Jim Willis
Editor & Publisher, Marcellus Drilling News (MDN)
CELDF advised Grant Township, Indiana County, PA to ban wastewater injection wells with one of its foolish ordinances. Now, Grant may have to go bankrupt..
Question: How will Grant Township (Indiana County, PA), a town with 741 people in it, pay a lawsuit it may lose awarding Pennsylvania General Energy (PGE) $1 million? Going by the law of averages, less than half of the 741 people actually pay taxes.
So the question is, how can something like 200 families come up with enough money to pay such a large lawsuit? Answer: they can’t. The town goes bankrupt. That is the very real situation facing the residents of Grant Township.

You may recall we’ve written about this before, as has Tom Shepstone. Grant tried to block PGE from building a wastewater injection well in the township by passing an illegal law stirred up and proposed by the odious Community Environmental Legal Defense Fund, or CELDF. The town has now tried to reorganize in order to avoid the judge’s ruling. PGE has sued the town claiming (truthfully) they’ve suffered at least $1 million in damages.
That case goes to trial in March. If the town loses, the town pays. The cowardly CELDF has admitted they won’t contribute a penny toward the $1 million fine if the case goes against the town. Nice friends the people of Grant have made in the CELDF, wouldn’t you say? Check it out (emphasis added):
Situated about 70 miles northwest of Pittsburgh, Grant Township, an Indiana County community with a population of 741, has not only found itself on the losing side of a federal ruling, but it also may face more than $1 million in damages tied to that case. That’s no small amount for a township with an annual budget of $274,032.
It all started in August 2014 when Warren based Pennsylvania General Energy Co. filed suit against the township in the U.S. District Court of the Western District of Pennsylvania, claiming that a township ordinance banning the installation of injection wells was federally unconstitutional and against Pennsylvania law. PGE had been attempting to get federal and state permits to install the well, which forces waste drilling fluid deep underground.
On Oct. 14, Magistrate Judge Susan Paradise Baxter sided with PGE.
“Although defendant wishes it were not so, the development of oil and gas (which necessarily includes the management of waste materials generated at a well site) is a legitimate business activity and land use within Pennsylvania,” she wrote.
In her federal ruling, Baxter was specific about Grant Township exceeding “its legislative authority under Pennsylvania’s Second Class Township Code” when it instituted a Community Bill of Rights Ordinance against injection wells.
Grant Township was indeed classified as a second class township. But it didn’t need to be. It could choose another municipal designation if it wanted to, and if it passed such a change in an election.
So that’s what it did.
On Nov. 3, Grant Township residents voted to redesignate the township under the commonwealth’s Home Rule Charter designation. As part of its charter, it specifically banned injection wells.
“The people of Grant Township spoke loud and clear: They have rights, and they will protect those rights,” said Chad Nicholson of the Mercersburg based Community Environmental Legal Defense Fund, which assisted Grant Township with the rewriting of its municipal laws.
Whether or not rewriting municipal laws will keep injection wells out of the township is up for debate. Matt Burger, who leads the energy legal practice at Buchanan Ingersoll & Rooney PC in Pittsburgh, said it probably won’t.
“What they’ve done has absolutely no impact on (Judge Baxter’s) analysis,” Burger said. What’s more, PGE and Grant Township are still in litigation over more than $1 million in alleged damages PGE hopes to recoup. That case is going to trial in March. If Grant loses that case and is forced to pony up $1 million, it could be in real trouble.
“Grant Township runs a substantial risk of having to declare bankruptcy,” said James V. Corbelli, an attorney and shareholder with Pittsburgh based Babst Calland. “Despite that, they’re continuing to pursue this.”
When CELDF’s Nicholson was asked if the nonprofit would pick up the tab if Grant Township found itself on the losing end of its federal case, he didn’t mince words.
“We are providing legal assistance to the township at no cost,” he said. “Any damages awarded by the court against the township would have to be paid by the township.”
Grant Township’s solicitor did not respond to requests for comment.
So, the CELDF approaches the people of Grant and convinces them (sells them a bill of goods) that they can help prevent the legal activity of drilling a wastewater injection well in the town. And when/if the town loses, after taking the CELDF’s advice, the CELDF washes its hands and refuses to contribute. Anyone else smell a rat? We think the people of Grant have a good case for suing the CELDF for legal malpractice. They should also challenge the CELDF’s tax exemption.
For more great articles on the subject of natural gas development every single day, subscribe to Marcellus Drilling News using this convenient link.



Municipal wastewater has been used as irrigation water for decades e.g. Israel, FL, CA. PA has a history of innovative application of technology i.e. using land application of municipal wastewater as bio-filter of abandoned mine fields e.g. Dr. L. Kardos UNIV PA ‘The Living Filter’ circa mid ’70’s – using treated wastewater as frac fluids is sound application of proven technology – Richard W. Goodwin West Palm Beach FL 11/17/15
Waste water injection is just another of the many unforced errors the oil and gas industry has made recently. To the anti’s it’s just a gift that keeps on giving, especially, as Mr. Goodwin has shown, the technology is available to clean and reuse it.
CELDF and their ilk will paint it as tiny David trying to do the right thing getting squashed by greedy Goliath. If the township wins CELDF will dislocate an arm patting itself on the back. If the township loses, both CELDF and PGE regard Grant Township as collateral damage in a bigger contest. When elephants dance …