Did PA Trial Lawyers Influence Act 13 Decision?

delaware riverkeeper - Tom ShepstoneTom Shepstone
Natural Gas NOW

 

Former Pennsylvania Supreme Court Justice Ronald Castille gets credit for the shallow Act 13 decision in 2013. Was he returning a favor to PA trial lawyers?

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court took an especially long time (513 days) to decide Act 13; finally and very conveniently rendering a decision on December 19, 2013, only 44 days after Chief Justice Ronald Castille was retained by voters for another year on the bench (he would reach mandatory retirement age only three months later and be forced to leave the bench at the end of 2014).

As I noted a few days ago in a post about the anything but charitable ways of the Delaware Riverkeeper, Justice Castille’s decision no doubt had to do with his desire to do some legacy building and secure the adoration of mainstream media for theoretically renewing the life of Pennsylvania’s Environmental Rights Amendment (although the celebration on that seems a bit premature). I also noted, though, he had conveniently received a $50,000 campaign donation from Philadelphia’s trial lawyers, which was exceptionally curious given he had only a year left to serve. Could this be the bigger reason; a desire to reward those who helped him get another year?

Why did Justice Castille want another year? There could be many motives but suffice it say he obviously wanted the power as long as he could hold onto it and was already engaged in a campaign of legacy building when he helped shoot down Pennsylvania’s voter identification law on spurious grounds. We do know why the trial lawyers wanted to invest $50,000 in him through their euphemistically named “Committee for a Better Tomorrow”, though, because they told us:

act 13

This same political action committee also donated $600,000 to Governor Tom Wolf’s campaign in 2014, which tells us a great deal about the values of Castille, Wolf and the Philadelphia Trial Lawyers Association. The Association includes several trial lawyers who would like to make money off fracking lawsuits, lawyers such as Kline & Specter (where former Republican turned Democrat Arlen Specter’s son Shanin is a partner). Shanin Specter also served as Ronald Castille’s campaign chair when he was running for Philadelphia District Attorney (Castille had previously worked for Arlen Specter). Shanin and his partner are both current board members of the Philadelphia Trial Lawyers Association.

Pennsylvanians for Modern Courts reported Justice Castille had previously said this about such donations:

The Pittsburgh Tribune-Review also examined the perception created by contributions to judicial campaigns.  According to Chief Justice Ronald Castille:

“It’s not a healthy situation. . . . I’ve seen those polls where the public thinks campaign contributions affect judges. It’s not healthy for the system. We want people to have confidence in the system.”

Somewhere along the line Justice Castille apparently decided it was healthy, after all, to take donations from trial lawyers who might appear before his court with a multitude of cases where they expected he’d “share their values.”

What might those “values” be, other than winning big-time contingency fee awards? Well, we can an idea from the activities of Attorney George Martin, a Past President of the Philadelphia Trial Lawyers Association, who also happens to serve on the board of EarthJustice. How interesting. EarthJustice filed an amicus brief in the Act 13 case.

act 13

Justice Ronald Castille – Friend of Philadelphia Trial Lawyers Association and Ant-Fracking Trial Lawyer Shanin Specter

What impact did all this have on the Act 13 decision? We can only speculate. It certainly isn’t comforting, though, to know a trial lawyers group, previously led by an EarthJustice board member, and where two lawyers actively seeking fracking lawsuits are part of the current leadership, invested $50,000 in keeping Justice Castille in office for a year while he considered where he’d come down on it – only to decide a few weeks after the election. Frankly, it smells and explains why Philadelphia is known as a “judicial hellhole.” Justice Castille came out of that environment and was funded by it.

And, by the way, the Philadelphia Trial Lawyers Association also gave a $50,000 donation for the retention of Justice Max Baer, a second justice in the 4-2 majority for upending Act 13. He reportedly received $150,000 for a retention campaign, even though it was known he’d have to retire in three years.

Please share this post and get the word out everywhere!

2 thoughts on “Did PA Trial Lawyers Influence Act 13 Decision?”

  1. It looks like the skunks in Philadelphia are mimicking Cuomo’s cesspool in Albany. Birds of a feather.

  2. Tom what makes you think giving the rights to state gov. to over rule local decisions is a good thing for those living in the local drilling areas .Possibly you’re letting your desire for wealth exceed your logic !What happened to smaller government .

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *