Methane Reality: Flaming Faucets That Don’t Get Reported

environmental justiceTom Shepstone
Shepstone Management Company, Inc.

 

…

…

Methane migration didn’t start with gas drilling and flaming faucets were nothing unusual in Northeastern Pennsylvania long before it arrived, though fractivists are loathe to admit it. 

Quite a while back some folks from Susquehanna County, Pennsylvania who happen to be on our NaturalGasNOW mailing list (sign up to the right if you’re not already on it) sent along a story about their own experience with a flaming faucet long before their was shale gas drilling in their community. It’s worth sharing because the narrative matches what we know from numerous studies (including this most recent one) and it contrasts sharply with the contentions of fractivists and gullible media types who routinely repeat Josh Fox’s lie.

flaming faucets

The Propert’s Flaming Faucet

Here’s the story we received from the Propert family in Susquehanna County:

Our family had a water well that initially provided good water.  Gradually, we began to notice a foul odor from the water and would occasionally get brown sediment from the spigot.  We contacted the well driller who recommended installing a potassium permanganate system to remove the sulfur odor.  This worked to some extent.  The well driller also indicated this was a common problem in our area.

As time progressed, we also noticed that the faucets would sputter when opened and the running water would bubble.  We had Culligan come to test our water.  The technician took a sample, closed the vial and shook it.  When he opened it, he lit the escaping gas with a flame.  Low and behold, our water contained methane and we could light the faucets with matches.  You can watch my husband do just that on You Tube.

Here’s the video to which the author, Pat Propert, was referring, followed by more of her story:

Knowing that the gas was methane based on the odor and its flammability and that the gas is not toxic, except in extremely high concentrations, we made sure to open all the faucets periodically to release the gas and keep it from building up in the water system.  Methane is not contained in the water, since it escapes as a gas.  Our water was still drinkable.

Unfortunately, the water began to get saltier and saltier and flecks of black material began to come out of our faucets.  The plumbing fixtures began to corrode from the salt.  We had a coal bed methane well instead of a water well.  To eliminate the salt, we installed a whole house reverse osmosis system at a cost of over $3,000.  We ran the system for several months, but had to replace the pump motor, due to corrosion from the salt, and the filter membranes, due to the large amount of salt being filtered.  Our electric bill also increased by over $100/month from the continuous operation of the pump.

Based on the ongoing costs, we eventually decided to have a new water well drilled.  This cost our family $6,800.  The new well supplies water that has a high iron content, which is typical for this area, but it is an acceptable alternative to the methane brine well.

In total, it has cost us over $25,000 to get potable water, that still has an odor and some mud on occasion!

We have subsequently purchased a house down the road that has an extensive water softening and rust removal system installed.  Obviously, this is not an unusual problem in Susquehanna County!

Pretty interesting, isn’t it? The next time you read about how fracking causes flaming faucets, bring this back from your memory bank and when you see yet another supposed “journalist” repeat the Josh Fox lie, send ’em a link to this story.

Please share this post and get the word out everywhere!

14 thoughts on “Methane Reality: Flaming Faucets That Don’t Get Reported”

  1. I remember speaking to an older gentleman years ago about this subject. He was probably at least in his 70s. and when he heard about lighting faucets on fire he laughed. He said he and his friends would do it when they were kids when their parents weren’t around. It wasn’t an uncommon phenomenon.

  2. Nice story ,however drilling in some cases can disturb shallow gas that was No problem ( or very slight amounts ) until drilling increased these ranges to unsafe levels.I have data ( From DEP and drilling company to prove this occurred ) …drilling a dynamic process will always create issues especially when done below aquifers.You can write all the PR you want but some of us know what really can happen( not in all cases but in some) ,The sooner the NG industry faces up to this and becomes responsible enough to correct these problems rather than deny them the sooner it will help their own image .Tom ….I can show you reports if you want !

  3. Most folks don’t realize that oil and natural gas seep out of the ground naturally. That’s how they were discovered.

    Here’s a link to pic of Eternal Fires at Wadi Naft near Kirkuk, Iraq fueled by gas seeps. It is estimated the fires have been burning for thousands of years:

    https://twitter.com/JKempEnergy/status/596996254107869184

    Two prime examples come to mind in California: The La Brea Tar Pits and Santa Barbara Harbor. Oil seeping into creeks in Pennsylvania led to its discovery there.

  4. I remember just before all the hoop la about NG a gentleman over on Old Fox Farm Road returned to the area and built a new home only to have flaming faucets after they put in the well. The story ran on all the local networks and if memory serves me, even the press ran it. Since the closest NG well is somewhere in PA, I would say Josh should crawl back into the hole he came out of.

  5. Greetings,

    In June, 2014, residents of the Castlewood Mobile Home park, near Linda, California (Yuba county) invited reporters to witness them lighting tap water afire.
    This was in an attempt to draw attention to the faulty water filtration that allowed the naturally present methane to enter their homes.
    In 2008, an explosion occurred at the complex due to fugitive methane.

  6. Josh Fox did actually comment on being quizzed about the flaming taps being present before drilling started – his reply was “Yes, but it’s not relevant”!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *