Climate, Coal, China and Change

Gas Drilling Impacts - Nick Grealy ReportsNick Grealy
Administrator of NaturalGas2.0, NoHotAir and ShaleGasInfo Blogs

 

These are truly wondrous times for the climate and the world gas industry. We’re seeing fundamental shifts in the entire energy field as coal is dying before our eyes. That is if we choose to look, something natural gas opponents in Europe are still much in denial about.  

Dieter Helm says we don’t have a 2C temperature change problem, we have a 5C issue. Climate Change via Carbon from Coal in China. We are replacing coal in China with the same prescription that works in the United States: efficiency, renewables and low cost natural gas.

Some will choose to ignore the role of gas at the same time they celebrate the “victory” of renewables.  Others will pretend we have to choose from a menu, instead of the prescription. It’s much like a course of penicillin: failure to take the whole medicine may make you feel good immediately but won’t prevent a recurrence of future problems.


Like climateanything else in nature, cross pollination of different energy sources will combine to provide innovative solutions. Efficiency and renewables alone won’t cure the outdated sickness we bring upon ourselves by continuing coal use.

Taking the drug analogy further, medicines often don’t work effectively because in the early stages they are prohibitively expensive. Someone has to pay for development, and it’s usually the richer patients, or countries. Drug companies more than anyone rely on patents, but after a while the formulation escapes into the wild and generic substitutes become available.

So too with natural gas as a key part of the prescription to cure coal. Natural gas and renewables thrive together in the US, and there is no reason to think that if the climate/carbon patient recovers in the world largest energy user and carbon emitter, the method won’t work in the second largest, China – or in Europe.  We need to think of Greenpeace, Friends of the Earth (and Russia and to a lesser extent OPEC), as playing the roles of patent trolls. They want to see oil and gas as premium fuels instead of generic, no name energy enabling them to price renewables – or expensive oil – accordingly.

The US shows, as, ironically, Greenpeace and Friends of the Earth point out constantly, that wind and solar are cheap fuels. The problem lies in knitting together an energy system that delivers them. These costs have to be grafted on to existing transmission systems and such mega projects cost the big money.

Developing nations have the considerable advantage of not being weighted down with old infrastructure. They have the advantage of building the new, and the best, at the same time. In this respect, telecoms provide a good example: Freed from the weight of fixed line telephony history, low cost entrants like Egypt’s Global Telecom provide mobile/cell service  that’s often better and cheaper in Cameroon than in Kent. In Europe and the UK, we’re weighted down with history and entrenched actors who invested billions in fixed line telephony that is evaporating before our eyes.

Emerging mega cites of Asia are being built with energy efficiency wired in. The problems in the developing world are worse in older cities like Beijing and Delhi where existing large cities had to develop using a coal model. But even there, new build is efficient by definition. A new apartment is not only more comfortable than a shanty town, it can be systematically programmed to use less energy overall. Counter to widely held green narratives, cities are naturally less carbon intense. Moving rural populations, as China’s five years plan states, is a win for the environment  while enriching the economy.

climate

The UK has a major problem with energy efficiency in older buildings that are often far more expensive than new build. But we do have a great advantage in the natural gas delivery system has been built and paid for. UK Greens are obsessed with a notion that natural gas will require major investment that will end up stranded, blocking new investment. That’s a key, and flawed, complaint often used to pretend that we can keep it in the ground and move straight to solar and wind.

Natural gas can act as a bridge fuel, but solar and wind alone have yet to build more than a clearing in the trees on the far bank of the climate river. Solar and wind on a mass scale are thought experiments, not reality. Perhaps green will have a sudden breakthrough of Apple like proportions, but if it does, natural gas, certainly in the UK, could rapidly empty the pipelines because they were paid for long ago. It’s hard to see from here if a no carbon technology would go from 200,000 users to 100 million in fifteen years like Global Telecom. But ten years ago, shale wasn’t on any menu or prescription either.

The shale industry was never meant to work. It was born out of years of hard work from academics like Terry Engelder, entrepreneurs like George Mitchell, Mark Papa and Harold Hamm, and unsung engineers, who spent years doing instead of talking. Some of those engineers are awaiting UK shale development, stuck like most of us in the tire kicking stage instead of the drilling phase. The shale revolution as paradigm shift was even more disruptive by being unexpected.  Releasing natural gas trapped in shale rocks was never thought technically possible. Shale has disproved the naysayers of the conventional industry and the snipers of the green movement to an extent none of the shale dreamers themselves (with the possible exception of Robert Hefner) ever imagined possible.

climate

Just like shale, many other things today are the result of sudden technological shifts no one foresaw. Moore’s Law may apply to shale, leading to constant innovation, but there could also be further game changers, China shale gas and Japan methane hydrates being only two. Too much of the green movement is stuck in the past and is rapidly approaching a moment much like the one the Venetians had in 1499 when Portuguese traders from India showed up on the Rialto – a moment when everything changed.

Many recent examples abound. UK Greens hold up the Stern Review of 2006 as an enduring, immutable Scripture. Yet 2006 also had Nokia phones and Blockbuster Video stores packed full of DVD’s people played on Windows computers, all based on the best technology available, and predictable, of the time. Creative Disruption need not be destruction for the open minded, but the new reality can blindside those facing only one direction.

Very, very few in 2006, would have dared think how the shale technology which first liberated natural gas would then move on to oil, increasing supply and causing what we have today. Simply put the unthinkable has become the new normal. Coal was cheap and available but dirty. Natural gas today is cheap, available and clean.

The coal industry is in crisis. It has failed to recognize the structural shift in power generation driven by regulation rather than price and has missed the window of opportunity to invest in clean coal technologies. Now it faces a slow King Canute style demise.

Friends of the Earth and Greenpeace sit in their thrones waiting to command the oceans not to rise. But they’re looking in the wrong direction as surely as Canute.

Coal is dying before our eyes. But we have to open them to see.

Please share this post and get the word out everywhere!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *