…
…
The juxtaposition of two stories from yesterday perfectly illustrates the corrupt influence of fractivist foundations and their funders on our energy policy.
Our contributor and friend Jim Willis, over at Marcellus Drilling News, covered a story yesterday about the way two fractivist outfits from the Philadelphia area, both of whom are on the payrolls of elitist fractivist foundations, are attempting to bully local officials in Western Pennsylvania. Another story, in The Daily Signal, addressed the outsized inside influence of the Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC) in the development of the EPA’s new carbon rules. Both stories lay bare the corrupt influence of these foundations and non-governmental organizations in setting our energy policy.
Here’s Jim’s take on what he calls “The Martian Chronicles” (his version):
The Martians are getting an assist from the Delaware Riverkeeper herself (Maya van Rossum). Get this: The Delaware Riverkeeper, along with another anti-drilling group called the Clean Air Council (both based near Philadelphia), have filed an appeal with Adams Township (Butler County), Pa. over the township’s decision to grant Rex Energy permits to drill gas wells 3/4 of a mile away from the Mars public school.
Back in June, Adams Township supervisors voted 4-1 to allow drilling to commence, subject to getting permits from the Dept. of Environmental Protection. Just a month ago, Rex got the permits from the DEP to begin drilling. Some Martian parents objected, and found a sympathetic wallet all the way across the state in Philadelphia with van Rossum.
What does Butler County, on the western edge of PA have to do with van Rossum’s Delaware River Basin group, which is focused exclusively on the eastern edge of Pa.? NOTHING. Except for her personal hatred of fossil fuels and willingness to spend her own (and other people’s) money to fight shale drilling wherever it happens.
Adams Township is, understandably, a bit shell-shocked to have big Philly pressure groups descend on them with threats of lawsuits. The supervisors say they’ll schedule a hearing next month on the matter. Meanwhile, Rex continues to push dirt around and get ready to drill.
And, here’s some of what The Daily Signal has learned about the NRDC’s role in the new EPA carbon rules:
Claiming 1.4 million members and online activists, the Natural Resources Defense Council lobbies and litigates for “curbing global warming” and “creating the clean energy future,” among other issues.
The organization, founded in 1978, has received $1.9 million in EPA grants since January 2009.
Allegations of the environmental group’s undue influence arose July 6 whenThe New York Times reported on the EPA’s close relationship with three of the organization’s principals—lawyers David Doniger and David Hawkins and scientist Daniel Lashof.
“The three were as seasoned and well connected as Washington’s best-paid lobbyists because of their decades of experience and the relationships they formed in the capital,” reporter Coral Davenport wrote.
The trio’s 110-page proposal, focused on cutting carbon pollution from coal-fired power plants, was “widely viewed as innovative and audacious,” the article said, adding: “On June 2, President Obama proposed a new Environmental Protection Agency rule to curb power plant emissions that used as its blueprint the work of the three men and their team.”
…
On Sept. 4, two days after Vitter and Issa [two members of Congress investigating the latter] pressed their questions in their letter to McCarthy, the Natural Resources Defense Council denied in a blog post that it had influenced the actions of the EPA “outside of the normal regulatory process.”
But the emails between EPA chief McCarthy and Doniger, the green group’s policy director for climate and clean air, reveal close communications dating back to 2010.
McCarthy was assistant administrator at the EPA from 2009 to July 2013, when the Senate confirmed Obama’s nomination of McCarthy as administrator after a four-month confirmation battle in which Vitter posed more than 500 questions.
Of her agency’s announcement just before Christmas 2010 of amendments to the mandatory reporting of greenhouse gases, McCarthy emailed Doniger, “this success is yours as much mine.”
The Daily Signal also published the e-mail from which this line came and some others showing the collaboration between the EPA and its special interest collaborators.
It’s all very reminiscent of what the Northern Wayne Property Owners Alliance discovered when it secured, under the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA), some of the correspondence between the Delaware Riverkeeper and the Delaware River Basin Commission (DRBC). That’s when it learned of the extremely cozy relationship between Maya van Rossum and friends with Carol Collier, then the Executive Director of the DRBC.
That relationship included free-wheeling access by the Riverkeeper to the DRBC files and staff (without having to pay for FOIA charges until months later, for example), Riverkeeper presence on five of the seven DRBC committees and DRBC use of the Riverkeeper as an ally in securing funding for the agency. We published some of those e-mails (must reading) here. They demonstrate a very similar pattern to what happened with the EPA and the carbon rules; the agency and the special interest organization worked together on policy, shared funding and got each others’ backs as fellow warriors against other “stakeholders.”
The bond is much stronger than that, however, because all these entities are connected through the fractivist foundations that fund them. Why are two Philadelphia-based organizations (one whom’s mission is specifically the Delaware River) spending their time harassing a township in Butler County way out there on the Ohio border? Because both of them are funded by the Pittsburgh-based Heinz Endowments. The Clean Air Council and Delaware Riverkeeper organizations are both run by attorneys who have never done much of anything else to speak of and are paid by Heinz to engage in the fractivist activity that consumes their daily lives. It’s a “have gun, will travel” relationship.

