Busing Crowds to a Fracking Protest Is Entertainment, Not Sacrifice

Fracking by Natural Gas Advocate Vic FurmanVictor Furman
Upstate New York Landowner
Shale Gas Activist at NYRAD-R

 

Vic Furman challenges FrackAction and points out the absurdity connected with the rally against fracking that fractivists are planning In Albany. He says it’s entertaining.

Following up on my post of the other day regarding the Albany rally being planned by FrackAction, I decided to make a special request of the organizer. Her name is Renee Vogelsang and she claims to a “community organizer who has worked on energy, water, environmental and human rights issues since 2002, specializing in political, membership, fundraising, and legislative based campaigns.”  She says she’s worked with Food & Water Watch, Clean Water Action and the New York Public Interest Research Group and “lives on the road and sometimes in Syracuse, NY.”

FrackAction is a front for the Sustainable Markets Foundation, a Rockefeller entity run by the head of the New York Public Interest Research Group. Both the Sustainable Markets Foundation and Food & Water Watch are also funded by the Park Foundation, while Clean Water Action (Clean Water Fund) is funded by the Heinz Endowments. The Rockefellers, Park Foundation and Heinz Endowments are the three biggest financiers of the anti-fracking movement, all run by trust-funder descendants of old industrial families. Renee is on their payroll and they finance her current life “on the road.”

Renee Vogelsang – “Have Signs, Will Protest” Agitator

Ironically, part of Renee Vogelsang’s life, which she labels as that of an agitator, has, in the past, included some protesting against a National Grid rate hike and advocacy for “public power.” Here she is in 2011 making that case:

Fracking Protestor at Earlier Rally Against Rate Hikes

She was opposed to electric and gas rate hikes then and is opposed to the natural gas development now that would make it possible to lower those rates, as has happened in Pennsylvania, New Jersey and elsewhere due to the availability of inexpensive shale gas obtained by fracking. Holding herself to such double-standards must take a special brand of chutzpah and hippyocracy.

It is, in any case, quite clear Renee is a “have signs, will protest” sort of roadie. Call me cynical, but a life “on the road” today would seem to require the use of a vehicle. I also couldn’t help but notice she’s providing buses to haul fellow protestors to Albany from places such as White Plains, Rockland County, Brooklyn, Manhattan and Long Island, every one of these areas being a heavy natural gas user. That motivated me to make a special request of my own. Here’s what I sent her:

Renee,

Is there anyway you can schedule more buses to depart from Syracuse, Oneonta, and Walter Reed Military Hospital for the anti gas rally on Jan. 8th? I know it’s short notice, but I was talking with a friend of mine who has a friend who served in Iraq and lost a leg, both arms and an eye.

When I told him about the rally in Albany and what the goal was, he thought it quite possible that some of the people he served with would feel  it was their duty to show up in their wheel chairs and wearing their prosthetics…to line the hallways of the capitol of NY with a visual of those who fought for your right, and my right, to foreign fuel that we rely on to get your protestors to Albany.

I explained to him that you and people like Chip Northrup, Sandra Stiengraber and former Mayor Matt Ryan (who is so proud to have shirked his responsibility when his country called upon him during Vietnam) are not especially sympathetic  to the fact American men and women of the sand wars sacrificed so much for foreign fuel, but might even deny their request.

I told him how you and your friends make up stories, spread junk science, and play on peoples fears with falsehoods like Josh Fox’s lies about water being made flammable due to fracking. I told him how Lipski got caught loading the hose with gas,  how you and your friends are the best customers of fossil fuels because you use so much of them in your efforts to stop their use.

I  shared with him the facts about how states where drilling is allowed are benefiting through jobs and reduced local taxes (like Windsor, NY, where the school taxes decreased for homeowners by 8 percent just because of a compressor station built outside of town).

I shared with him the story of farmers in Dimock, PA and how they built a new barn and bought new tractors and beef cattle to raise because of natural gas development, but right over the border, not less the 30 miles away, a farmer watched his livestock get auctioned off, his tractors sell for pennies on the dollar.

Yes, Renee…he wants to go to Albany, not to stand with you but, quite honestly, to ride his wheel chair up and down the hallways and yell out “Drill a Well- Bring Home a Soldier.” I had to tell him Renee, that those of us who believe in American ingenuity do not have the funding you have, that Moveon.org didn’t offer 100 of pro-gas activists $500 each to fight fracking. Farmers, unlike some universities, can’t offer extra course credit just to show up in Albany and wave a sign made from a natural gas byproduct…

But true to his nature he said to me ” sacrifice is only known by those who have done so. These protestors flocking to Albany on fossil fuel powered buses and auto’s would be the first to complain if suddenly they got their wish and New York was cut off.  How loud would the screams from the Dakota building be if Yoko and Sean suddenly had no heat surging into their 8,000 square foot apartments because their natural gas supply was shut off?

How quick would Hollywood react if they couldn’t blow up buildings or race cars, because their fuel was cut off? How many protestors would go to Albany if they had to drive electric cars, stand outside and do their protesting in the cold instead of being inside a Capitol Building heated with gas and powered with electricity from gas…

You and your friends …you go to Albany, Renee, and protest yet again. This time, though, I suggest you begin your speeches with “Thank God for the fuel that got us here. Thank God for the warmth of the natural gas heated building we are gathered in. Thank God for the clothing, our boots and shoes. Thank God for our cell phones and the hot coffee that we have to drink because of fossil fuels.” Then, do your thing and yell out “Ban Fracking Now”  because quite frankly Renee… hypocrisy is quite entertaining even if you don’t give thanks, because we all know how you’ll get there.

Fracking BusRenee, unsurprisingly, didn’t answer my e-mail, so I guess my special request will go unheeded. Her little dog and pony show, financed by the spoiled super-wealthy residents of natural gas heated homes in Manhattan will, nevertheless, go on. They’ll power their way up to Albany on big buses, get out their plastic signs, march around natural gas heated buildings and then head back down the highway to the comfort of their own natural gas heated homes, all the while holding themselves in the highest of esteem for having opposed it all. It’s just another day in the life of the fracking opposition. It is undeniably entertaining, though. Maybe Renee could really take this thing on the road and do a reality show called “Fracktopia”–what do you think? I’ll watch.

follow-us-on-twitter  like-us-on-facebook  follow-us-on-linkedin

Please share this post and get the word out everywhere!

66 thoughts on “Busing Crowds to a Fracking Protest Is Entertainment, Not Sacrifice”

  1. I have never heard these people object to natural gas. They are objecting to the METHODS that natural gas is extracted. Make the gas & oil companies adhere to Clean Air Act & Safe Drinking Water Act and I bet you’ll see them come up with some high tech, clean, non toxic methods of extracting that gas. Then everyone would be happy.

    • Actually, they do adhere to those acts and HF has an enviable safety record. Moreover, one can’t talk natural gas today without fracking–without it there is only a declining resource. Finally, while I appreciate your sentiment and am inclined to that sort of positive view, I am not convinced any of opponents would not still be against it if every agency on earth endorsed it. They are anti-development by nature and especially so with regard to fossil fuels and they’d find a hundred new reasons to oppose it. That’s life in NIMBYland.

      • I think you are very wrong believing that anyone who opposes fracking as it is now, would oppose it if were proven clean and harmless. NIMBYland, as you so sarcastically refer to your neighbors is everybody’s backyard. At least we are not driven by money, but rather by genuine concern. What do suppose our motive is?

        Pennsylvania has confirmed at least 106 water-well contamination cases since 2005.

        In regards to the gas companies adhering to the safe acts, you could refer to the EPA’s own paper available on their site titled “Exemption of Oil and Gas Exploration and Production Wastes from Federal Hazardous Waste Regulations”

        http://www.epa.gov/osw/nonhaz/industrial/special/oil/oil-gas.pdf

          • The case to ban fracking grows stronger everyday. Fracking injects millions of gallons of fluids a mix of sand, water and chemicals, including ones known to cause cancer into the ground. The process of fracking introduces additional industrial activity into communities beyond the well.Clearing land to build new access roads and new well sites, drilling and encasing the well, fracking the well and general waste,trucking in heavy equipment and trucking out (not all but some) of the vast amounts of toxic waste-all of these steps contribute to air and water pollution risk and devaluation of land that are turning our communities into sacrifice zones.Fracking threatens the air we breathe, the water we drink, the communities we love and last but not least the climate on which we all depend.That’s why over 250 communities in the U.S. have passed resolutions to stop fracking, and why Vermont, France, and Bulgaia have stopped it.

          • This is a lot of speculative nonsense and baseless assertions. And, Vermont, doesn’t have any gas, so if they want to ban it that’s just fine but they’re also on record on wanting more supply. So much for their (and your) intellectual integrity.

        • Okay. Here is a wild ride:
          To understand the list of “HARMED” First you need to understand the game the antis play. Contamination vs pollution. Look it up. One is normal amounts , acceptably levels,but the use of the word Contamination is use to lead people to think pollution. They, the Anti spin docs rely on ignorance. The press also rely on ignorance to sell papers. Why would the press try and educate people when they have so much to gain? Top that off with the total lack of people understanding that PA has no regulations on water well drilling and no prior history baseline on methane in aquifers. But you wont find that in the mainstream media. Forget about the sins of the past from the coal industry deep beneath the surface. The mainstream are mushrooms fertilized by media.
          Our population has fallen prey to tabloid journalism that sucks on the buck to make payroll. Hey it business. I can no longer watch the news nor read a paper. I have made news and then read the reporters take of my news. Reporters /”journalists” that never took the time to pick up a phone to call and ask about any background. I can no longer stomach any politician knowing what I know, To be totaly honest I wish I never got involved in this battle.
          I hear people talking about a headline in the paper and its like they “know” they were their. It,s sad to see what has become of the general population. This battle is being won by the anti gas and anti everything because no one stands up anymore.
          Guns and guts will no longer be our demise. It is being won by people like the anti gas crowd that are puppets for the wealth and those that hate this country founded on one nation under GOD!.
          The same wealth and haters that use the anti to distract while they buy up mineral rights from the desperate. The same wealth that works our youth that work our school systems by way of indoctrination.
          Example:
          Once it was called working together and if you were not in it together you were an independent. You won together. Or you won based on your own effort.
          Then it became “Team” and if you were not a team player you were labeled not a team player. Now in our schools it is called a “cooperative” group. If you are not in the “cooperative” group you are labeled non cooperative..

          Will people ever wake up? Are they is a haze? Or is it they feel they are non team players that do not cooperators so why is it worth trying?

          Until the time that those non cooperative non team player stand up we will be preyed upon by those that know how use the politically correct hand of dominance to hold you down.

          The largest fear in NYS is for any group to become financially stable enough to put up their own non corrupt candidate to run for office.
          That is why they can push through Casinos rather than natural gas development.
          The few Casinos owners can be controlled and need politicians. Many landowner becoming wealthy might form teams and become cooperative.
          That my friends scares the shit out of old money and any existing politician.
          But thats just my delusional freedom of speech two cents.

    • Jennifer
      you don’t have to look far to see the rejection of natural gas, From the Ithaca Journel
      “Sandra Steingraber, Distinguished Scholar in Residence at Ithaca College, is focusing on the investment that will be wasted by using fossil fuels.

      “Rather than swapping one climate-killing fossil fuel for another, we could insist that the antiquated, coal-burning Cayuga Power Plant is transformed entirely, becoming an emblem of a renewable energy future rather than yet another incursion of the predatory natural gas industry into our beloved Finger Lakes,” Steingraber said. “In fact, we do so insist.”

      “FANCY WORDS OR FANCY BS….?

      as well as pipe line protest other plant conversions etc..etc…etc… the problem is the lie being told is we can convert to wind and solar AND THAT ITS GOOD FOR THE ENVIRIONMENT…. NOT TRUE.

      The reality many can’t seem to face is the truth before them and that truth is renewables in the future NATURAL GAS NOW!!!

    • I’ve heard plenty of them object to it and all fossil fuels. They don’t have a clue about all the products that we use in our everyday lives made from the byproducts of it. Not only is it fueling their buses but all of the components used to manufacture that bus was made possible with the help of fossil fuels. Same goes with the so called green renewables. It takes products derived from fossil fuels to manufacture them. Life saving medicines are another good example of a product made possible with them. That’s the whole point of Vic’s article.

