Bailouts for Wasteful States Banning Drilling? No Way!

President, Upper Delaware River Basin Citizens


Ned Lang, President of Upper Delaware River Basin Citizens, tells the President not to do bailouts for wasteful states such as New York that ban drilling!

Dear Mr. President:

I write this letter as president of the Upper Delaware River Basin Citizens (UDRBC) concerning the request by the Democrats and blue state governors for another round of bailouts.  We are a landowner group representing the interests and rights of landowners throughout the Upper Delaware River Basin, which includes portions of New York and Pennsylvania.  As you know, for decades these governors, who are begging for bailouts, have been anything but fiscally responsible with our hard earned tax dollars. 

In fact, New York State has a projected six billion dollar shortfall in its 2020 budget.  Pennsylvania has a $1.5 billion shortfall in its budget for 2020-2021.  These two states have years of outrageous budget shortfalls, well before the Chinese virus, COVID-19, hit our country. They have buried their states in debt and are now attempting to seize the opportunity to have all of the financially responsible states and their taxpayers bail them out! We say to you, Mr. President, please tell them, “Not so fast! No bailouts!”


A couple of examples of the gross mismanagement by these two governors of their taxpayers’ money are included here.  According to data posted today on the Empire Center’s government transparency website,, over one in six New York State and New York City public authority employees were paid six figures in fiscal year 2019.  Additionally, the Washington Times reported that based on projections by the two retirement systems by the auditor general’s office, Pennsylvania’s two major public employees’ pension funds face $70 billion in debt while municipal pension funds face almost $9 billion in debt.

If the governors of NY and PA really need an influx of dollars, they should allow the exploration and harvesting of natural gas in all of New York including the Delaware River Basin.  Due to an imposed moratorium by the Delaware River Basin Commission (DRBC), the Delaware River Basin portion of Pennsylvania is prevented from developing its natural gas reserves through the modern process of hydraulic fracturing combined with horizontal drilling, despite the fact that the remainder of Pennsylvania can do so, and New York has hydraulically fractured vertical wells for decades without problems. 

The decisions of the DRBC and New York State are not based on science as the EPA long ago found hydraulic fracturing was not tied to any significant pollution.  They are, rather, based on the short-term cynical politics of appeasing urban special interests, which have no concept of how their energy is made and delivered.  Neither state nor the DRBC should receive any federal rescue when they have inflicted their economic woes on themselves.

Data assembled in 2015 by the Institute for 21st Century Energy, under the auspices of the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, found Pennsylvania natural gas development via hydraulic fracturing and horizontal drilling added $4.5 billion to Commonwealth’s GDP that year.  New York State has viable Utica and Marcellus Shale resources that spread across the entire Southern Tier from Steuben County to Delaware and Sullivan Counties in New York State. 

The seven counties most affected have resources roughly equivalent to the Northeast PA region that has accounted for about one-third of all Pennsylvania wells, meaning New York State has lost out on approximately $1.5 billion per year just from upstream oil and gas activity.  Indeed, one company in Susquehanna County has already invested $10 billion and paid out $2 billion to landowners in royalties and lease payments. 

But, that’s not all.  The Commonwealth also benefited from $5.8 billion in lower residential energy prices and $2.7 billion in lower industrial energy prices that have occurred due to the development of pipeline infrastructure that Pennsylvania has permitted and New York has repeatedly denied.  Additionally, in New York State there are the additional millions that would have been paid in ad valorem taxes by gas drillers.

The DRBC region of Pennsylvania represents roughly 200,000 acres of land with developable natural gas resources, which is about 38% the size of Susquehanna County, PA.  Assuming, even if that area had 25% of the impact as in Susquehanna County, this would amount to roughly $162,500,000 of natural gas drilling economic activity for bordering Wayne County every single year with attendant increases in Marcellus Shale Impact Tax fees coming back to the county.  If Wayne County, PA, had been allowed to start drilling in 2007 with Susquehanna County, it reasonably could be expected to have seen $2.5 billion of investments by now along with some $500 million in royalties and lease payments, not to mention the increase in property and property tax revenue.

Put it all together and Pennsylvania and New York are missing out on a combined $2 billion of GDP per year and $12.5 billion of cumulative investment, along with consumer and industrial savings on energy prices (which are effectively the same as tax cuts) and $2.5 billion in payment to landowners.  It would be absolutely inexcusable to do bailouts of these states and agencies when they declined that much economic activity for purely political reasons. 

On behalf of the citizens of the Upper Delaware River Basin, their children, grandchildren and great grandchildren, I implore you to tell the governors of New York and Pennsylvania that there will be no more federal taxpayer bailouts for their wasteful states.  It is only through this very reasonable and responsible stance that, quite possibly, the natural gas resources we have beneath our feet can be harvested to assist our great nation maintain its energy independence, not to mention its sovereignty as a free people nation!

This letter was co-authored by Thomas Shepstone, also a member of the UDRBC Board of Directors.  We both thank you very much for your time and assistance in this matter. 

Very respectfully yours,

Edward Lang
President UDRBC

Thomas J. Shepstone
Member of Board of Directors of UDRBC

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

3 thoughts on “Bailouts for Wasteful States Banning Drilling? No Way!

  1. I fail to see how this article does anything to expand to expand the market for Marcellus and Utica gas in its natural market.

    States like NY and NJ has always contributed billions more to the federal government that they take back in federal programs, unlike the moochers in the south and mid west. New York’s budget shortfall is from the loss of tax revenue due to the steps taken to control the pandemic, but, no doubt, the those states where disease is now overwhelming their health systems will want to be first in line for even more federal money.

    What about all the Republicans and conservatives in NY? Are they a write off because Cuomo got elected by wide margins three times? Am I supposed to be surprised when you fail to sell gas by linking it to a conservative agenda customers don’t want, instead of the natural advantages of gas?

    Am I supposed to be impressed by 5 year old figures from a group invented by the US Chamber of Commerce that has/had the same physical address as the Chamber and used the their e-mail address also ( Are the conditions of the last two years representative of the overly optimistic earlier figures?

    No, NY is not missing anything because nobody will drill here when gas is $1.80 and PA is oversupplying the market. Just what everyone needs is more over-leveraged companies selling an inelastic commodity in an inelastic market subject to the whim of international players.

    You must make gas an issue independent of politics, not denigrate people because of what state they live in or insufficient loyalty to your political ideology. Stop complaining about what the anti-gassers are doing. It is your job to create a market for gas; oversupply with insufficient demand is a waste of time and capital.

    • Then write it. I’ve invited you numerous times. I also notice you you don’t hesitate to go after those with whom you disagree, Mark.

  2. I found it to be a well written piece. And although the figures are 5 years old – could simply be tied back to the fact that is when the fracking movement was halted by some questionable means. A good majority of the persons I speak with in Chenango County are in favor of Fracking and think a great blow was placed onto their community when the resources under their land became controlled by NYS. I believe a reconsideration of Fracking is forthcoming and the abundant benefits will become a reality.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *