Tom Shepstone
Shepstone Management Company, Inc.
The virtues of shale gas are clear, unmistakable and so obvious we sometimes lose sight of them in the arguments over details. Shale gas is a not only an energy revolution, but a healthy one.
Richard Muller has been a Professor of Physics at the University of California, Berkeley since 1980 and, together with his daughter Elizabeth, recently authored a report on shale gas for the Centre for Policy Studies, a free-market neoliberal British policy think tank, that should be getting a lot more attention than it has. Why? Because, this is what it says:
…shale gas is urgently needed to address the greatest human-caused environmental disaster of our time, rising levels of air pollution, currently causing over three million deaths per year worldwide. At the same time it can dramatically slow the rate of global warming, and, as a bridging fuel, provide the time we need to develop truly sustainable non-carbon energy sources. The main dangers of shale gas can all be addressed by regulation to ensure that development is done using industry best practice, with heavy fines for malefactors.
Strong words, and they’re backed with equally compelling data.
Shale Gas Is A Serious Health Issue
The Mullers have put together one of the most comprehensive, yet succinct, apologetics for shale gas out there. Negative stories based on what is almost always speculation tends to get out of the gate faster with media folks looking for bleeding leads, but the only narrative that matters is the one that goes into the history books and when they are written about our times it will be said this was the time of the revolution that changed everything.
Shale gas is the printing press, the cotton gin, the telephone and the micro-chip all rolled into one. It is already spawning economic development everywhere and changing the balance of power in our world, but it’s greatest impact will be in the human health it improves, including that of these Chinese children.
The report is entitled Why Every Serious Environmentalist Should Favour Fracking. Here is a short introductory video:
The Muller case builds on one very simple foundation; that microscopic dust particles created primarily by burning coal and secondary chemical reactions are killing as many as 3.2 million people per year globally, primarily in places such as China and India, but also Europe and other places where coal use is heavy and populations are dense. This particulate matter, which is typically 2.5 microns or smaller in size is called PM2.5 for short. The particulates are small enough to penetrate our lungs, get absorbed into the blood and cause cardiorespiratory disease, which kills.
There is also a website that summarizes some of the key points, but it is the report itself that must be read to learn why shale gas is the antidote to this world health problem. Here are selected passages that tell much of the story:
Natural gas offers a practical and relatively quick way to stem the rise of PM2.5 air pollution. At the same time, as an alternative to coal, it offers an important opportunity to significantly slow the growth of CO2 emissions.
The cleanliness shale gas delivers is intrinsic. Compared to coal, shale gas results in a 400-fold reduction of PM2.5, a 4,000-fold reduction in sulphur dioxide, a 70-fold reduction in nitrous oxides (NOx), and more than a 30-fold reduction in mercury. As a result of coal-to-gas transition, over the last 15 years, the electric power derived from coal in the US has dropped by 1/3, replaced by shale gas power. This reduction, in turn, is responsible for much of the unanticipated drop in US greenhouse gas emissions during that same period.
Shale gas can help address the global warming issue too [as the] CO2 produced per kilowatt-hour of electricity from gas is only one third to one half that of coal. Natural gas consists primarily of methane, CH4, and when methane is burned more than half of the energy comes from the hydrogen which burns into harmless H2O – water. In contrast, when carbon burns, all the energy comes from creating carbon dioxide.
The increases in atmospheric CO2 that we are observing is coming largely from expanding coal use in developing countries. If their increased energy needs can be met from natural gas instead of coal, we can slow global warming by a factor of two to three. That means that instead of having 30 to 50 years before we reach twice the preindustrial carbon dioxide levels in the atmosphere, we might have 60 to 100 years or more. In that time, the cost of solar, wind, energy storage and nuclear could drop to a level at which they can be afforded by the developing world; we may even have fusion energy, or something we have yet to dream of. In fact, with the hoped for economic growth, there may be little of developing world that is undeveloped in 50 years, and the whole world could afford to use zero carbon energy sources even if the cost of solar and wind were to remain high.
Cheap natural gas can also make it easier for solar and wind energy to further penetrate electricity markets by providing the rapid back-up that those intermittent sources require. In addition, natural gas is the only base load fuel that can be downscaled into microgrids and distributed generation networks to provide that same flexibility and reliability for solar energy on rooftops and in buildings, expanding the market for urban solar systems. Particularly for areas focusing on distributed generation, natural gas can be an enabler of wind and solar.
But why is shale gas needed in the developed world – a world that can afford to pay the premium for solar and wind? The fundamental reason is speed. Europe can develop shale gas far more rapidly than it can move to solar and wind, largely because of the low cost, the absence of an intermittency problem, and good existing gas infrastructure. To the extent that shale gas replaces coal, it will save hundreds of thousands of deaths each year, lives that will be lost if we choose the slower and more expensive transition to renewables. In addition, shale gas can enable Europe to quickly follow the US lead to lowering greenhouse gases. Coal use is still widespread in Europe. In 2009, it produced 28% of the electric power in the UK, 56% in the Czech Republic, and 42% (more recently up to 50%) in Germany.
The air pollution crisis in China and in the rest of the developing world is only beginning. We observed on recent trips to China that many people mistakenly believe any level of pollution below an Air Quality Index (AQI) of 250 is just “haze” and rarely bother to put on masks. When the PM2.5 levels rise above this, the government issues radio alerts and most residents mask up. The average AQI in Beijing10 this year has been 159, in the unhealthy range; the US mean is 45.
As the pollution grows it will soon be a mask day every day. Foreign businessmen who recently flocked to China as the land of opportunity now spend as much of their time as possible out of the country. Air pollution makes it an unattractive place to raise a family. Chinese citizens who have the capability of living abroad are doing so. The Chinese government is deeply concerned about this brain drain.
We must help the world switch from coal to natural gas. This is not just a public heath issue but a humanitarian one. We need to advance shale gas technology as rapidly as possible and to share it freely. We are in the midst of the greatest environmental catastrophe of modern times, but we are also in the midst of an energy revolution, comparable in significance to the 1849 US gold rush.
Shale gas, with its near-total reduction of PM2.5 pollution provides a solution to the pollution. It can be a clean technology, and even though it will not halt global warming, only energy conservation offers a more affordable way to slow it. Environmentalists should recognize the shale gas revolution as beneficial to society and lend their full support to helping it advance.
Delays in Approving Shale Gas Are Killing People
The Muller report is well documented and they do a very effective job dispensing with some of the baseless fears regarding fracking and shale gas, using very new data in many cases. Ultimately, their analysis is the scientific articulation of common sense; not losing sight of the forest for the trees.
They say “environmentalists who oppose the development of shale gas and fracking are making a tragic mistake” and then go on to prove it. They also answer, in very short order, what Governor Andrew Cuomo says he keeps putting his Health Commissioner on a jet plane to learn; shale gas will deliver a healthier world. Delays in accepting that simple fact are killing people right now, which is something for which the supposedly humanitarian Heinz, Park, Rockefeller and William Penn foundations who finance the shale gas opposition ought to be called to account. They’re not humanitarians; they’re hustlers and people denied the benefits of shale gas are dying as a result of their NIMBY agendas.


Pingback: Marcellus & Utica Shale Story Links: Wed, Dec 11, 2013 | Marcellus Drilling News
Pingback: The Shallow Motivations of Hydraulic Fracturing Opponents - Natural Gas Now
Pingback: The Health Benefits from Shale Gas Development - Natural Gas Now