      • Don; Each gas well requires an average of 400 tanker trucks to carry water and supplies to and from the site.
        It takes 1-8 million gallons of water to complete each fracturing job.
        The water brought in is mixed with sand and chemicals to create fracking fluid. Approximately 40,000 gallons of chemicals are used per fracturing.
        Up to 600 chemicals are used in fracking fluid, including known carcinogens and toxins such as…Mercury, Formaldehyde, Hydrochloric Acid, Uranium and Lead, are just a few of the chemicals used Bush/Cheney and the lobbyist for Halliburton made sure they don’t have to disclose to the public what they’re putting in the ground.8 million gallons of water per fracking and a well can be fracked 18 times.
        During this process, methane gas and toxic chemicals leach out from the system and contaminate nearby groundwater.
        Methane concentrations are 17x higher in drinking-water wells near fracturing sites than in normal wells.
        and
        72 trillion gallons of water
        and
        360 billion gallons of chemicals
        needed to run our current gas wells.
        Contaminated well water is used for drinking water for nearby cities and towns.

        There have been over 1,000 documented cases of water contamination next to areas of gas drilling as well as cases of sensory, respiratory, and neurological damage due to ingested contaminated water.
        Only 30-50% of the fracturing fluid is recovered, the rest of the toxic fluid is left in the ground and is not biodegradable.

        The waste fluid is left in open air pits to evaporate, releasing harmful VOC’s (volatile organic compounds) into the atmosphere, creating contaminated air, acid rain, and ground level ozone.

        In the end, hydraulic fracking produces approximately 300,000 barrels of natural gas a day, but at the price of numerous environmental, safety, and health hazards.

        Still think fracking is good clean energy?

          • Than can you please enlighten me to the chemicals in the fracking process, the industry won’t release that information? While your at it can you tell me how much is recovered please?

          • Tom I found your site to be funded by the energy commission and oil and gas companies too. I did find this as well thank you.
            The term “fracking” is short for “hydraulic fracturing.” Over the past 10 to 15 years, the number of fracking wells has expanded rapidly in the US, liberating increasing amounts of methane.
            What are the benefits?

            So much natural gas has been extracted through fracking in recent years that US carbon emissions are actually falling. This is partly due to the economic recession since 2008, but theUS Energy Information Administrationreckons that just less than half of the fall in emissions is due to the replacement of coal burning with shale gas for electrical energy production. It would seem that shale gas, which occurs in shale deposits around the world, is in a perfect position to replace coal in power stations. Already more than a third of natural gas burned in the US is coming from fracking wells, and shale gas is now cheaper than coal in the US.President Obama recently praised the US natural gas boom in a speech on climate change, crediting it with delivering cleaner energy. Many have described fracking as the bridge between the carbon-based energy systems of the past and a cleaner, greener future.

            What are the risks?
            If fracking was just a new-fangled way of tapping natural gas sources, it would be welcomed by most people as a cheaper, cleaner alternative to oil and coal. The problems lie in the method of extraction.In order to get the gas out, a witch’s brew of toxic chemicals has to be pumped into the shale at high pressure. More specifically, this is a mixture of water, sand, lubricants, poisons to keep bacteria and other microorganisms from clogging the pipes, and hydrochloric acid to dissolve the excess cement in the pipes (Brooks, 2013). If these fluids stayed far underground, they might not damage the human environment. The problem is that they find their way back to the surface through accidents at well heads, well blowouts, backflow of fluids to the surface, and leaks throughout the system. Altogether, more than 650 products containing chemicals with potential cancer-causing properties have been used in fracking (Balaba and Smart, 2012).

            One would think that a country such as the US would have laws to protect the environment from toxic pollutants like these, but unfortunately the current laws are full of loopholes when it comes to fracking. For instance, an exception to the Safe Drinking Water Act is made for toxic chemicals injected into wells during hydraulic fracturing. An exception to the Clean Water Act permits temporarily stored waste water from fracking facilities to go untreated.

            Other exemptions to US environmental safety regulations mean that fracking well operators are not obliged to report annual releases of toxic chemicals from their wells (Centner, 2013).Finally, the government does not require well operators to disclose the chemical contents of the fluids they use in the fracking process. These are considered trade secrets. It seems ironic that these companies do not have to disclose the contents of their fracking chemicals, when the manufacturers of household cleaning products must disclose every detail of their contents (Lauver, 2012).
            The Obama administration is proposing a new set of fracking rules, and their initial proposal has received an enormous number of comments from the public (more than 175,000 responses). The new set of rules only cover fracking on public lands, but the administration hopes that these rules will be adopted by individual states for use on private lands as well.

            The rules set standards of well integrity and management of polluted water that flows back to the surface. Groundwater pollution is another serious concern, but results of an EPA study on that threat are not expected before 2016. In the meantime, thousands of new fracking wells are springing up all over the country.
            Thank you but you haven’t changed my mind on the dirty business of fracking!
            References

            Balaba, RS, Smart, RB, “Total arsenic and selenium analysis in Marcellus shale, high-salinity water, and hydrofracture flowback wastewater,”

            Chemosphere89, 2012.

            Brooks, M, “Frack on or frack off? can shale gas really save the planet,” New Scientist, August 10, 2013.

            Centner, TJ, “Oversight of shale gas production in the United States and the disclosure of toxic substances,” Resources Policy 38, 2013.

            Lauver, LS, “Environmental health advocacy: an overview of natural gas drilling in northeast Pennsylvania and implications for pediatric nursing,” Journal of Pediatric Nursing 27, 2012.

          • Apparently, you’re talking about FracFocus, not my site. They are separate. I find it pretty incredible that you just dismiss a resource that several states actually require be used to disclose frack fluids as not being reliable because industry helped fund it. Who else is capable of funding it? Isn’t this exactly what people like you asked the industry to do? Meanwhile, you cite sources such as New Scientist, which is an non-peer reviewed journal. See: http://golem.ph.utexas.edu/category/2006/09/a_plea_to_save_new_scientist.html for a few insights on that subject. I also must point out you still don’t understand fracking or you wouldn’t be citing the 650 chemicals nonsense. I urge you to check out our Hydraulic Fracturing page for various sources, including FracFocus, that explain the process, its very safe record and how many chemicals are actually used and why. You’ll find any given fluid typically uses a dozen or fewer components and many are relatively innocuous. Some are now being made with 100% food-grade materials.

          • Some of the known chemicals that are used in fracking fluid, including known carcinogens and toxins such as…Mercury, Formaldehyde, Hydrochloric Acid, Uranium and Lead, are just a few of the chemicals used Bush/Cheney and the lobbyist for Halliburton made sure they don’t have to disclose to the public what they’re putting in the ground.
            Food grade why don’t you try digesting these so called food grade chemicals then the rest of us won’t have to see you B.S lies anymore Tom Please!

          • It’s true. Halliburton has developed a HF fluid using food-grade materials. It’s called Cleam-Stim. Google it. I know you’d rather have the issue than the solution but gets your facts correct.

          • The site you referred me to is funded by oil and gas companies Tom no surprise to me and I still don’t want to trade so called clean energy LMFOL! For polluting our precious resources and dirtying up the ground water and everything else too!

          • Hydraulic fracturing has never polluted any groundwater anywhere in this country. Check it out before you throw around such lose accusations. Also, Pablo, I notice from your Facebook page you seem to be more into challenging Republicans than anything else. You wouldn’t be one of those MoveOn funded folks would you?

          • Props are in order for Chesapeake Energy Corp., one of the country’s biggest natural gas producers, for finding yet another way to make a big mess with fracking. This time, it was irresponsible construction practices.
            Company subsidiary Chesapeake Appalachia will pay a near-record $3.2 million in federal penalties for clean water violations at fracking facilities in West Virginia. It will also spend $6.5 million more to restore 27 sites that it damaged with construction activities and pollution. From the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review:

            Most of the discharges subject to the consent decree are related to the construction of fracking facilities, but none of them involved actual fracking, said Donna Heron, spokeswoman for the EPA’s Mid-Atlantic region.
            “In doing the construction, that’s where they were discharging fill material into the wetlands and the streams. And that’s what the violations were about,” she said.
            The violations of the Clean Water Act involved discharges done without required Army Corps of Engineers permits, said Tom Aluise, spokesman for the West Virginia Department of Environmental Protection. …
            West Virginia, which is a co-plaintiff in the settlement, will receive half of the civil penalty.

            We get that that frackers are keen to make a buck. But why, oh why, must they do absolutely everything with nary a thought given to the environment?

            Never polluted ground water your full of it buddy!

          • You apparently don’t understand the difference between ground water and surface water, drilling and fracking, or violations and pollution. No groundwater was polluted in any of the instances you cite and none has been polluted by hydraulic fracturing anywhere in the US, ever. You have but a superficial understanding of what you’re talking about Pablo.

          • Pablo you’re not fooling me with your uneducated BS propaganda. I suggest you watch this video.

    • Victor you should be ashamed of yourself.Your straw man arguments are juvenile..Shame on you for dragging disabled veterans into your B.S.

      • They are not juvenile at all. He knows whereof he speaks and to suggest that our oil policies and what we do to protect our sources of oil are not relevant to natural gas making us independent of that – well, that’s what’s juvenile, in my opinion.

  2. Excellent write up! News like this will never make the tabloid market of today.As always follow the money. Who loses if America becomes energy independent? In fact who loses in any area that lacks natural gas.The longer this goes on the more mineral purchasing by the likes of Rockefellers. It is always about the dollar. We are just ants in their game of Riches.

  3. Renee– “activism is an action of the powerless against the powerful”. Your efforts could be helping some three billion energy-poor people globally that are denying through export– cheap energy–that is key to emerge them from poverty and certain death. They are desperately poor–they cook and heat their homes with open fires & stoves that leak burning dirty fuels such as– wood– dung– crop waste and coal. If you really want to achieve greatness–abandon the group of elitist that finance your cause & embrace this gift – demand through protest the expansion of technology through the creative destruction process, and in doing so, some 3.5 million people will not die prematurely each year as a result of breathing the polluted air inside their homes — about 200,000 more than that number die prematurely annually from breathing the polluted air outside,—-this all documented by a study from the World Health Organization.

    For many parts of the world, fossil fuels are needed for their very existence where this trend is expected over the next few decades. As an activist— who truly cares about the powerless as the definition dictates– American Natural Gas is currently the only means to lift these people out of the smoke and darkness of energy poverty.

  4. Hi, my name is Cliff Budd and I am a retired Petroleum Engineer who has fracked wells. Very few people really understand fracking and how it is done and if there is a problem, what has caused it. The REAL PROBLEM is the well integrity. That is, is the surface casing cemented properly. Think about it; the fracking is done about 1-2 miles down and the surface water is usually 300-900 feet down – and the fracking doesn’t travel that far into the rock. I can be reached at: cliffbudd@eastex.net You all need to educate yourself before you oppose fracking.

  5. Pingback: Marcellus & Utica Shale Story Links: Tue, Jan 7, 2014 | Marcellus Drilling News

  6. All energy development has impacts. Google “Noxen PA” and click on maps, then choose the Google Earth view. Just north of Noxen is a huge wind farm. See the massive amounts of forest fragmentation that will exist for time immemorial. Understand that every turbine sits on a concrete pad that is 30×50 feet and between six feet and 30 feet deep. That concrete is never coming out of that ground to return the shallow aquifer to its natural state. Those roads are never going away. Those trees are never coming back. Those turbines with their lights flashing 24/7/365 will scar that forest forever. And here is the kicker: that entire wind farm produces the same amount of energy in a year as a single natural gas well produces in a day. A day! Is all that environmental devastation worth having to live with an unreliable power source that sits like a scar on our landscape? Maybe. But let’s quit devouring fractivist manipulation hook and have a serious discussion about which potential impacts are worth the cost of producing American energy. Because like Vic says, if you are against American energy, you are for blood-for-oil wars. And I say you or your kids or your grand kids need to go fight the next one.

    • Excellent points, Scott! Each wind turbine pad is effectively unusable for any other purpose for the entire lifetime of the turbine because of the real dangers associated with wind turbines – I’ve been to the wind farm near Palm Springs, and seen 50-ton nacelles lying on the ground due to failures. I read that for a typical sized turbine to produce power regardless of wind direction when part of a 2-dimensional farm, the pad sise is on the order of 30 acres. Compare that with a 5-acre pad during drilling, and perhaps 1-2 acres when complete. Quite a difference in destruction, I’d say.

  7. Contrary to your assertion,I do not believe we are dependent on any other country for natural gas, so “drill a well and bring home a soldier” is every bit as incendiary as the lies of which you protest.

    • Not so, we were on the verge of having ti import vast quantities of LNG prior to shale gas. You also ignore the growing interchangeability between oil and gas.

    • Craig

      Are you a veteran… i and three of my kids are and trust me… being free and independant of foreign fuel is almost a reality and when we do get there “”world trade and security decisions will no longer be influenced by energy”””. The job of our US Navy is to protect the oil shipping lanes and ports. We are in Afghanastan to protoect kuwait and Iraqi oil transports through the largest American pipeline to stretch across Afghanistan to an American owned export port. Drill a Well Bring Home A soldiier is a threat to you and tthat is the only reason anyone would deny it. BTW The president of the United States repeated this very assertion.

        • But, we would if it weren’t for fracking. We were building LNG import facilities and production was crashing before we combined fracking with horizontal drilling. What part of that don’t you understand, Craig? Vic is anything but a fraud. He’s the real deal, and someone who understands how the world actually works and who was a vet and has children who are vets and has put his money where his mouth is. He’s not even saying the wars weren’t necessary for oil or other reasons but simply that being able to break away from reliance on Mideast oil is part of the wonder of fracking. We produce both oil and gas today using fracking (think Bakken) and natural gas is being substituted for oil in NYC and, gradually, in vehicles. It is a miracle of sorts for these reasons and you want to call Vic a fraud? He gets the big picture and all you keep doing is harping on one superficial point that is beside the point other than to illustrate what a gift we’ve been given.

    • I’ll let a Saudi prince explain it to you in his own words:

      “In addition to the many discoveries of oil and gas in the U.S., Canada and Australia, there are also great discoveries of shale gas, which will lead to a reduction of consumption of our oil,” Al-Waleed writes.

      Here is the link to the entire story, Craig: http://www.torontosun.com/2014/01/10/saudi-letter-concerning-oil-and-gas-has-panicky-tone?token=70e71eee50732135b392bd3f4d08deac

      • Not relevant. We have all the natural gas we need, but those who wished to profit on the “first discovery” have skewed the truth of it all. We have always been the leader of technological solutions, so why on earth would you speak of “those damn wars for oil” when we are speaking of natural gas. Why on earth do you think natural gas futures hover around $4.00/cf, which is dirt cheap? It’s because we have a buttload of it right here in the good old USA. Your politics give you away as a fraud. Your logic is flawed, and you are a fraud.

        • Why is it not relevant that Saudi Arabia sees American natural gas as a threat to its oil? It seems that it is only not relevant to people who A. have a political agenda to marginalize the many positive impacts of American produced energy and B. don’t see themselves as having a stake in blood-for-enery wars. (There, I changed it to a term that better describes it.)

    • Right “were.” As in, “the population centers of the Northeast were not reigning in their natural gas use at all, they needed more, and thank GOD, American ingenuity found a way to bring an abundant American natural resource to market.”

      • U.S. troops are volunteers. Did they volunteer to be exploited by you? I bet they didn’t. You bring every thing back to something about soldiers. You are a sad person to use veterans in this fashion. China is the country getting the oil from Iraq not U.S. I’d go into the complicated geopolitical machinations going on that force young men and women into the military but you obviously are not interested in anything but being a demagogue.

        • Vic brings it back to that perspective because he knows the subject as for demagoguery – I’d say you’re the master.

        • Ok so our men and women are all Volunteers… Lets bring back the draft but close the borders so self professed dodge drafters like Binghamton’s ex Mayor Matt Ryan can’t run away from the call of duty sending another in their place. Better Yet because we have an all Volunteer Military lets no longer report on victory or defeats… after all who cares they signed up for whatever reason so if they die or lose limbs tough titty said the kitty. Robert, I am guessing from Vestal’s VeRSE the only thing being exploited in this argument is the non paid anti to lazy or blind to see the truth for themselves. They are led around by the nose of those paid or getting large grants from foundations like the Sustainable Markets Foundation (the Rockefellers) who have given Walter Hang another 750.000.00 to keep your type of thinking in line.
          DRILL A WELL-BRING HOME A SOLDIER

        • Why is it demagoguery to show concern for the veterans who fight wars to satisfy YOUR need for energy and political stability in the countries that export energy resources?

        • Robert, I was not the one to first go there. My comment was in response to another comment regarding our troops. Your attempt at giving me a verbal spanking is less than thoughtful and, in my opinion, quite juvenile.

  8. A true Rock a feller Craig. Maybe you did,not start it but you sure stuck your foot in it! I say Let these damn antis freeze . And Vic we are all very proud of you and all that you have done for our property rights in NY! Thanks again and keep fighting the good fight, it,s working. Pass Gas NY we need heat and energy for industry not ungrateful rude pushy downstate tourists! Send them to Canada and send us well permits . Then we all can prosper!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *