K.J. Rodgers
Crownsville, Maryland
….
….
Those most against fracking all seem to use the same arguments over and over. It is almost as it someone made a handbook for them to follow.
Anytime a pro-natural gas article or meme is posted on Facebook, there are plenty of users trolling the posts and commenting with idiotic misconceptions of the truth. The logical stance is just to ignore them and let them continue to make a fool of themselves, but I have to admit; responding to these people’s posts is a guilty pleasure of mine.
I try my best to resist their attempts of dragging people into a virtual debate, but once in a while, I dive right in and argue back. There are a few key points these people say that wield enough temptation to draw me in and the more I see their defenses, common trends become more apparent.
It is interesting to me that almost all anti-fracking activists are in the same mindset. It is almost as if Mark Ruffalo and Yoko Ono penned a manual on how to argue against fracking. Just for fun, let’s look at this manual for dummies would read.

The Anti-Fracking Handbook for Dummies
Sponsored by Artists Against Fracking
Step 1: Follow Your Enemies
Any good activist needs to be aware of news feeds that promote natural gas. When anything positive about natural gas is posted to their audiences, you must not believe what it says. All energy sources other than renewables are dangerous to us all and any good news about them must, therefore, be fraudulent and fueled by the deep pockets of money-hungry big corporations. Proceed accordingly.
Step 2: Educate (Attack) Others
Fractivism is easy. You do not need to be a scientist to spread helpful information to the cause. Those in favor of fracking will try to use methods of logic, reason, or science to explain why they love their precious natural gas, but never fear, here are the key points you need to scream from a mountain (or your keyboard):
- Fracking causes water pollution. Fracking is a process that shoots thousands of gallons of toxins in the ground and it will pollute the water table. Try pointing out the EPA doesn’t like fracking that much by mentioning how Gina McCarthy, Administrator of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, has called for additional regulations because fracking is new. Importantly, though, pay no attention to the actual studies conducted by Yale and the EPA that are contradictory to this and if the latter happens to arise in discussion, dispense with it by accusing the industry of having overwhelmed regulators. We are not going to concern ourselves with so-called scientific proof – our proof is our ideas and ideas do not die.
- Fracking causes flammable water. We all know that water is not flammable, but when fracking has happened nearby, it’s not that hard to get naive people to think it can happen and fracking is to blame. Just ask Josh Fox how he was able to light water on fire from a water hose in Texas for his film, Gas Land 2. Well, better not use that example; he was apparently using artistic freedom by attaching it to a propane tank. Use Dimock! Dimock, Pennsylvania has water that catches fire from the faucet. Even though it has been proven this is a natural occurrence for the region; most people do not know that, so keep using it, just as Josh Fox does.
- The Halliburton loophole. Gullible people who want to believe businesses pollute can easily be convinced the process of fracking is so bad that companies seek out special exemptions to regulations. Selling them on the idea these fracking companies are not regulated and proceed to do what they want as if no one is watching, is a piece of cake. Simply proceed as if the only people not blinded by their influence are those of us leading the fight; make it your burden to educate the public on the fact fracking practices are not being monitored.
Step 3: Repeat
In the heat of the debate, you will be exposed to facts, scientific studies, and articles that claim fracking is safe, well-regulated, and beneficial to combatting climate change; don’t buy it. No matter, though, you must continue to use these three arguments, preferably in order, to wear your opponent down. It may take a while, but eventually they will quit and you will have won. If they do place you in a position of failure, see the section titled, “Vera Scroggins – How to Get in Their Faces” to learn how to use negative stereotypes and direct your anger in a way that’s sure to be noticed. Who can forget this example, after all?
Congratulations, you are now a fractivist. Go forth and troll.


this article is far from wrong and limited in it’s knowledge !
Brilliant expose of the idiocy spewed from the antis. Unfortunately, the non thinking idiots suck it up. Many call this garbage gospel. FEAR PORN. Chicken little lives on. I’m surprised he did not yet die of an anurism caused by excessive fear.. A massive stroke is likely. The world needs “fear therapists”. or perhaps soma laced kool-aide…
The Antis are sick and need help.
Mark Ruffalo and “Loko” Ono heat their many homes with good clean hydro fracked natural gas. They, and the rest of their phony sidekicks, are all sporting gas guzzling SUV’s too.