Richard Downey
Unatego Area Landowners Association
Natural gas opponents seem to think renewable energy just sprouts from the ground with no costs or investment required. This blind faith will produce nothing but energy poverty for all of us.
The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission held a hearing in Oneonta on the Constitution Pipeline two weeks ago and the antis continued their obstruction of anything fossil-fuel related. Once again, the project was the target of their usual litany of devastation, destruction, noise/fumes/traffic/crime, explosions and other disasters. The skin falling off milking cows was a nice new touch, though. The collapse of the arctic ice sheets was another.
Those few antis who chose to stay on message claimed the 950 page Draft Environmental Impact Statement was “inadequate” and needs to be studied and re-studied by agency after agency who should then pass their studies to other agencies. It’s never enough, of course, because their goal is delay–delay that kills the project.
OK, we get it. The antis don’t like gas. If not gas — what?
Energy Poverty in Europe (Environmental Poverty, Too)
Renewables, of course, and the antis have a plan. It calls for 17,000 off-shore/on-shore windmills, 1,200 solar plants, 5 million photovoltaic rooftop units, and a sci-fi wish list of wave/tidal/geothermal/hydroelectric projects. All of this will power . . . New York. Sorry, New Jersey. You’re on your own!
Aside from the non-existent electrical storage technology and the mind-boggling electric grid adaptation, there’s the little matter of astronomical capital costs and the huge, eternal life support of subsidies, tax credits, rebates, mandates, et. al., to enable an energy system that will last . . . twenty years? That’s its’ efficiency life-cycle.
OK! OK! Let’s say money is no object, we can magically wish storage and transmission technology into existence, and we’ll re-build the whole thing in twenty years. How about it then?
One small problem (among many): if it’s impossible to get a windmill spinning in Meredith or Denning, New York, does any sane person think Ammasgansett, Rhinebeck, Syosett or Niskayuna will be elbowing their way to the front of the windmill line? Lots of luck getting site plans approved for thousands of industrial-scale, view-shed spoiling, shadow-flickering white noise machines that kill birds. I can just see the local hearings now. The horror! The horror!
Anyway, it’s all been tried before. Fourteen years ago Germany instituted the policy of energiewende. The goal was to cut CO2 emissions 80% over 50 years by prioritizing zero and low carbon sources over coal, gas, and oil. In 2011 after Fukushima, Germany set a goal to decommission its nuclear plants by 2022. To meet its’ carbon goals, Germany heavily subsidized wind and solar, mandated that electricity from these sources be used first, and taxed consumers with a surcharge to support the costs. As a result, Germany now gets 22% of its electricity from renewables.
The dirty little secret is that almost half of that 22% is hydropower, biomass (yeah, wood) and burning thrash. The economic, environmental, and social results of the energiewende policy are catastrophic: sky high residential and industrial electricity rates, three times those in the United States. German officials now warn of the “de-industrialization” of their country as manufacturing moves elsewhere.
Is the air cleaner? No! CO 2 emissions have risen. Coal and gas generators continue to operate as an inefficient standby for the intermittent renewables. US coal does BIG business in Germany. Russia supplies 30% of Germany’s gas, 45% of its oil. So Germany get dirty air and dependence on Russia. The kicker is that about one fifth (and growing) of German households have fallen into “energy poverty,” defined as the point where the cost of energy is 10% of household income. Most Germans are renters, and 90% of poor Germans rent their homes. The renters don’t get the subsidies for those rooftop units, but they sure pay for that high-cost electricity, the equivilent of 41 cents per kwh.
Is Energy Poverty Coming to the US?
If you think it can’t happen here, call a friend in California and have him send you his electric bill. It’s probably twice what you pay here in New York and New York is no great bargain. California, going down the same green road as Germany, is getting German results. Business is packing the U-Hauls and heading to Arizona. The State of Texas maintains a recruiting office in California to lure business away. California — a nice place to visit; a tough place to do business.
After suitable delays to placate the obstructionists, the Constitution Pipeline will be built. It will transport Pennsylvania gas to New York City where it will heat apartments, clean the air an ensure no one suffers from energy poverty. It will service New England, replacing the electricity generated by the geriatric Yankee nuclear plant. Hopefully, some day it will transport gas destined for Europe that will end up in a free and vibrant Kiev.
But first it has to be built. The sooner, the better.



nofracking hobbits are energy poor
but of intellect they have no more
Smack! Out of the park article Dick! I love reading your stuff, its short to the point and dead on. I give it 10 out of 10 well flares up!
I think the best location for the anti’s boondoggle would be Central Park in New York City, or as close as possible to Albany, New York.
Pingback: A Test for Shale Gas Skeptics – Part II | Natural Gas NowNatural Gas Now