Tom Shepstone
Natural Gas NOW
Some recent comments from the National Park Service regarding natural gas development reveal the fragmented forests of the treehugger mind.
The Hawley News Eagle carried a story last month about an Upper Delaware Council meeting in Narrowsburg, New York, where the National Park Service Superintendent for the Upper Delaware, Kristina Heister, reported on she learned from a tour of natural gas operations in Bradford and Susquehanna Counties in which she participated. Answer: nothing she didn’t want to see or hear. Like Carol Collier, the former head of the Delware River Basin Commission (DRBC) she obsessed on the danger of fragmented forests without knowing the facts.
Here’s what the News Eagle reported about Heister’s remarks (emphasis added):
An educational tour of natural gas production in the northern tier of Pennsylvania brought home an impression for the local National Park Service chief: It’s apples and oranges.
Superintendent Kristina Heister, National Park Service, Upper Delaware Scenic & Recreational River, offered her opinion that allowing gas drilling in the heavily forested Upper Delaware region would risk spoiling the high quality river. Unlike Bradford and Susquehanna counties, where there is more open agricultural land, she said that fragmenting the heavy forest could lead to erosion and degradation.
She shared her thoughts at the Upper Delaware Council (UDC) December session in Narrowsburg, following a presentation about the Natural Gas Summit…
A main point that Heister stressed is that Bradford County is 60 percent agriculture and 40 percent forest, whereas on the Upper Delaware the land is 80 percent forest. “Whatever you think about how beneficial it was, we’re nor comparing apples to applies,” she told the UDC.
As someone who was instrumental in creating the Upper Delaware Council, who worked with the National Park Service in developing its program for the Upper Delaware and as a consultant to several of the municipalities impacted by its activities, I was appalled by her remarks and her lack of knowledge. She’s wrong on the facts, wrong on her implications and wrong on her conclusions.
Let me focus on my home area, Wayne County, which I also assisted in crafting its County Comprehensive Plan. That plan includes an Existing Land Use Study, the data for which was assembled not by me but by the staff of the Wayne County Planning Department in the most thorough examination of land use changes over time that has ever bee done by any agency operating in the Upper Delaware region.
You can read the whole thing here and the basic study from which the data was drawn here (maps were subsequently updated). Three charts tell the story. This one depicts Wayne County land use in 1959 when forest land represented 56% of the land cover, pasture accounted for 20% and 18% was cropland.
Some 49 years later, in 2008, forest land had increased to 65%. Pasture land and cropland both dropped due to reversion to forest and some very limited development or urbanization. Development didn’t reduce forest land; rather, it accelerated reversion of pasture land and cropland to forest as undevelopable portions of properties being used for development were allowed to revert.

The changes are summarized in this figure:

The conversion of pasture and brush land to forest over the 49 year period is almost a direct offset, meaning much of what is forest today was pasture, brush or cropland then. The county plan, in fact, notes this:
…forestland has grown by 44,458 acres or 16.7% since 1959. Open space uses (forestland, pasture/brushland, cropland and water) as a whole have dropped slightly since 1959, with 25,767 acres or 5.4% of the County converting to development uses over the 49 year period, an average conversion rate of 524 acres per year.
Are to we suppose today is a more perfect land use scheme than then and that we should stop right here? That would seem to be what Collier and Heister and their downstream allies at the William Penn Foundation and Delaware Riverkeeper (the same entity for all practical purposes) suggest. Even though we have more forest than ever and it is the pasture and cropland we’re losing, they’re worried about fragmented forests. Is there any doubt where either would have stood in 1959? Both would have insisted on the dangers of forest fragmentation then and, given their druthers, have prevented the change that has led to almost 17% more forest now.
We’ve dealt with this issue before (here and here, for example) and the forest fragmentation argument nonsense for numerous reasons, not the least of which is the lack of evidence for their contention; like most fractivist hype, it’s all speculation. It also ignores the very real benefits natural gas development has offered with respect to wildlife propagation, which we discussed here, here and here.
All of this, though, misses the much bigger point; that open space protection depends upon the ability of landowners to hold onto their land, earn a living from it and pay their taxes. It cannot simply be legislated unless everything is to become government parkland and there isn’t enough money in the world to buy everything. Heister apparently likes to think private land is government parkland subject to her whims as government’s agent, as do Collier and all the others who would dictate our future while absolving themselves of any responsibility for paying our bills and putting food on our table. This isn’t the first time she’s taken a similar tack, either.
Heister possesses no such authority and has no checkbook from which to buy the land she wants to control, so she, the DRBC and all the others of similar minds will ultimately have to find another way. They should start by looking closely at this Wayne County data because it clearly demonstrates development can lead to more forest preservation, not less. Landowners who are able to secure an economic return from a property in forest are more likely to keep it in that use. It’s that simple. Put a gas well pad on a property today and you might disturb 1% of it but you’ll earn enough to not have to clearcut your trees or residentially develop your property to pay the bills.
Worried about pipelines? OK, then double it to 2% disturbance. It’s still minuscule and likely to lead to much more than that in forest preservation at the bottom of the land use balance sheet.
Fragmented forests concerns are a figment of Heister’s imagination. She’s worried about what is, in reality, a solution staring her in the face, but this tree-hugger wasn’t able to see it because she didn’t want to see it. She’s simply uttering ideological talking points without giving any real thought to what it is that’s at stake.
It’s sad to me as someone who looked to the Upper Delaware Council as a place where the competing interests of landowners and recreationists could reconciled in frank, intelligent and adult discussion. Instead, we’re getting the childish world views of preservationists presented as the thoughts of a government agency that is supposed to focused only on a narrow corridor in which any drilling is highly unlikely anyway (gas there can be extracted via wells located outside the corridor by the miracle of horizontal drilling). The only fragmented forests she should be worried about are those found in the minds of tree-huggers like Collier and herself.
Check out what else is new at NaturalGasNow today!
While you’re at it, follow us on Facebook, Twitter and Linked-In!


Pingback: The Fragmented Forests of the Tree-Hugger Mind | ShaleNOW
Pingback: Shale Gas News - February 7, 2015 - Natural Gas NowNatural Gas Now
It time to call a time-out in the blame game perpetrated by the neo-pagan religion of the pseudo-science radicals who wrap themselves in the politico/rhetorical blanket of delusional environmental extremism. They are making up the rules as they go along. Let’s take a knee and look at some facts. (“Smoke ’em if you’ve got ’em.”)
The entire Northeast is an anthropogenic habitat. That means that nature without humans does not exist, that the ecology of the Northeast has been entirely generated and permanently altered by human influence.
The ‘natural habitat’ if it ever existed, was first altered by the newly arrived ‘Native Americans’ at the end of the last ice age. The wooly mammoth, the mastodon, the saber- tooth tiger, and who knows how many other species of flora and fauna who didn’t fear man (having never encountered their hunting and gathering prowess), were made extinct by activities of the newly arrived ‘Americans’ 13,000 years ago. They burned the land to farm it, then abandoned it when they exhausted it. In nearby forests they would burn out all the undergrowth or harvest all the dead wood, so much so that when the Europeans arrived in Virginia, one could see for great distances through the woods. Try that today. It is impossible.
The Europeans brought European honey bees, earth worms, starlings, mute swans, boars, the red fox, wheat, and a host of European fruit trees and vines. Today there are so many ‘invasive’ species that DEC and the US Fish and Wildlife are mere fingers in the dike. The Indians fished with seine nets stretched the full width across streams, not to mention weirs. They herded dear in great fenced areas and slaughtered them by the hundreds. Upstate New York under Iroquois occupation, much of which they took from the Algonquin, had orchards and farm fields.
There is no natural habitat in the Northeast except that which humans have created by their activities. The first Americans, as the Canadians call them, had long irretrievably altered the Northeast. The Europeans were simply the next higher degree. Forest fragmentation in the Northeast is an entirely artificial construct – an extension of a long debunked nineteenth century myth of North America as some ‘unspoiled Eden’.
I recommend that we all learn and spread that wonderfully descriptive and liberating word – “Anthropogenic”.
The Myth of Eden in America needs a prompt and deep burial, for the carcass has begun to rot.
Such great points, Paul!
Thank you, Paul.
It saddens me when people throughout Central New York refuse to know their own history. Even if they do, some are willing to twist it with a race card for mere political gain.
As a member of the council I found it disturbing that she would say what she said at the meeting not knowing the history of the area where at one point (turn of the century to the 1930’s) the area was totally devoid of trees. She also implied that the Susquehanna river was polluted because of oil and gas development, a false statement.
People including NPS officials forget that 99% of the land in the river corridor is privately owned and land owners were not compensated when they gave up much of their development rights to make the UPSRR possible!
I also mentioned to her that her statements were at odds with the Department of the interior Sally Jewell and indicated that I misinterpreted what she said. I think not, I wasn’t the only council member that took notice of her comments at the meeting!
The other thing I take issue with are the claims by groups like the William Penn and Riverkeeper that deforestation in the upper basin is the biggest hazard to the down basin people.. Not once do they mention or have they done real studies on tributary restoration which is even more of a concern then deforestation in preserving the quality of the river.
One can only come to the conclusion that these down basin groups are concerned with their well being and economic freedom at the sacrifice and expense of the upper basin landowners! Maybe they should clean up their own mess before they preach to folks who have been stewards of their lands in the upper basin for hundreds of years!
Pingback: Penn State’s One Sided Study on Pipelines and Forest FragmentationNatural Gas Now