Mark Dye
Unatega Area Landowners Association
Otsego County, NY resident Mark Dye makes a thoughtful plea to engage the real interests of those who may not be landowners but could be shale supporters.
There is a memorable scene in the movie “Jaws” in which the Roy Scheider’s character, Brody, is startled to see how big the shark is, stumbles back to the captain and says “You’re going to need a bigger boat.” After the three disasters of 2014, the Middlefield decision, the election and the Cuomo ban, that’s how I feel. The political ground has shifted beneath our feet. If we want natural gas development, fellow shale gas supporters, we must expand our influence to the part of the population that is not a committed to either the pro- or anti- side of the natural gas question.
We Shale Supporters Need More Allies
The Middlefield court decision makes it possible to use home rule/zoning to ban natural gas drilling on a town by town basis. This means that town board elections, planning board appointments, comprehensive plans and zoning ordinances can be used to frustrate development even if the governor’s ban is rescinded. We need 51% of the population in every township or we lose.
The election showed our lack of support even among supposedly predisposed conservative Republican, who stayed home by the thousands. Counties that should have been Republican landslides, were won by much slimmer margins. The Quinnipiac poll showed that 42% of NY Republicans think Cuomo is doing a good job (see here, here and here). When conservatives couldn’t deliver their own people at the polls, Cuomo patched up things on his political left because there was no threat from the right.
The Department of Health medical report justifying the governor’s ban is of course a shoddy hatchet job done by political hack. Still the anti’s will latch on to it and we will have to discredit and destroy it before drilling can move forward. Remember, it is a political document and if it is discredited, much of the cover for the ban disappears.
The problem for the pro-gas movement is that the people we need to further our cause do not share some iconic conservative ideas. Many of our positions, if they do not actually drive them to the opposition, do nothing to make us useful or reasonable in their eyes. We must make the benefits of natural gas solutions to the problems they face. It is only after we earn and keep their support that development will be safe from an isolated and declining anti-gas minority.
The Shale Supporters We Need Don’t Care About Property Rights
The first issue is property rights of land owners; nobody, except landowner associations, ever mentions it. It irrelevant to people who rent or own small suburban lots, which are most people, even in the Southern Tier, let alone the rest of the state. They do care about taxes and jobs, so talk up the ad valorem tax and how it comes directly to the township. Compare it to the equivalent tax in PA and the amounts paid out. We need to point out cheap, clean gas is good for home owners, business, and the environment. Our property rights will be secure after we have made it worthwhile for our neighbors to help us.
The next issue is climate change denial. I don’t care if you believe climate change is false; the people you need think it is true. Polls shown about 75% of New Yorkers believe that climate change is real and happening now. Natural gas is the cleanest, least greenhouse gas producing fuel we have for the “bridge” to renewables. Again, if we make natural gas the solution to their problem, rather than call them fools for being hoaxed, we have another win-win situation.

Even the authors of the most optimistic plan for a switch to total renewables in NY state, the Jacobson study of 2012, give themselves until 2030. That is 5,475 day sto build 16,720 5MW wind turbines, over 12,000 of which will be built “off shore.” That’s three per day, every day, for 15 years, mostly in the Atlantic Ocean. The wind turbines will get us 50% of the 2030 energy target only if we factor in a 37% decrease in total demand from today’s figure.
What could possibly go wrong? Plenty, obviously, but I have a clean, abundant local fuel that will take care of us for the next 20-30 years. There is a place for renewables; they will only be part of the solution and are decades away. If your crystal ball can number crunch all political, technological, economic and international factors farther out than that, please give me a peek.
Next is energy deregulation. Most people see the EPA and DEC as a protection from the excesses of large energy companies, even if they aren’t wild about bureaucracy. Republican congressional leaders Boehner and McConnell have made it clear they want to relax restrictions on coal. To the general public, coal is a dirty, polluting fuel; to shale supporters, every train load of coal is money out of the pocket, as are imports whether from OPEC or the XL pipeline.
Natural gas, on the other hand, requires no EPA regulation for carbon capture in new or existing gas fired electric generation plants and we will require many of these to make up replacing old atomic plants, which produce 19% of the nation’s power.
Finally, there are the alternatives to fossil fuels, such as atomic, hydroelectric, biomass and conservation. What should aging atomic plants be replaced with? My preference is for new atomic plants, but that may be impossible politically. We must remind others that France, which has banned fracking, gets 75% of it’s electric from atomic plants and imports natural gas from Algeria. If the anti’s are slow in installing their solar and wind alternatives or they are not as effective as planned, then the “bridge” fuel can win again. The Jacobson plan requires one more large hydroelectric facility. Ask them which river they have in mind and watch them twitch.
Conservation is almost always a winner, because people can see the payback as money in their pocket. The problem is the time frame. The Jacobson plan’s 37% reduction in total energy consumption in 15 years is delusional, yet technology, new building codes and fuel economy standards will make significant conservation possible. This will extend the useful lifetime of natural gas well into the future.
This message is the bigger boat we need.
Check out what else is new at NaturalGasNow today!
While you’re at it, follow us on Facebook, Twitter and Linked-In!


Any thing done on aperson’s property that exceeds and affects those around him ( or her ) is considered a nuisance and shall be handled as such !!Check the law .
I agree Bill F. That,s why we pro gas people think you are such a pain in the butt ! Mind your own damn property and we will do the same ! Check the law of the land ! Ya see Bill this has become a land rights thing for a lot of us pro gas land owners too. And that fact in my eyes makes you appear to be a damn commie! Are you a commie Bill? Are you a Putin fan Bill ? Only commies are against US energy development ! Maybe you would be happier in China ? They pay a lot more for gas than we do.Would that make you happy Bill? Over there they cant even go outside most days,too much smog from coal plants! They would kill for our energy resources and might well do so some day if we let folks like you keep stalling energy development in this country ? So Bill F. try not to take this too personal ,It,s just I look at this as protecting my family and yours. Try to understand ? Nice article Mark.