The New York State Energy Vise: NYC vs. Upstate

Patrick Leary - Massachusetts energyPatrick Leary
New Hampshire Engineer (BSEE) and System Engineer

….
…. 

Guest blogger Patrick Leary describes the energy vise that exists in New York state as naive New York City residents continually squeeze Upstate New York.

NaturalGasNOW‘s post yesterday about the prospect that New York could well freeze in the dark, given its paralyzing political correctness on energy issues, made me think. I live in New Hampshire where we still use our heads from time to time, but it seems New York State has gone over the edge. What I see with New York is a gigantic energy vise where New York City folks squeeze the life out of Upstate New York and, especially, the North Country.

Here’s how I see that energy vise:

energy vise

Yes, the way I see it, New Yorkers north of New York City might well freeze in the dark. Or, perhaps it’s simply a case of some City folks who couldn’t care less if that’s what happens to Upstate and the North Country.

The people in New York City seem to think the people Upstate and in the North Country should cover their landscape with more or less permanent industrial scale wind turbines to generate electricity for New York City. It has to be wind power, of course, because that allows the City folks to feel good about themselves. It’s guilt-free energy they don’t have to produce so it’s impact-free, too! What could be better?

Upstate and North Country folks, though, face a different scenario. The new generation of industrial scale wind turbines are pushing to 750 feet tall. The tallest I know of is 722 feet base to tip. Here’s a picture:

energy vise

This is taller than all but seven buildings in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. It is taller than all but/about 100 buildings in the USA

All of this taken together is the energy vise – on one side, the city folk who dictate energy policy to the major detriment of the country folk, and on the other side the industrial scale wind turbines built all over the place where they don’t live (wup, wup, flash, flash, flicker, flicker) and built by big green corporations with which they seem to have no problem.

Please share this post and get the word out everywhere!

7 thoughts on “The New York State Energy Vise: NYC vs. Upstate”

  1. Well Patrick….you are spot on….these clueless straphangers from the Asphalt Jungles are the same vacuous blowhards who think electricity comes from the light switch or wall outlet, gas comes from the gas station and food comes from the supermarket. God forbid a cataclysmic event forces us as a society to be resourceful, self sufficient providers, or worse, foragers & hunter/gatherers…..can’t you see folks who don’t know how or never mowed a lawn sowing and raising a garden simply to survive..?? Those poor blowhards won’t last a week. And where would they find white wine & artisan cheese..??!!

  2. Well it is hard to see how nyc folks who are used to not just lots of tall buildings but living on top of each other will see this large windmill surrounded by what looks like nice open space as threatening.

    Plus you should know that offshore wind is also being considered and this would not involve lots of windfarms in upstate NY but actually offshore and close to where the power is needed.

    Having said that what I do agree with is that a very small group of people actually dominate what gets discussed when it comes to energy and it does not actually appear to me that it is the vast majority of nyc citizens at all that are involved .

    So get more specific about who generated this problem that you see is what I would say.

  3. It is high time split NY into two separate states: North New York and South New York. As a former downstater I can safely attest that this is the only way for the current Upstate to survive. SNY would have Long Island, NYC, Putnam, Westchester and Duchess east of Hudson and Orange Rockland, Ulster and Sullivan on the west side. They would control most of their reservoirs and those in Delaware and Schoharie would have their water sold to them at a highly reasonable price. Of course, SNY would also get the biggest booby prize of all, his Lordship.

  4. What’s wrong with requiring that buildings built in NYC have to have wind turbines placed on top of the buildings to generate at least a small percentage of the energy that they consume? Having visited the top of the empire state building I can tell you first hand that the wind blows up there.

    Would love to see someone photo shop an NYC skyline with 722 foot wind turbines on top of some of the buildings so that we can all see how beautiful that would look from upstate NY.

    Additionally, NYC could capitalize on the venturi affect which occurs when winds coming into the city are forced through the small gaps between the buildings (streets) and accelerate. Blade style generators could span the gaps between buildings and capture this energy.

    But it’s all ugly of course and they wouldn’t want to look at it when all of this infrastructure can be place in upstate NY where they can’t see it.

  5. To help bring some reality to the NYC crowd, I’d suggest that the gas and oil pipelines into the city mysteriously “stop flowing due to technical problems” for three days in mid-February. Then they could empathize with those people farther up the coast who can’t get gas delivered to them because of NYC & Cuomo. After getting cold and threatening to have their pipes freeze, THEN they would better understand the need for some pipelines!

  6. A wind tower on the steep hill behind me appears to be sticking out of my roof. I receive no money. My farm was listed for 6 months this summer. No one came, no call from broker. Prospects look at google maps which show the wind farm. What the wind farm pays in taxes is a pittance compared to what we have lost in “pristine”. We are a poor area and can thus be enticed by wind farms and solar. Solar is another subsidizes boondoggle that is being promoted where we don’t get enough sun.

    I suggest that for every wind tower erected in the southern tier, one be erected on the Hudson Palisades and offshore of the Hamptons. How about wind towers on the Rockefeller estate?

    • Don’t forget all those dead bats and birds, many of them listed as endangered littering the base of these electromagnetic radiating behemoths.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *