Impact Fee or Severance Tax? Choose Wisely!

Severance TaxEdgar Warriner
President & Founder, Elk Advisors Group
Montrose, Pennsylvania

The Commonwealth of Pennsylvania is the midst of a political debate about a severance tax but voters ought to think long and hard about it before abandoning the very workable Marcellus Shale Impact Fee.

Yesterday, I had the pleasure of making a presentation to the Wyoming County (Pennsylvania) Chamber of Commerce on the subject of Pennsylvania’s Marcellus Shale Impact Fee and why it is far superior to the severance tax we keep hearing some politicians say they need. The reality is that they don’t need it as much as they want it. They want it so they can solve problems they created at the least possible cost to their own reputations and with the most credit for passing out other peoples’ money.

While these politicians are fond of saying Pennsylvania is the only oil and gas state without a severance tax, the conveniently neglect our super high state corporate income tax and act as if the Marcellus Shale Impact Fee didn’t exist. But, it is does exist and no other state has anything like it–anything so fair and so well tailored to address the needs of communities. It allows communities to decide how to spend the money rather than the state politicians, so, perhaps that’s what they don’t like.

Anyway, Act 13 Impact Fees are collected based on the price of natural gas. That price averaged $3.652 in 2013, which put the impact fee assessment in the third column of this guide for determining the fee:

Severance Tax 1

The beauty of the Act 13 Marcellus Shale Impact Fee is in its distribution, which is targeted toward communities and away from politicians. Here are the formulas:

Severance Tax 2

And, here’s how the money actually got spent:

Severance Tax 3

And, who paid it:

Severance Tax 4And, here’s where the money went in Wyoming County, Pennsylvania as one example:

Severance Tax 5

This is how the funding formula worked for Wyoming County:

Screen Shot 2014-08-14 at 6.19.29 PM Severance Tax 6

Screen Shot 2014-08-14 at 6.29.22 PM

What can these impacts fees be used for? Well, it’s a long list of things designed to mitigate the impacts of natural gas development and enhance communities where it takes place.

Severance Tax

Here’s where the impact fees went by county and you’ll notice they largely went to communities most impacted by natural gas development which is precisely how one would hope it would work (unless you’re a freeloader county).

Severance Tax 8This is just one aspect of the natural gas industry, of course, and the other much more important part of the formula is simply this; energy = jobs. Here are a few statistics and a chart illustrating what I mean:

Severance Tax 8

Severance Tax 9

Consider also where those job opportunities are; they’re concentrated in industries impacted by natural gas development.

Severance Tax 10

Advocates of a severance tax, of course, want us to suppose Pennsylvania is letting oil and gas companies skate free but that simply isn’t the gas, as the following illustrates:

Severance Tax 11

And, oil and gas companies do have alternatives, as the following chart illustrates. Pennsylvania offers some incentives to companies, to be sure, but it’s far from the best place to do business, which means business will go elsewhere with a severance tax.

Severance Tax 11

Companies are, in fact, already investing in other plays and have numerous options:

Severance Tax 12

Severance Tax 13

Those greedy for a severance tax need to consider how very fortunate Pennsylvania has the industry, given its high corporate taxes. The revenue multiplier effect is simply huge and already produces increased taxes across the board because we’ve managed to avoid killing the golden goose with a severance tax:

Screen Shot 2014-08-14 at 7.07.53 PMSeverance Tax 14

Do we really want to tamper with something that works?

Severance Tax 15

Does this make any sense?

Severance tax 16

Severance Tax 16

No, it doesn’t and Margaret Thatcher captured the severance tax problem in a nutshell:

Severance Tax 17

And, here’s the bottom line:

Severance Tax 19

Think about it, please, and choose wisely. A severance tax is bad for Pennsylvania.

follow-us-on-twitter  like-us-on-facebook  follow-us-on-linkedin

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

2 thoughts on “Impact Fee or Severance Tax? Choose Wisely!

  1. Severance tax push appears to be coming from the places where no gas is being produced. I can see the money disappearing into the money pits at Phila./Pitts./Harrisburg never to be seen again.

  2. Pingback: The Marcellus Shale Resource Is Lifting PennsylvaniaNatural Gas Now

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *