Why Does Food & Water Watch Hate Poor People and Women?

LNG - Nick Grealy ReportsNick Grealy
Administrator of NoHotAir/ReImagineGas Blog

….
….

Nick Grealy nails the apparent hate Food & Water Watch has for poor people and women by wanting to condemn them to dependence on biomass energy.

US pipeline protestors such as Sandra Steingraber not only pretend that slowing down LNG export infrastructure somehow saves the earth. They also pretend it is a battle than empowers people in less developed countries in general and women in particular.  They really need to be confronted with the consequences of their actions: Banning fracking kills women.  Here’s how.  It’s complicated Sandra, but one has to go to real women with real problems, not rich American narcissists who are convinced they alone have the solutions to make women’s lives matter.

It’s easy to forget, in one’s centrally heated house in Ithaca New York, or even in the 94% of UK Michelin Restaurants who cook with gas, that there is a far larger number of women who could use gas for cooking fuel. But, this means replacing natural sounding biomass with LPG, the cooking fuel of propane or butane we use to barbecue in many countries.

Members of the “Keep It In The Ground” school are horrified natural gas use would be extended.  To their eyes we should be using less carbon fuels, not more.  Affordable LPG however has clear benefits.  We can only assume the Food & Water Watch leadership is ignorant.  Surely, Food & Water Watch founder and leader Wenonah Hauter doesn’t want Indian women to die, or children to grow up unhealthy even as CO2 emissions are lessened.

Food & Water Watch

Wenonah Hauter lecturing students at Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health by reading from her book.

This is the problem:

In India smoke from fire wood, coal, dung cakes etc affect the health of women, he said referring to a World Health Organisation report which stated that smoke inhaled by women is equivalent to 400 cigarettes per hour.

The story refers to a program where LPG stoves are given to families below the poverty line – a definition that is unthinkable for anyone anywhere reading this on a computer:

…the poverty line had been fixed at Rs 27 in rural areas and Rs 33 in urban areas, levels at which getting two meals may be difficult.

Such a damning statistic: 27 rupees is 40 US cents. Note how this is for two meals a day, not the three many of us expect in the west.  If you can eat lunch in rural India, you’re rich.

If we have a discussion that is longer than a Tweet or won’t fit on a tee shirt, some basic economics come to mind.  Banning fracking in the US would lead to no US LNG exports. Two cargoes from Sabine went to India almost right away.  Being able to use those cargoes means that the price of gas in India is falling. They recently renegotiated the price they paid for Qatari gas. And that saves Indian women’s lives:

Women in India who cook using fuels such as wood, crop residue and dried dung instead of cleaner fuels are more likely to have cataract, according to a new study published in the journal Environmental Health Perspectives on Thursday. The study, the largest of its kind, was conducted by the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, Aravind Eye Hospital and the All India Institute for Medical Sciences.

LPG is cleaner and now it’s cheaper. But it isn’t just about money as this study from Duke University shows:

Besides the health impacts, the demands for gathering biomass resources (i.e., collection of fuel-wood) are generally assigned to women and children. As shown in Figure 4, women and children in Tanzania spend several hours a day collecting fuel-wood for household use (IEA, 2006). This causes a dramatic opportunity cost in terms of lost education chances and limiting other possibilities generating income.

The backbreaking labour of collecting “biomass” ensures a generation of women aren’t educated, richer or liberated from outdated thinking.  An entire generation of women, condemned to a life of poverty by an unthinking generation of American women.  One more reason to trust facts, not emotions.

Editor’s Note: Wenonah Hauter is yet another example of trendy elites who imagine they ought to run the world and impose their standards while ignoring their responsibilities to others. As the tax authorities in Fauquier County Virginia who had to battle her and her husband Leigh Hauter to get them to pay property taxes. They run the trendy Bull Run Mountain Farm there where you buy organic GMO-free eggs and the like produced on property apparently inherited from her family. Her life is vastly different than these Indian women:

Food & Water Watch

Please share this post and get the word out everywhere!

2 thoughts on “Why Does Food & Water Watch Hate Poor People and Women?”

  1. Unsurprisingly food and water watch was involved with the spread of this conspiracy theory on the port ambrose lng import project that it was actually secretly intended for export when it wasn’t and unsurprisingly that book mentions activists that I know are not credible.

  2. Does Wenonah cook with dung or boycott resturaunts that use natural gas ?? Doubtful. These hypocrites don’t know how much their thinking and demands hurt people.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *