado about a buoy and the photo is missing the most important piece of the proposed project..the ships. Most noticeably absent from the coverage of course is the fact that the hearing had fractivists bussed in talking about export and holding an absurd press event on the side. The hearing transcript and videos and other coverage demonstrate the reporter could not have missed this.
The entire thing…press coverage for years and activists deception, the politicians approval of this is ridiculous.