Karen Orlando
Organic vegetable gardener at Floyd Bennett Gardens Association
Publisher of Outside Now blog
….
….
Karen Orlando observes how the Port Ambrose debate has evolved; being an anti-fracking activist these days too often seems to be an occasion for lightness and folly.
The activists responsible for bamboozling the public, reporters and politicians for two plus years now about the Port Ambrose LNG import proposal and also on the history of the Rockaway pipeline project are accountable to no one. They don’t represent a community. They aren’t elected to speak for one. It’s all too easy for them to be seen as experts or powerful entities representing lots of members just based on their word, a clever press release, facebook meme, or any other number of activist tactics.

Josh Fox’s Gasland social media promotes a conspiracy theory that the Port Ambrose LNG import project is for export and directs people to sign a form letter that says so.
So, in this moment, we have EPA head Gina McCarthy, presumably in some way accountable to citizens, saying this:
“Cleaner-burning energy sources like natural gas are key compliance options for our Clean Power Plan and we are committed to ensuring safe and responsible production that supports a robust clean energy economy.”
May Boeve, executive director of 350.org and a climate activist who lives in Brooklyn and is currently being promoted as one of 10 leaders who are reshaping the environmental movement disagrees. She says the opposite, which is basically what I have seen for years now with activists surrounding the issue of fracking and natural gas. It is what defines the activism surrounding the Rockaway pipeline and Port Ambrose proposals. According to a very recent press release from 350.org, “the only safe way to deal with fracking is to end it.” I can almost guarantee that quote has already been picked up by someone somewhere in the media.
One dirty secret about the environmental world, its leadership or activism tactics is that it is in no way held accountable. It isn’t just 350.org either. Because the environmental activist world is like any other, the controversy over natural gas development in NY state and the Deleware River Basin has impacted many organizations which network or associate with each other, not just the ones that have sprung up over this issue.

One consequence of the activism surrounding the war on fracking is that the public is losing access to credible information on natural gas and environmentalists are losing their ability to provide credible information to the public as well.. To quote Ms. Mccarthy again quite recently:
“Hydrofracking has certainly changed the energy dynamic considerably. You are absolutely right, it has created an opportunity for a shift away from coal into natural gas, and that shift has been enormously beneficial from a clean air perspective, as well as from a climate perspective.”


Karen, agree with your sentiment, swam in the waters under ambrose lighthouse, many kegs at Riis park. check your grammer in the 4-5th sentence
Yup. The Delaware Riverkeeper Network is on video saying “I represent the Delaware Riverkeeper Network’s thousands of members.” The DRN has no members, as it reports on its filings to the state and IRS justifying its non-profit status and exemption from paying taxes. The DRN also uses “Riverkeeper” to give the impression it is affiliated and aligned with the American Littoral Society and all of its Riverkeepers and Baykeepers. It is not.
Nicely put Karen!
As you well know i have been against imported energy right from the begining of the shale gas revolution.
I feel it has robed the U,S, economy of much needed revinue.
To each their own.
Funny aint it Karen? You are all for NG as long as it,s produced some where else yet you want to run pipe through your neighbors yards to get it?
How,s yer Water mellons doing?
ALL NY OR NONE-We need permits then pipes.
I don’t know why you continue freegas to put words in my mouth.
While you say “we need permits, then pipes”, the reality is that while the fracking issue was being debated for an overly long time period in NY state, pipeline expansions were approved and continue to be evaluated, just as they were prior to the fracking moratorium and ban. As an example there were three expansions that deliver into NYC proposed and susequently built during this time period and that is only NYC.
I have no idea what you mean when you say I want to run pipe through my neighbors yard either. I’m not exactly the authority on where any pipe is proposed or eventually built.
And again I am not doing a commercial for Liberty’s import proposal which by the way goes through noone’s yard as the entire project is offshore.
What I am saying is that the antifracking movement has used the Port Ambrose LNG import proposal as a tactic in their war against fracking. They have used this proposal and public hearings to create a conspiracy that the project is for export. Some people have done this deliberately as well.
Karen,
Your observations are on the money. Other readers should realize you’re not advocating for anything other an intelligent debate and what you’ve been consistently pointing out is the lack of intelligence, honesty and reason on the part of fractivists using Port Liberty as leverage in their ideological war – nothing more. I get it.
Idiocy soon reveals its self and melts away in the naked light of truth.