FERC Hailed for NY DEC Overturn as Other Pipelines Seek Relief

delaware riverkeeper - Jim Willis reports

Jim Willis
Editor & Publisher, Marcellus Drilling News (MDN)


FERC delivered a blow to the NY DEC by overturning their Millennium Pipeline denial; the Constitution and Northern Access pipelines will now seek similar relief.

Yesterday we told you history has been made, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) has broken the back of the New York Dept. of Environmental Conservation (DEC) by overturning the DEC’s decision to block a short pipeline Millennium wants to build to a power plant in Orange County.

The DEC has also blocked federally-approved pipeline projects in two other cases, the Constitution Pipeline, a $683 million, 124-mile pipeline from Susquehanna County, PA to Schoharie County, NY carrying Marcellus gas (a Williams project), and the Northern Access Pipeline, a $455 million project includes building 97 miles of new pipeline along a power line corridor from northwestern Pennsylvania up to Erie County, NY, to carry Marcellus gas northward (a National Fuel Gas Company project).


Given Millennium’s success in having FERC overrule NY DEC, one would think these other two projects would also file requests with FERC for the same thing. According to Reuters, NFG already has filed such a request, and Williams is about to.

Energy traders and natural gas pipeline companies on Friday hailed a U.S. federal regulator’s decision to overturn New York’s denial of a water permit for building the Millennium Pipeline in the state.

People in the industry expressed hope that the U.S. Federal Energy Regulatory Commission would be willing to override state decisions to block other pipelines, including Williams Cos Inc’s Constitution and National Fuel Gas Co’s Northern Access pipelines from Pennsylvania. These could also be approved if similar waivers are granted by FERC.

FERC, which is in charge of U.S. energy regulation, now has three members, after two new commissioners were appointed by President Donald Trump. Environmental groups and other opponents of fracking blasted the decision, saying it violated the state’s authority.

The New York Department of Environmental Conservation said it was reviewing whether to appeal FERC’s decision, “and will consider all legal options to protect public health and the environment.”

Both Williams and National Fuel said they would seek similar relief from FERC.

New York had denied a water quality certification for Millennium, a 7.8-mile (12.6 kilometer) line to provide around 0.127 billion cubic feet per day of gas to the Valley Energy Center power plant in Wawayanda, New York, from an existing pipeline. New York uses about 3.6 bcfd.

National Fuel’s CEO Ronald Tanski sent a letter to FERC earlier in the week asking the agency to overturn the NYDEC’s denial of a water certificate for its Northern Access project, which runs from Pennsylvania to New York.

FERC’s decision on the Millennium pipeline “is certainly a positive step for the natural gas industry, however, our argument with regards to the Northern Access Project is substantially different,” National Fuel spokeswoman Karen Merkel told Reuters.

Williams spokesman Chris Stockton said the company would seek a waiver for the planned 124-mile, 0.65-bcfd Constitution pipeline that would move shale gas from Pennsylvania. New York does not allow fracking.

Sierra Club Atlantic Chapter Director Roger Downs in a statement called FERC’s reversal of Governor Andrew Cuomo’s decision “an insult to New Yorkers and our right to protect our communities and our water.”

He said states “unquestionably have the authority to rule whether a dirty, dangerous fracked gas pipeline violates clean water laws, and nowhere is FERC granted the right to override that authority.”

The NYDEC denied Millennium’s water quality certificate in August 2017. FERC said the agency failed to act within a year of the original application in 2015.


The radical Sierra Club is dead wrong, whether intentional or not. States DO NOT have the right to reject pipeline projects. The law was crafted to give states a say in how pipeline projects are developed, not a say in rejecting them. Why? Because what one state may consider a “dirty, dangerous fracked gas pipeline” another state may embrace with open arms. The federal government, via FERC, is the arbiter of the decision, precisely so one state (like New York) cannot screw other states (like Pennsylvania) by blocking projects. Stick that in your craw and eat it, Sierra Clubbers.

For more great articles on natural gas development every single business day, subscribe to Marcellus Drilling News using this convenient link.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

5 thoughts on “FERC Hailed for NY DEC Overturn as Other Pipelines Seek Relief

  1. As a New Yorker who supports conservation and wise use of resources and the proper maintenence of its transportational infrastructure I am not insulted as Mr. Downs claims. In fact, I challenge Mr. Downs et al to identify the difference between a molecule of methane in a pipeline that originated from a conventional well, a fractured well and one from agricultural/wastewater digester. If he can’t, he has little ground to stand on.

  2. “…a dirty, dangerous fracked gas pipeline…”

    Well that just told me all I need to know. I suspect he’s from San Francisco and spends all his time contemplating the odor of his own farts (yes, that’s a South Park reference).

    I hope this trend initiates a true snowball effect; I think the tide is turning toward sanity, for a change…

  3. cuomo, schniederman, lippman, zucker, martens and seggos should all be prosecuted under RICO statutes for brazen abuse of authority, screwing landowners, and blocking interstate commerce.

  4. Roger Downs isn’t the only person at the Sierra club who isn’t credible. And keep in mind it wasn’t so long ago that the Sierra club was criticized for taking money from the natural gas industry for their beyond coal campaign. In an article in Time in 2012 head honcho Micheal brune mentioned “grassroot” pressure plus occupy as part of why the Sierra club shifted it’s stance on natural gas. He didn’t mention science.

  5. it has been too long since people have been cold and hungry. Land owners and farmers have been taken for granted. At the latest solid waste and environmental concerns committee of Otsego County Craig Stevens and William Huston came and explained why we shouldn’t have XNG trucks rolling through our County. I politely told them we wouldn’t except for all the people who lobbied against pipelines. It was quite a show, bottle of dirty water and all.To our credit Otsego County sent Cuomo a letter asking to approve the pipeline. We are still waiting for a reply.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *