Severance Tax A Pension Sop, Not An Education Program

Severance TaxDenise M. Furey
Energy Consultant, University City, Philadelphia

 

…
…

Pennsylvania Governor Tom Wolf seems more interested in avoiding meaningful pension reform than funding education with his proposed severance tax.

Two years ago at the Marcellus Shale Coalition’s annual conference, Lt Gov. Jim Cawley warned Democrats in Harrisburg that one cannot both tax and ban shale-gas development. Unfortunately, the severance tax in Gov. Wolf’s proposed budget could unintentionally do just that.

The Pennsylvania legislature offered Wolf an alternative budget with no severance tax, but he promptly vetoed it. I hope the legislature sticks to its guns.

The weak price of natural gas already has resulted in a reduction in the number of rigs in the state, down from 116 in 2012 to 47 in March. A severance tax would only further curtail the drilling of new wells and eliminate related construction jobs, not to mention the income tax and other related state revenues from those activities.

Screen Shot 2015-07-09 at 6.14.05 AM

Restored Marcellus Shale well pad in Bradford County, Pennsylvania

Wolf’s plan would be particularly deadly to the sector. The governor wants to put a 5 percent tax, along with a fixed fee of 4.7 cents, on each thousand cubic feet of gas extracted. Also, he wants the tax assessed on a minimum price of $2.97. Today’s market price for natural gas is $2.86, which is already below that base. Perhaps more importantly, gas producers in Pennsylvania are reportedly receiving significantly lower prices – ranging from $1.20 to $1.80 – owing to inadequate transportation infrastructure.

At these prices, the tax works out to be as high as 16 percent, making it one of the highest in the nation. If Wolf gets his way, drillers will look to develop reserves in other states – effectively banning new development in Pennsylvania. The American Petroleum Institute estimates that Wolf’s plan would reduce the state’s gross product by $20 billion through 2025.

Wolf wants the proceeds from the severance tax earmarked for public education. Sadly, I doubt any large portion of these tax revenues will go to classrooms instead of ever-expanding pension expenses. Ninety-eight percent of municipalities that petitioned the state for exemptions to increase real estate taxes at a rate above inflation from 2010 to 2014 cited pension expenses as a cause. Our underfunded pension plans are a real problem, but we won’t solve them by derailing an industry that has been and could continue to be an economic engine in the state.

Screen Shot 2015-07-09 at 5.57.56 AM

Google Earth image of Central York High School Complex (Tom Wolf’s home area) – Note tennis courts in lower left. Underfunded?

I do not believe that the governor is an extreme environmentalist who wants Pennsylvania to exit the shale-gas business. He probably read the same Environmental Protection Agency report I did, which concluded that there is no evidence that hydraulic fracturing negatively affects water supplies. He did ban drilling on state land. But in many cases the state did not buy mineral rights when it bought land, so the governor may not be able to prohibit mineral owners from accessing their assets.

If I were a cynic, I would worry that callilng for the use of the severance tax to fund schools without addressing the pension crisis is a sop to the teachers’ unions that helped get Wolf elected. The drilling bans appear to be gestures to environmental groups, which also backed him last year.

I really do not believe this governor has a plan to derail the shale-gas industry. But given his actions to date, it appears that he has no concrete and coordinated policies for the sector (except to tax it), which to me is as frightening as a plan to ban development.

Please share this post and get the word out everywhere!

3 thoughts on “Severance Tax A Pension Sop, Not An Education Program”

  1. Until pension plans start side stepping Wall street and invest in the comunities they reside in these problems will continue.
    Money does not disapear, unless it is stolen!
    All NY or None ! Permits, then pipes!

  2. As they do in NY with Lottery and Gambling money they want the money to come to the state so they can control it and make the people come begging for a handout. Wolfes’ new tax plan may help the southern tier of New York. by making lpg fracking look more affordable to drilling companies. The pa gathering pipeline is only a mile from my place.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *