Poetic Justice: Norse Energy Trustee Filing Suit Against NY

Norse Energy - story by Jim WillisJim Willis
Editor & Publisher, Marcellus Drilling News (MDN)


Norse Energy is out of business, workers are out of jobs and leaseholders are out of opportunities due to the nonfeasance of New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo, who will soon be on the receiving end of his own handiwork as Norse Energy sues him. 

It seems we haven’t heard the last from Norse Energy. Just last month, the Norwegian-based driller converted from Chapter 11 bankruptcy, or “keep the creditors at bay while we reorganize,” to Chapter 7, or “sell off the furniture and turn off the lights.” There’s still a bit of fight left in Norse, or fight left in its creditors anyway.

Late last week MDN received a tip from friend and intrepid blogger Andy Leahy, writer of the excellent NY Shale Gas Now! blog, about some of the biggest New York news we’ve heard in some time. Norse Energy, or what’s left of it, has decided to file a lawsuit against New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo, Dept. of Environmental Conservation (DEC) Commissioner Joe Martens, and State Health Commissioner Nirav Shah. This lawsuit would force the completion of the SGEIS (Supplemental Generic Environmental Impact Statement) and adoption of associated draft gas drilling regulations.

The official Norse Energy lawsuit has not yet been filed but according to MDN’s sources, it will be filed in early December. This story is a bit complicated, so we’ll break it down for you and show you the evidence we have that a lawsuit against the Cuomo/Martens/Shah cabal is indeed on the way–very soon…

Leahy’s first tip that something was in the air visa vis a lawsuit against Andrew the Ditherer was this posting on the Naturalgasforums.com website:


Leahy then took to Twitter to see if there was any scuttlebutt about such a lawsuit. He found this tweet from a Binghamton real estate attorney:

Gary Kline tweet on lawsuit

Off he went in search of documentation, and Leahy found it, proof positive, deep in the weeds of the Norse Energy bankruptcy proceedings paperwork. Click here to read a copy.

What Does this Say and Mean?

The document above is an application by the Norse Energy bankruptcy trustee, filed with the U.S. Bankruptcy Court Western District of New York (Buffalo) on Nov. 20, that says the trustee, the guy looking out for the best interests of the creditors now left to hold an empty bag, wants to hire attorney Tom West and the Albany-based West Firm to represent Norse in an Article 78 Proceeding.

What is an Article 78 Proceeding? If the New York State government, or a New York government official, refuses to fulfill their constitutionally appointed role, that is, if they won’t do their job, a citizen or company can sue them to force them to do their job. That’s an Article 78. It includes the ability to file for something called a Writ of Mandamus, which is described succinctly here (emphasis added):

Writ of Mandamus to compel a government agency or official to do something they are required by law to do. For example, one might file an Article 78 in the form of a Writ of Mandamus to Compel to compel a government agency to issue a decision on an application. One might also file an Article 78 in the form of a Writ of Mandamus to Compel to compel a court to issue a decision in a case or on motion when that court has taken too long to render such decision.

The paperwork above is an official request to the court asking permission to hire the West Firm to pursue an Article 78. The actual Article 78 Proceeding has not yet been filed. The U.S. trustee appointed to the case (not to be confused with the overall trustee) accepted the application, but the judge for the bankruptcy case had not, as of noon on Monday, November 25, officially accepted it (yet).

When Will Article 78 Paperwork Be Filed?

With the West Firm now approved by the court, when will they file the Article 78 paperwork? An MDN source has confidentially told us to keep a sharp eye out on December 2nd, the date when the courts re-open after a holiday break. We expect (but don’t know for sure) that the Article 78 will be filed on or about that date.

West Law Firm Funding

You may recognize Tom West and the West Firm name. Tom is representing Norse Energy in a different lawsuit against the Town of Dryden, New York over their questionable action of banning hydraulic fracturing for all landowners throughout their rural township. The Dryden case is being funded by unnamed third parties (not Norse and not Norse’s creditors). The paperwork above is mostly a full disclosure of all potential conflicts of interest Tom and his firm may have in taking on an Article 78 case. We see from the documentation above that once again unnamed third parties will fund West’s work on the Article 78 Proceeding when it’s filed.

Is the funding for the Article 78 coming from other drillers? From drilling industry groups? From private individuals? Foundations? Who knows and, frankly, who cares? Anti-drilling lawsuits are constantly being filed with the direct and indirect backing of deep pockets anti-drilling groups. If the industry wants to fund this effort, God bless them. A positive result from any lawsuit that forces Cuomo to act will ultimately benefit landowners and every resident of New York who wants to use clean burning (and cheap) natural gas from fracking.

Norse is Bankrupt, So Why Norse?

Norse_mapYou may wonder why Norse Energy would bother to file an Article 78 Proceeding; especially since they’re ripping up the floorboards and selling them for fire wood (metaphorically speaking). Number one, it’s not costing Norse anything since the Article 78 will be paid for by unnamed third parties. Number two, Norse still has 130,000 acres of leases in its portfolio–assets to sell (in yellow area on map to right). Right now those leased acres are worthless. Who will buy them with no shale drilling in New York? If, however, Cuomo and his lieutenants (Martens and Shah) are forced to release the new drilling regulations and if drilling begins, the value of Norse’s assets goes way up.

What Happens Next?

What happens next is, we eat turkey, we go shopping on Black Friday, and we wait. And on December 2nd, tune back in to MDN for some (hopefully) very good news.

Be sure to read Andy Leahy’s take on this story here. A big hat-tip to Andy for breaking the story.

For more great articles on the subject of natural gas development every single day, subscribe to Marcellus Drilling News using this convenient link.

follow-us-on-twitter  like-us-on-facebook  follow-us-on-linkedin

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

5 thoughts on “Poetic Justice: Norse Energy Trustee Filing Suit Against NY

  1. Seems like Norse has a valid takings claim they could pursue in addition to the Article 78 . After all, they have leases they paid real money for, and those leases have been rendered worthless, as worthless as our so-called leader.

  2. http://m.bizjournals.com/pittsburgh/blog/morning-edition/2013/11/fracking-sees-widespread-support.html?r=full
    President Obama and his administration also support it. It is the Governor’s failure to lead that has created this divide in NY. He has prevented the state’s experts from speaking on this issue. The DEC has been completely absent from this discussion for 5 years. The last time our state said anything substantive about drilling was on March 14, 2011, when Taury Smith, New York State Geologist and Director of the New York State Geological Survey of the New York State Museum made favorable comments about HVHF stating that he has been examining the science of hydrofracturing the shale for three years and has found no cases in which the process has led to groundwater contamination; that several portrayals by anti-fracking groups about underground pools being harmed because of drilling are exaggerated problems that are unrelated to HVHF; that HVHF could help fight climate change; and that allowing HVHF in New York would be a huge boost for New York job creation and for income and business tax revenues. Former DEC Commissioner Pete Grannis said he agreed with Smith that the dangers of HVHF are overblown. Smith was immediately shut down by his superiors and eventually left the state for a position as a private geology consultant in January 2013.

    Governor Cuomo controls the message in NY. On casinos, he added to the ballot that casinos will be “promoting job growth, increasing aid to schools, and permitting local governments to lower property taxes.” If he had the political will, he would say the same things about drilling. Governor Cuomo is to blame for the failure to educate New Yorkers about the benefits of this American energy revolution.

  3. Pingback: Gov. Cuomo: Where Do We Go to Get Our Business Back? - Natural Gas Now

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *