Jim Willis
Editor & Publisher, Marcellus Drilling News (MDN)
Congressman Tom Reed proposes landowner compensation for Southern Tier farmers and other landowners aggrieved by Governor Cuomo’s fracking betrayal.
Congressman Tom Reed (Republican, Conservative) from the Southern Tier/Twin Tiers area of New York (Corning region) is “leading the charge” in Washington by proposing new legislation that would require states, like New York, to compensate residents when it causes them harm by action or inaction–like the recent Gov. Andrew Cuomo decision to ban fracking in the state.
Under Reed’s proposal, called the “Defense of Property Rights Act,” landowners would be entitled to receive $20,000 or 20% of the value of their land. Below is the press release from Reed’s office, a few extra details we’ve gleaned from news accounts, and our own opinion of this strategy.

Congressman Tom Reed
First up, the announcement from Congressman Reed’s office:
Congressman Tom Reed (NY-23) introduced the “Defense of Property Rights Act” in response to recent adverse action taken by government actors against Southern Tier landowners.
The bill would defend private property rights by providing an option for compensation on behalf of those unfairly harmed by government action. It would also open the judicial process in a more fair and equitable way. Congressman Tom Reed released the following statement:
“Far too often private property owners are left on the sidelines while local, state and federal governments’ make decisions for them on what they can and cannot do with their property. This is not right; it is not fair; and it is not the American way. These actions by government entities often leave our neighbors and friends with property that is worth much less, hurting their families and leaving them little choice but to accept the lower value.
“That is why I invited Steuben County farmer Neil Vitale to the State of the Union this week. I wanted to highlight those unjustly and unfairly impacted by adverse government action. I care deeply about the farmers and families of Western New York, which is why I am putting this concern into action.
“As a result, I have introduced a bill to defend Neil Vitale and all those unfairly harmed by government. This legislation would allow our friends and neighbors the option to seek compensation for their loss and provide a more fair process in our court system.
“I appeal to our highest of American ideals – fairness and doing what is right. And today I believe we have taken a big first step in defense of fairness and in defense of private property rights.”
The key section of the bill is Section 5 – Compensation for Taken Property. Here’s a part of that section:
IN GENERAL – No agency, shall take private property in part or in whole except for public purpose and with just compensation to the property owner. A property owner shall receive just compensation if–
(C) such action results in the property owner being deprived, either temporarily or permanently, of all or substantially all economically beneficial or productive use of the property or that part of the property affected by the action without a showing that such deprivation inheres in the title itself;
(D) such action diminishes the fair market value of the property which is the subject of the action by the lesser of–
(i) 20 percent or more with respect to the value immediately prior to the governmental action; or
(ii) $20,000, or more with respect to the value immediately prior to the governmental action;
The first phrase to notice is “in part or in whole.” This is key. Until now, a “takings” case has had to prove that the entire asset’s value must be diminished in order to have a case. In the case of shale drilling, both surface and sub-surface value is involved. If a government, like New York State–or even a township in New York–bans fracking, it affects the value under the surface, not on top of the surface. The language in this bill introduces the legal concept that part of the asset – the part under the surface in this case – can be diminished or harmed if the government takes an action. You no longer must prove that the entire asset’s value is diminished.
The next thing to notice is in (C) above, and that is “temporarily or permanently.” Without this language, a judge might say that the action taken by Gov. Cuomo, or by a township, is not permanent. A new governor may arrive and allow fracking. A township may reverse a frack ban vote. Therefore, the ban is “temporary” until such time. The problem, of course, is that those things may or may not happen–but in the meantime (years and years) the landowner has been harmed economically. This bill addresses that potential loophole–guarding against an easy out for a liberal judge (more on judges in a moment).

Governor Andrew Cuomo
Finally is section (D) above, where we get to the numbers that (before we had a copy of the bill yesterday) confused us. Section D is a litmus test–a standard for measuring whether or not there is “enough” economic harm to bring a case in court. This language means, “If the action of a state, like New York in banning fracking, has caused the value of a property to be diminished by AT LEAST 20%, or $20,000 – that landowner has a legitimate case. These numbers have nothing to do with how much a landowner might conceivably receive for the economic harm done.
Example: If a small beef farmer in upstate with 50 acres wanted to lease his land for drilling, but because of the state ban he cannot lease, he has been harmed. Let’s say the farmer can produce experts that have appraised his property as being worth an extra $2,500 per acre if he could lease it – and that’s just in signing bonuses. That farmer’s property value has just been diminished by $125,000. Since the value exceeds the $20,000 level, he has a case. But it gets better. Let’s say seismographs show an underground structure similar to other areas that produce X amount of natural gas and the farmer, with even a modest 12.5% royalty, might expect to receive another $300,000 over the course of 20 years–he’s been further harmed by that amount.
Having laid out such a scenario, a couple of things are obvious: Even if this bill passes and is signed into law (which we earnestly hope happens), landowners have a tough slog ahead of them. They will have to produce experts and hire a legal team to prove harm. There is no class action with this legislation. Every landowner’s situation is unique and there is no way to combine people into a class action to make the process easier or quicker. The best result from passing this legislation would be for Cuomo, and the towns that previously passed bans, to rethink their actions. Hopefully they would see the light: they face bankruptcy if landowners in large numbers start filing successful lawsuits against them. They will have no choice but to allow shale drilling.
But wait! (you say). The judges in New York State, even those not appointed by Cuomo, have proven their willingness to put their own jobs and politics above the law. You’re very perceptive. If we get this law passed and then liberal, Cuomo-appointed judges toss out the cases, we haven’t made any progress.
That’s why there’s Section 6 in the law – which removes these cases from state court and puts them in federal court:
IN GENERAL – A property owner may file a civil action under this Act to challenge the validity of any agency action that adversely affects the owner’s interest in private property in either the United States District Court or the United States Court of Federal Claims. This section constitutes express waiver of the sovereign immunity of the United States. Notwithstanding any other provision of law and notwithstanding the issues involved, the relief sought, or the amount in controversy, each court shall have concurrent jurisdiction over both claims for monetary relief and claims seeking invalidation of any Act of Congress or any agency action defined under this Act affecting private property rights. The plaintiff shall have the election of the court in which to file a claim for relief.
Section 6 is the other KEY aspect of this bill. If the court cases remain in state courts, there is a built-in conflict of interest for judges to rule against them. Remove the cases to the federal level and that bias disappears.
The following is a summary of the provisions in the bill, sent by Congressman Reed’s office:
Summary of Defense of Property Rights Act “DOPRA”
This land is our land: affirming property rights and fair compensation
Private property is essential to our freedom as Americans. The right to private property was recognized by our Founding Fathers in the Fifth Amendment, which states that “… nor shall private property be taken for public use, without just compensation”. This clause is a central tenant of the Fifth Amendment and critical to the fundamental property rights of all private property owners as American citizens. Unfortunately the Federal Government, States and local governments have infringed upon these rights by limiting the use of property and adversely affecting the property’s value by various Governmental actions. DOPRA stands with citizens to protect these rights.
The Defense of Property Rights Act (DOPRA)
Compensation
* Provides opportunity for compensation for property owners when government action significantly impairs the value of ownership of their property.
* Promotes accountability by making government actors liable for compensation to impacted property owners as a result of burdensome government actions.
Legal Reform
* Streamlines Federal Court process to ensure an avenue to adjudicate claims
* Helps ensure fundamental fairness is provided to property owners
In addition to the important points noted above the DOPRA:
* Significant impairment of property rights is set at $20,000 or 20% of property value whichever is less
* Establishes a 6 year statute of limitations
* Allows attorney fees to be awarded to prevailing property owner
* Sets in place an arbitration or alternative dispute resolution process between parties
* Ensures nothing in the bill is construed with the State authority to create additional property rights
* Takes effect upon enactment.
This is what the JLCNY says about it:
Dan Fitzsimmons, President of the Joint Landowners Coalition of New York said: “We are extremely pleased that Congressman Tom Reed (NY-23) has introduced federal legislation in response to Governor Cuomo’s theft of property rights in the Southern Tier. We are especially proud that JLCNY board member Neil Vitale accompanied Congressman Reed to the President’s State of the Union Address, highlighting our fight for the rights of New York landowners.”
Congressman Tom Reed released the following statement:
“Far too often private property owners are left on the sidelines while local, state and federal governments’ make decisions for them on what they can and cannot do with their property. This is not right; it is not fair; and it is not the American way. These actions by government entities often leave our neighbors and friends with property that is worth much less, hurting their families and leaving them little choice but to accept the lower value.
“That is why I invited Steuben County farmer Neil Vitale to the State of the Union this week. I wanted to highlight those unjustly and unfairly impacted by adverse government action. I care deeply about the farmers and families of Western New York, which is why I am putting this concern into action.
“As a result, I have introduced a bill to defend Neil Vitale and all those unfairly harmed by government. This legislation would allow our friends and neighbors the option to seek compensation for their loss and provide a more fair process in our court system.
“I appeal to our highest of American ideals – fairness and doing what is right. And today I believe we have taken a big first step in defense of fairness and in defense of private property rights.”
Scott Kurkoski, attorney for the JLCNY said: “Congressman Reed’s Defense of Property Rights Act provides that government may not take private property, including oil, gas and mineral rights, in part or in whole, temporarily or permanently, without just compensation. The Act will allow all landowners aggrieved by Governor Cuomo’s hydraulic fracturing decision to pursue Fifth Amendment claims for the taking of their mineral rights. It will also level the playing field by allowing us to pursue these claims in federal court.”
Here is a copy of the bill as introduced by Congressman Reed.
Special Recognition: We’d like to give Scott Kurkoski, attorney for the JLCNY, a hat-tip and “thank you” for responding to our questions about the proposed law, and for enlightening us on its provisions. If anything in the above explanation is not 100% correct, we take full responsibility (it’s not Scott’s fault). Every time we “play lawyer” we get in trouble! Hopefully we’ve steered clear of that this time. Thanks Scott!
For more great articles on the subject of natural gas development every single day, subscribe to Marcellus Drilling News using this convenient link.
Check out what else is new at NaturalGasNow today!
While you’re at it, follow us on Facebook, Twitter and Linked-In!


Pingback: Congressman Reed Proposes Landowner Compensation | ShaleNOW
This bill is probably another attempt by Reed to look like he is doing something when, in fact, nothing will happen. (For instance, he has voted for stand alone bills defunding Obamacare that had no chance of becoming law). What are the chances this bill will become law? Many legislators introduce bills that look good but will go nowhere just so the legislators can look like they are favoring something. Second, as the article points out, it will be very difficult to establish a value and, of course, the government being sued will challenge those “expert” opinions. Save any praise for Reed until he actually achieves something.
This bill is not needed as both the NY Constitution and the US Constitution already cover this. Just another diversion to get us to think he’s on our side.
My ? goes like this.. if I took 20,000$ as comp for my oil rights being denied, and 3 years from now Gov elect Jones allows fracking, do I still own the oil or can NYS claim I was comped and the oil is THEIRS??? In legal parlance–you only get one bite of the apple..
It’s unfortunate that we ended up with a governor who thinks he was elected dictator of a third world nation, aka, the New York State, Southern Tier. The issue at large here is whether or not New York State Landowners have the right to mine the minerals that exist beneath the surface of their land. Thirty two other states in the United States are mining those very same minerals as of right now. Unfortunately, Cuomo doesn’t possess the necessary leadership skills that are required of a supposed to be unbiased setting governor, and just relies on the opinions of equally uninformed partisan handlers, like Robert Kennedy, Jr. He, Cuomo, got elected by New York City dwellers who for the most part, have no idea where their water, or natural gas heat comes from. It’s a shame, but Cuomo’s turned out to be just a partisan marionette for his New York City base, which definitely doesn’t include the New York State, Southern Tier Landowners. Cuomo has already proven to be an extremely partisan political bean counter, who only represents Andrew Cuomo. Bouquets to Congressman Tom Reed and Scott Kurkoski! Thank you both for all that you do. Let’s set a goal of a Cuomo free New York State as soon as possible.
I for one am glad to have a representative speak up for our rights. Say what you want, but Tom Reed has guts enough to take a stand. How many other politicians have the guts to do that? Like him or not, he has been on our side from day one.
Sincere thanks to all involved in this effort but lets just RECALL CUOMO !! And Tom ,as much as i want to see all NG move forward I say PIPES ? We need Permits befor we need pipes! Them pipe permits will only help those we are being victomised by. And to Cabot, We in NY look to you for help, please delay the plans to heat NYC. If we let them have their way all of you folks in Pa. will be attacked next ! We may as well circulate petitions to to tax Wall street too? Why feed the beast?
In Western PA – I thought the judge ruled something like a delayed damages case. In this case the judge suggested the adverse extended beyond the royalty owners, but all associated business interest. Think this was for individuals that just help the mineral and gas rights – not both. I may be wrong.
The importance of this bill appears to be lost on previous posters… it is tailor made to allow us to fight back and prevail against the corrupt NY court system. Both houses of Congress are GOP so if there is no Obama veto we finally have a chance. If passed into law, some well heeled large landowners will have to go first on this as the initial suits will be costly, but thank you Tom Reed.