Tom Shepstone
Shepstone Management Company, Inc.
…
…
A junkyard plaintiff and his fractivist attorney try feeding PennLive and other sympathetic journalists a diet of antimony baloney but the food is spoiled.
A litigious junkyard plaintiff with a mug shot by the name of Loren Kiskadden has twisting the courts into knots for years now under the tutelage of fractivist attorney John Smith, who is a favorite of the Delaware Riverkeeper and other Heinz and Haas family shills plowing their money into fighting gas drilling. I first wrote about Kiskadden in 2012 over at Energy In Depth, laying out the absurdity of his claims given the location of his unmaintained water well in the middle of his massive junkyard, some 2,900 feet removed from the Range Resources well he claimed was the problem. Then, earlier this year I followed up on the case here. Then, in June, I reported on the Pennsylvania Environmental Hearing Board (EHB) ruling that Kiskadden simply didn’t have a case.
If you thought that was the end of it, though, you haven’t dealt with Loren Kiskadden or John Smith, who seem to have access to a bottomless money supply to finance their activities and recently announced their intention to pursue the matter still further. They also supplied some antimony baloney to PennLive reporter Candy Woodall for consumption by her “Shale Bargain” series readers.

General location of Loren Kiskadden water well.
Here’s some of that antinomy baloney from Woodall’s piece (emphasis added);
Kiskadden’s lawyers appealed the decision on behalf of their client, who maintains he has not had clean water in more than four years due to nearby drilling operations.
Citing new evidence, Washington County attorneys John and Kendra Smith last week asked Commonwealth Court to vacate the June EHB decision.
The new evidence was discovered during recent depositions in another case with Range Resources subcontractors and allegedly shows the company was using tracers in 2009, which was not disclosed during the EHB trial last year, according to court documents.
Range Resources disputes that claim.
Chemical tracers, including chlorides and isotopic analysis of methane, were heavily relied upon during the EHB hearing and determination, a company spokesman said…
DEP is still evaluating “the accuracy and relevance” of the information in Kiskadden’s most recent filing in Commonwealth Court, department spokesman Neil Shader said in an email on Friday…
At issue are chemical tracers that act like liquid barcodes and can tell drillers how successful or deep their frack is. They can also be used to detect water contamination, scientists said.
It really depends on the type of tracer being used, regulators said.
Shale drillers often use low-activity radioactive tracers, which have a 14-to-28 day lifespan, making them unreliable for determining water contamination, according to the DEP.
Some chemical tracers can last for upwards of several years, according to the court filing last week.
DEP does not routinely test for tracers, but could if additional testing was warranted by particular facts of an investigation, a department spokeswoman said in an email.
Kiskadden’s attorneys say the Environmental Hearing Board entered an order last year requiring Range to submit a list of all known chemicals used or brought to the site.
“That was necessary as Mr. Kiskadden had the burden of showing the board that the chemicals and products used, spilled and released at the site were the same constituents that showed up in his drinking water,” John Smith said in an email.
Despite the order, Range never revealed its subcontractors were using tracers or listed the multiple tracers being used and released at the drilling site, he said.
“We had no idea that tracers were used,” Smith said. “Range provided a list of companies and products used at the Yeager site which excluded the tracer chemicals and products, and the company performing the tracer services.”
Attorneys have now learned at least one of the tracers – antimony – used at the Yeager site was also detected in Kiskadden’s water. Prior to learning this new information, their client could not test for the constituent in his water, Smith said.
“Since we now learned new information…we requested that the appellate court vacate the decision and send it back down to the EHB to consider the new evidence that was withheld and to issue an appropriate sanction for withholding evidence,” he said.
This was after introducing the article by presenting Kiskadden, a junkyard operator with an unmaintained water well drilled in the middle of his decades old junkyard (and which penetrates coal seams and lacks controls to prevent surface runoff from the junkyard from pouring down the well), as just a simple gardener trying to grow a few tomatoes. Woodall does indirectly mention the junkyard and well by quoting the EHB decision, but then proceeds to buy into the the Kiskadden and Smith antimony baloney.
Why is it baloney? Well, there’s no better answer than the one just filed by John Quigley’s Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection (DEP), which is no friend of the gas industry. It is DEP’s response to the accusations raised by Kiskadden and Smith about antimony and other tracers. It speaks for itself and here are the relevant parts (emphasis added and legal references deleted):
In his Application, Mr. Kiskadden argues that this Court should vacate the EHB’s order and remand this matter for further proceedings because of the purported discovery of new “after-acquired evidence… This purported after-acquired evidence consists of:
1) information about chemical additives known as “tracers” used in hydraulic fracturing fluids at the Yeager Well Site;
2) a “draft” letter from the United States Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry (“ATSDR”), dated September 27, 2013, which reports and interprets certain water quality data for Mr. Kiskadden’s well water; and
3) information that a product used at the Yeager Well Site, SP -43X/Unhib A, contained ethyl-benzene and toluene…
Mr. Kiskadden claims that he learned that products with tracers were used at Range’s Yeager Well Site during an April 10, 2015 deposition in a related civil case… In the deposition, a representative of Multi-Chem Group, LLC, testified that its product, MC S-2510T, contains a tracer… At the time of this deposition, however, Mr. Kiskadden had known for almost two years that this product was used at Range’s Yeager Well Site. In a letter from Range’s counsel to Mr. Kiskadden’s counsel, dated August 20, 2013, Range identified products used at Range’s Yeager Site; MC S-2510T was identified…
Mr. Kiskadden does not identify when he received the draft ATSDR Letter… However, the Application suggests that it was received on May 1, 2015, which was almost one and one-half months before the Board issued its Adjudication… Moreover, the draft ATSDR letter states that the letter summarized a March 2013 conversation between Mr. Kiskadden, ATSDR, and EPA representatives regarding the analytical results for Mr. Kiskadden’s water well. Thus, the information in the letter was known to Mr. Kiskadden at the time of the EHB hearing in 2014…
Mr. Kiskadden also seeks relief based on his discovery in August 2015 that toluene and ethyl-benzene were present in a product used at the Yeager Site…
The facts in the three items identified in the Application were either known or presumed to exist prior to the Board’s adjudication, and therefore were not “after-acquired.” This information could have been presented to the Board.
Mr. Kiskadden learned that Range used products with tracers at the Yeager Site in April 2015, more than two months before the EHB’s Adjudication was issued. As discussed below, Mr. Kiskadden had available remedies to place this evidence before the Board by moving to reopen the record or seeking reconsideration but failed to use them.
Mr. Kiskadden had ample time to raise the “tracer” issue with the Board but chose not to do so…
Furthermore, even if the draft letter was new to Mr. Kiskadden, the information in it was not. The ATSDR Letter summarizes a March 29, 2013 conversation between Mr. Kiskadden and representatives of ATSDR and EPA… Thus, the facts and analyses in the letter were known to Mr. Kiskadden for several years and cannot be characterized as “after-acquired.”
…Finally, Mr. Kiskadden claims that he learned that toluene and ethyl-benzene were used at the Yeager Well Site… Mr. Kiskadden also avers that toluene and ethyl-benzene were detected in his water well… If these substances were present in Mr. Kiskadden’s water well, as he avers that they were, then they would have been subject to the EHB’s “rebuttable presumption” and would have been presumed to have been present at the Yeager Well Site… It would follow that these substances’ presumed presence as a matter of law makes the fact of their presence on the Yeager Well Site not new or after-acquired…
In this case, Mr. Kiskadden broadly asserts that evidence of the “tracers” requires this Court to vacate and remand to the Board… The EHB held that Mr. Kiskadden failed to prove the existence of a hydrogeologic connection and rejected his appeal… Mr. Kiskadden points to analytical results purportedly showing high levels of antimony in his well water on June 6, 2011 as relevant to prove a hydrogeologic connection… Antimony is one of the “tracers” he asserts that Range used…
Mr. Kiskadden’s assertion must be rejected because it is simply wrong. The analytical results cited are not an analysis of the quality of Mr. Kiskadden’s water. Rather, the results are for water from Mr. Kiskadden’s well that had been “spiked” by the Department’s laboratory by adding known amounts of substances, including antimony. This is done as part of the Laboratory’s quality assurance and quality control procedures.
The actual results for Mr. Kiskadden’s well water – i.e., water not “spiked” – do not show that antimony is present in his water… Mr. Kiskadden presented no evidence of a “tracer” in his water. The ample record regarding the absence of proven tracers for oil and gas fluids (the characteristic “fingerprint” for oil and gas related waters is made up of elevated chlorides, sodium, calcium, and metals, in this order of concentration) shows that Mr. Kiskadden’s “evidence” would not compel a different result…
Although legal argumentation is always redundant and somewhat hard to follow, it doesn’t get much clearer than this. The DEP has demonstrated, without any doubt, not only that Kiskadden and Smith are fibbers but, also, that their case is more frivolous than the latest Kardashian rumor. Kiskadden and Smith are clearly keeping this going because it’s part of a much broader narrative being spun by fractivist special interests (and trial lawyers such as Smith are among them, along with the funders of Smith’s numerous other fractivist initiatives). They managed to sell the antimony baloney to a gullible Candy Woodall, who was only too happy to acquire it in furthering her own ambitions and views, but it’s still baloney. The only real question is much longer this farce will run. The baloney is already spoiled and not even antimony (which looks a little like black pepper) can restore the taste.


Pingback: The Heinz Endowments and the Rippel Effect