Richard Downey
Unatego Area Landowners Association
Professionals on our side prefer the word fraccing to fracking when talking hydraulic fracturing, but whatever we call it, Upstate New York needs it soon.
It’s always has been about the water. Of all the “evils” the antis-drillers throw against gas development, water-gone-bad grabs people like nothing else. You can see water. You can drink it. If it’s gone bad, you can smell it. Water is primordial.
The anti drillers jumped on the water wagon early on and did a good job framing hydraulic fracturing as the culprit. Then, by taking the industry jargon (frac), and adding a “k,” they morphed a process into a demon word. Frack. It’s short. It grates on the ear. It sounds like the all-purpose, Anglo Saxon expletive. Substitute “frack” in any expletive laden phrase — you’ve got your edgy sound bite, just south of naughty with attention grabbing cache. No thought necessary. The word says it all.
One problem. Fraccing has nothing to do with contaminated water. Zip, zero, nada. Knowledgeable on both sides of the gas development/renewable debate have known this from the git-go. Oil and gas wells have been fracced for over 60 years, the last 30 years in the tight shales. No contamination from fraccing. Congressional hearings, two EPA administrators, the Susquehanna River Basin Commission, lead environmental officials from 28 oil and gas states, numerous academic and industry studies. All confirm – fraccing doesn‘t contaminate water.
Recently a National Science Foundation study published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences once again found water well contamination is NOT caused by fraccing. When contamination does occur, it’s faulty well construction, not fraccing.
So, enough already on “fracking.” Bring back the “c,”, drop the “k,” unless you want to waste more time and money on another study to find – fraccing has nothing to do with water well contamination.
What’s the chances of a water well being impacted? Can those chances be lessened? Is gas development worth it?
Pennsylvania data shows 243 water well impacts over a 6 years, 8 month period, starting January, 2008. Over the same period there were 20,353 gas and oil wells drilled. More significantly, in 2011 Pennsylvania upgraded its drilling regulations, many of which have been in place in NYS since 1982. The results — water well impacts fell. This year, as of August 27, some 10 water well incidents occurred while 1,420 gas wells were drilled. The impact rate was 0.7%. That’s 7 temporally disturbed water wells for every 1,000 gas wells drilled.
Can this be lowered? Sure. It’s declining all the time. The industry has come up with about 60 different types of cement employed in the drilling process, depending on conditions. It has invented “walking” rigs that can self propel themselves on a drill site to drill multiple wells in less time while lowering environmental impacts. Last year, 713 patents were filed to improve production and safety. GE is exploring means of substituting CO2 for water in the frac. New York’s new SGEIS regulations provide additional regulatory safeguards The industry can and should improve well construction and it will.
Finally, is a 0.7% impact rate worth the risk?
Drilling in the shales has created jobs, stabilized global energy prices, revived manufacturing in the US, and curbed our import dependence. It will add heft to our foreign policy decisions. It is one of the few bright spots in our economy. All this while bringing CO2 emissions to a 20 year low and saving lives by reducing New York City air pollution.
Meanwhile, if New York does nothing, we continue our upstate decline. Private industry isn’t rushing into an over regulated, high tax, expensive energy state. Over the last 12 months, the 52 upstate counties have gained 10,000 private sector jobs, many of them part time without benefits. Some recovery! Binghamton suffered a -0.1% job loss. Syracuse, – a 1.3% loss.
Our 25 to 40 year old population cohort is “hollowing out,” looking for jobs elsewhere. Our schools have declining enrollments. Our population is aging but AARP says retirees are looking elsewhere. Our counties’ bankruptcies, foreclosures, and tax delinquency sales — moving up. Our young – moving out.
Cuomo’s idea of upstate revival is beer, wine, and betting. While Albany‘s gaming franchise was up for bid, one of Donald Trump’s casinos closed shop in Atlantic City. You think The Donald knew something when he sold it? Using our upstate college knowledge could boost the technology sector but young professionals usually don’t move to ghost towns.
Upstate is stagnant. Pretty, but the barnyards are growing weeds, not jobs, as the photo below illustrates. And, according to the Bureau of Economic Analysis, the State as a whole ranks 45th among all states in economic growth.
Photo by Matt H. Wade (CC-BY-SA-3.0/Matt H. Wade at Wikipedia)
We have an opportunity for classic cost/benefit analysis. Myths stand in the way. Let’s start small. Take that special ”k” out of frac”k”ing and face reality. Reality is that fraccing doesn’t contaminate water wells. Without hysteria, maybe we can have the conversation that starts New York moving again.
Check out what else is new at NaturalGasNow today!
While you’re at it, follow us on Facebook, Twitter and Linked-In!



It’s simple. DRILLING and FRACKING are 2 spearate and distinct processes. There have been DRILLING incidents which contaminated water but there have been no documented FRACKING incidents causing any water contamination. If you don’t care about the facts you can easily combine the two to make a false argument.
Well said, Bill!
Bill what the Hell is the difference Both ” drilling and fracing ” are part of the NG extraction process !! I believe you need to Read your facts much closer ! Games don’t change opinions .Actual experiences ( like mine ) do !!
I agree that faulty construction is the culprit and you can’t make anything absolutely perfectly “safe”. The obvious answer is to have a moratorium or better yet an outright ban on all construction. There. That solves it, no building permits, no road paving, no repairs, no new autos, and lets help by getting rid of all hardware stores and building supply industry.
Besides, the acoustics in caves can be breathtaking.
Richard, do you think that if it was spelled “druncc” that DUI would suddenly become acceptable?
Bill, right and for the same reason drunk driving is safe since it’s only the drunk crashing that is dangerous.
Clifford, Weird methaphors aside, all I’m asking is to be factual. Drilling has caused incidents of contamination. Fracking has not.
I understand the contention. The point is there would be no drilling if fracking was not to follow.
Do you need another metaphor?
Huh? No drilling? There is, has been and always will be drilling with no fracking to follow. 380,000 conventional vertical oil & gas wells have been drilled in PA, none fracked. Countless water wells are drilled and no fracking follows. Test borings for construction aren’t fracked. So, are you against drilling or are you against against fracking? That’s my point. Make all the arguments you want, just use the facts. And yes, I’d enjoy another offbeat methaphor.
Both drilling and Fracing are part of the Same process of extraction .besides drilling is the cause of most incidents ,but plenty issues come from chemical spills,and air pollution from ( silica dust etc) from the Fracing part .
Bill F.Then simply say you’re against extraction, period. Cliff said he opposes fracking because it can contaminate groundwater. I suggested he be more precise by being against drilling since fracking does not cause it but drilling can if not done properly. So, you have come up with something Cliff can oppose…EXTRACTION. Not as sexy or mean sounding but more accurate.
We are all getting weary of the meaningless distinctions. It’s the leakage of the frack water that presents the health and environmental risks. I’m afraid semantics and a delicate parsing of the process is not going to change reality.
Best to own up to the problem and either fix it 100% or admit the risk.
So you think we should outlaw alcohol? Back to prohibition?
This is just a bad argument. When people or companies make bad decisions, they alone are accountable and should be held so. Can’t hold Jack Daniels responsible for a DUI. We also can’t live in bubble-wrap.
And hence cliff why one has police, breathalizers and consequences when people DUI.
The frackivist mindset is you ban cars because you may have some incidents . everyone takes public transit, in the frackivist world, which have huge subsidies.the longerwe have experience with technology the better we get .common sense regulation and updating it go for Fracking or any energy source including renewables
Paul, I agree 100%. But where are the “police, breathalizers and consequences” when it comes to FWG (Fracking Without Guarantees). All I see is the PADEP acting as the local emergency room if we stick with the DUI analogy. If a home owner finds contaminants in their water the PADEP might eventually step in and identify the cause and apportion some minor compensation. Who are the fracking police? What meaningful level of groundwater monitoring corresponds to the breathalizers? Who has gone to jail or has lost their license to pollute?
Jim, where do you come up with this stuff? DUI is already illegal.
Anyway, I do not blame drill bits or high-pressure pumps for groundwater contamination. Furthermore, what you consider an acceptable risk may not be what others do. But many here want to impose their standards on others.
Cliff you hit that nail right dead center on the head! We do not accept your standards of imagined risk. Facts and science trump your imagined risk every time! Has anyone else noticed Cliff,s writing style seems to change from time to time? Cliff, are you being coached? I still think there seems to be a lot of Vera-tone in some of your posts?
Freegas, excellent, I can see another conspiracy theory brewing.
do you idiots really believe you can just upset the foundations of the planet without consequence? drill away, jose, it won’t be my home burning. Short-sights set on job creation without a lasting, sustainable future is definitely the STABLE way to go, huh? While the planet gets raped. Even if you don’t care about natural environments and the beauty of an interconnected nature we are all a part of NOW, don’t you realise your grandchildren will suffer for your greed?