Jim Willis
Editor & Publisher, Marcellus Drilling News (MDN)
The Cuomo fracking ban was the subject of a giant protest yesterday in Binghamton as landowners rallied against the governor’s cruelly cynical decision.
New York landowners assembled in downtown Binghamton, NY at the Holiday Inn yesterday to attend a protest rally organized by the 70,000-member Joint Landowners Coalition of New York (JLCNY). The crowd at the rally was enormous–at least 500 people (perhaps more) who filled a banquet hall and spilled out into the corridor. The crowd was fired up and ready to do something to counter the Cuomo fracking ban in the Empire State.
I was there and witnessed something I have not previously witnessed: conservative, quiet, “salt of the earth” farmers and landowners were mad and loud and noisy and they wanted Gov. Cuomo to hear it. It seems Gov. Cuomo has stirred up a sleeping giant and that giant is now on the move. The one question on everyone’s mind at the meeting, What can we do now to fight the Cuomo fracking ban?
Scott Kurkoski, attorney for the JLCNY and a partner with Levene, Gouldin & Thompson, LLP, was the master of ceremonies. Scott kicked off the meeting with an expression of sympathy for the Cuomo family and the recent passing of Mario Cuomo. Kurkoski then pointed out many people, including Scott himself and others in the JLCNY, have lost a parent over the past several years while waiting for a decision to allow fracking to commence. Scott said “we’re fighting because our region needs opportunities” and “we will not give up!” Thunderous applause and cheers from the crowd followed Scott’s statements.

On Dec. 17, Gov. Cuomo held a cabinet meeting in which he hid behind the skirts of his commissioners of Health and Environmental Conservation, attempting to portray his political decision to ban fracking as a decision he had nothing to do with. Everyone sees through it. Dr. Howard Zucker, Acting Commissioner for the Dept. of Health, delivered the results of his department’s “studies” of fracking on public health. Zucker concludes there are too many unanswered questions and potential risks, which Joe Martens (Commissioner of the Dept. of Environmental Conservation, DEC) agrees with. Cuomo endorsed this farce.
During his opening comments, Scott made this highly damaging-to-Cuomo/Zucker observation: How is it that 35 other states currently allow shale drilling and have had not negative health impacts, yet Zucker concludes there’s a problem? Why did Zucker ignore published reports that indicate there is no public health problem, and instead rely on unpublished reports from select, anti-drilling sources? How is it that New York is the only state to “get it right” when it comes to a frack ban? Answer: New York is the only state that has gotten it wrong. Scott quoted President Obama’s Secretary of the Interior, Sally Jewell, who recently said frack bans are “the wrong way to go” (see Obama Sec of Interior Says Frack Bans ‘Wrong Way to Go’).
What Can We Do Now to Fight the Cuomo Fracking Ban?
Near the end of his talk, Scott squarely addressed the question on everyone’s mind about what the next steps will be to right the wrong of the Cuomo fracking ban. Scott said the JLCNY is “exploring all options” at this point. In other words, keep your powder dry and sit tight. They are not giving up–not by any means.
Scott offered the following specifics about the JLCNY’s strategy:
- First up, we have to wait until the final Supplemental Generic Environmental Impact Statement (SGEIS)–the draft rules that govern oil and gas drilling in shale–are officially filed by the DEC. Depending on what form the SGEIS takes will govern the response to it.
- The JLCNY continues talking to the Mountain States Legal Foundation. He said “they want to help us.” The Foundation will provide legal assistance when/if a lawsuit becomes necessary.
- The JLCNY has already begun working with local townships/municipalities to construct zoning ordinances to allow fracking. In the wake of last year’s NY Court of Appeals decision in the Dryden/Middlefield case, townships can outright ban all fracking. However, if they want to allow fracking, they must have an ordinance that specifically allows it. The JLCNY is assisting towns with drafting and adopting those ordinances.
- Finally, and the most interesting comment Scott made (for us), was this: The JLCNY is actively talking to companies like Gasfrac, a company with waterless fracking technology. In addition to Gasfrac’s liquefied petroleum gas (propane) fracking technology, the JLCNY is also investigating nitrogen fracking and carbon dioxide (CO2) fracking technologies. The current frack ban, depending on the final version of the SGEIS, prohibits high volume fracking that uses water only. It does not prohibit fracking that uses other substances–something sure to give the antis heartburn. They may see their “victory” disappear into a cloud of propane or CO2.
Scott was followed by a number of politicians who stand shoulder-to-shoulder with the JLCNY and New York landowners in this fight. First up was State Sen. Tom O’Mara from the Twin Tiers (Elmira) area. He was followed by Assemblman Chris Friend (with a PhD in chemistry), Assemblyman Cliff Crouch (a former dairy farmer himself), and Broome County Executive Debbie Preston. Preston had perhaps the biggest response from the crowd. She fired them up. Preston told them, “You’re too quiet! I’m afraid you’re giving up and you can’t give up.” She made it clear that she’s in the fight all the way.
Several more politicians or their representatives also addressed the crowd, along with representatives from three different labor unions. There were a number of union members in the audience. As the nearly two-hour meeting progressed, chants of “Hell no Cuomo!” could be heard. A recurring them from all of the speakers: Don’t give up.
The second-to-last speaker was the head of the Sullivan/Delaware Property Association, Bill Graby. Bill told the story of his own farm, holding on by a thread. He recently had to declare bankruptcy in order to keep the farm as his legacy to pass on to his kids–a farm that’s been in the family since 1860. The decision by Cuomo was a serious blow to Graby’s efforts to hold on to the farm. Increasingly, many other New York farmers are in the same boat. Graby also shared a funny story of an encounter with one of his “neighbors,” the anti-drilling celebrity Debra Winger, at a local town board meeting. Graby called her Debby and she huffily replied her name is Debra, not Debby. (Be sure you call her Debby if you ever see her!)
Concluding the meeting was JLCNY president Dan Fitzsimmons. He told those in the meeting to be sure and sign up for their email list and to stand by and be ready, at a moment’s notice, to support the cause by showing up at rallies and meetings, writing letters–however you may be needed. Dan said it’s important that we act and react rapidly, and being on the email list will help. Dan said Cuomo and the anti-drillers are “stealing from us.” He said, “This madness must stop.” His concluding comment: “Cuomo Must Go!”
For more great articles on the subject of natural gas development every single day, subscribe to Marcellus Drilling News using this convenient link.
Check out what else is new at NaturalGasNow today!
While you’re at it, follow us on Facebook, Twitter and Linked-In!


Pingback: Landowners Fired Up to Fight Cuomo Fracking Ban | ShaleNOW
I have a suggestion to grow your grassroots movement that is easy and cheap. Have a good Adobe PDF filewith you a simple message in which you membership can share . Make it standard page size and have those people print copies on your home printers that everyone has. We used to have these small milk deliver today signs we would put in our windows here. I took the same concept to campaign against an anti_ industry candidate . visiters to our supporters homes became aware on the door step of our cause. IT started conversations and gained supporter whom would ask where can
I get those to support your cause . the home owner would printer them off . The key for a movement is easy participation and comfort levels. With 500 people plus showing up and 70000 in an association of landowners you have a great base to spread yr displeasure with the Ban . A sign in a window is 24 hours a day for as long as you wish .
We had a mere 150 people out of a district of 20000 do the sign in window thing but the anti industry candidate was defeated by the largest margin of anyone in his governing party . It was the worst defeat in the history of Nova Scotia Politics for a Governing party cabinet minister . We don’t take all the credit but it certainly nudged the electorate
I couldn;t make the meeting but a few other suggestions to all:
1. Listen to Fred Dicker on talk1300.com. He is your one and only correspondent that is a pro-advocate
2. Stop buying the Press/Sun-Bulletin. You want to read it, set your browser to private and no subscription required
3. Stop buying lotto tickets in NY, go to PA
4. Make big purchases in PA, not NY, a short drive and buy gasoline, the lower gas prices will compensate for your time
5. Call Dr Zucker at his Montefiore office in the Bronx at 718-920-4317 and let him know how you feel
Ed – I like all your suggestions, and in fact have not bought a Press and Sun in decades and never will. Blatantly biased. I also want to add a big THANK YOU to the Holiday Inn!! I never go to downtown Binghamton anymore (avoid it at all costs) but I went there Monday, just as all 800 people did. Thank you JLCNY.
For #1, I was specifically referring to Albany correspondents. Tom Shepstone, EID and others are very fair and unbiased.
Also supercritical CO2 (liquid) is being developed as a fracking fluid. The challenge is compressibility, water is incompressible (think pipes banging from pressure changes), it is the high pressures that water can hold to crack the shale rock. An alternative fluid is needed to overcome Cuomo’s ban on hydraulic (aka water) fracking
Once you adopt the LPG-fracking technique, then we ALSO need to get NYS/Cuomo to also allow more LPG-storage in the area, and we have salt-cavities waiting to store LPG in high-volume in the Southern Tier at multiple locations!
As long as New York City is being supplied with all of the cheap natural gas they want, why should they, or our absentee governor give a damn about Southern Tier Landowners? This has to change and it’s time for the natural gas suppliers to exercise their ability to control the spigot by cutting the flow, and raising the price of natural gas to any entity that is hostile to natural gas drilling. We’re banging our heads against the wall and we’re not getting any help from the natural gas suppliers, etc, whatsoever. It’s time the natural gas companies get a dog in the hunt, and exercise their considerable clout and stop leaving the Southern Tier Landowners to twist in the wind. Message to Cuomo, if you outlaw natural gas drilling, you get no natural gas supply. He should not have a problem with that. Now should he?
sue the state for taking our right to develop our resources, landowners should be compensated.