Both organizations and the NRDC (as well as the DRBC in a shameful lack of objectivity and corruption of the public interest) have also been funded by the William Penn Foundation. It is allied with the NRDC’s sister organization, the Open Space Institute, which seeks to buy up as much of the Catskills and Upper Delaware regions as it can and is headed by a Rockefeller descendant who also funds the Riverkeeper. It’s a web of fractivist foundations and their special interest toadies. The NRDC also receives funding from the EPA while being deeply involved in setting its carbon policy.
Here is one tiny example from the FOIA material gathered by the Northern Wayne Property Owners Alliance; an e-mail from Will Price at the Pinchot Institute (also funded by the William Penn Foundation) to Carol Collier, who simultaneously served as chair of that group while doing Executive Director duty at the DRBC.
From Will Price
To Collier, Carol
Sent Friday, March 30, 2012 3:01 PMCarol.
I hope you are well, and enjoying what appears to be in the far window a beautiful day. You had mentioned when we talked that you may be meeting with Diane Scrauth re: her departure from William Penn.
The reason I ask is that I spoke for a while yesterday with several folks from the Open Space Institute, who have been working with Penn on the Delaware Bayshores Initiative. OSI Is working with Andy Johnson at Penn who I don’t know, but with whom Diane checked when I was talking to her about including the Delaware in OSI’s re‐granting initiative.
OSI is now working with Penn to revamp their focus to watersheds, to perhaps include the Delaware and/or Susquehanna, so I want to help make sure this happens. But I also would like to connect with Andy directly rather than just OSI. Before I do so, and setup a get‐to‐know you meeting with Andy, I wanted to check in with you on whether you know him and their interest in expanding their re‐grant program.
Incidentally, OSI also seems to have some reservations on whether there is too much uncertainty around gas to justify significant conservation investments in the Delaware. A point we discussed at some length, which to my mind is all the more reason to make conservation investments in the basin.
Thanks,
Will
Then, there’s this exchange between Collier and van Rossum (bearing in mind they were both heavily funded by the William Penn Foundation):
From Collier, Carol
To ‘keepermaya@delawareriverkeeper.org’
Sent Wednesday, April 18, 2012 7:27 AMMaya, how are you doing? Can you give me an update about the petition on making the upper Delaware EV? I understand it was before the EQB yesterday. Anything we can do to provide data or write support letters? Are the Conservation Districts involved? I know Susan Beecher felt strongly about this.
Thanks,
CarolSubject Re: Delaware River ‐ PA EV
From Maya K. van Rossum, Delaware Riverkeeper To Collier, Carol
Sent Wednesday, April 18, 2012 9:25 AMThanks so much Carol for your support and offer of help. The EQB voted yesterday to move the petition forward in the process. Here is our press release http://www.delawareriverkeeper.org/resources/PressReleases/FINAL.press%20re lease%2004.17.12.pdf. I’m sure a letter of support from the DRBC would be very valuable. I’ll pass your email on to Faith as she is the lead and can best give guidance on how and when to best tap in.
One of the best ways for the DRBC to help is to prioritize the analysis of the data collected on the tributaries covered by the petition which were taken by DRBC staff. If our offering a bit of money to help cover the cost of analysis is appropriate and helpful let me know.
Thanks again Carol. Really appreciate your support and outreach.
Maya
How does one tell the government agency from the non-governmental in the case of the DRBC or the EPA? The answer is that one cannot. These entities are all hopelessly compromised and corrupted by their incestuous relationships. That’s the real story here and one that won’t get told nearly enough as the events in Mars Township and the EPA’s publication of its carbon rules are reported. The Mars Township Supervisors may never know, in fact, who is really trying to intimidate them or that they’re just pawns in a corrupt chess game being played by some of the wealthiest people on earth against the middle class, but that’s what it is.



We know they are corrupt. What I Don’t understand is why we keep letting them run our lives. I say we all ignore them and get a gas company with some back bone drilling up here in Wayne county.
There are ways to develop gas without using significant amounts of water and what you suggest may be an option at some point.
Hopefully with the changing of the guard, new ED, we in the basin can move forward with development and put an end to special interest influence using science based factual information.
Very interesting that they say there is enough uncertainty in regards to natural gas development that it would be unwise to invest in purchase of land for conservation. Do they know that waterless drilling is a real possibility and would shut down the DRBC’s command over our rights to access our own resources? We must find ways (and they do exist) to shut down this pressure to purchase lands in the upper basin and make it a of region devoid of humans (except the rich and privileged who are members of the conservancy owning the land – how convenient for them).
Move the school! Jack the fool thing up and drive a trailer under it. And most importantly, BOYCOTT Duncan Hines products !!! And all the rest of their mega money drains on US consumers. Let um sell their products where they do their banking!