Another New York Pipeline Debacle in the Works?

atlantic sunrise - Jim Willis reportsJim Willis
Editor & Publisher, Marcellus Drilling News (MDN)


If the initial signs are any indication, Andrew Cuomo is set to create another New York pipeline debacle as he attempts to appease gentry class fractivists.

We hate to say this, but we’ve seen this movie before. Last October the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) approved Dominion’s $165 million New Market Project–a project that expands Dominion’s transmission pipeline from western New York across the state to the Capital Region of the state, near Albany (see FERC Approves Expansion of Dominion Pipeline in Upstate NY). As with any fossil fuel-related project, radical environmentalists objected (see NY Antis Flood FERC in Fight Against Dominion’s New Market Project).

Also, once again, there’s a holdup in New York; the Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC), at Gov. Cuomo’s behest, has delayed granting necessary permits for the project to begin. Can anyone say “Constitution” (see NY Gov. Cuomo Refuses to Grant Permits for Constitution Pipeline). Yesterday, three groups, including the Consumer Energy Alliance (CEA), the Business Council of New York State and New York State Laborers’ filed a petition with Cuomo with 10,000 signatures requesting he get off his rear-end and approve the New Market Project.

There are important differences between the stalled Constitution Pipeline and the New Market Project. The Constitution involves building about 125 miles of new pipeline, most of it through New York State. Dominion’s New Market Project involves no new pipe to speak of, but mostly just adding two new compressor stations (“Horseheads” in the Town of Veteran, Chemung County; and “Sheds” in the Town of Georgetown, Madison County), and upgrading a third compressor station (“Brookmans Corners Station” in the Town of Minden, Montgomery County). The extra compression horsepower serves to increase wholesale natural gas supply to National Grid, so that utilities can add more natural gas customers overall. Both pipelines will flow Marcellus Shale gas through them.

new york pipeline gas-compressor-station

The New Market Project is an absolute no-brainer. Before the current era of fossil fuel irrationality and radical left politics, which reigns in New York State, this project would have already been built. But because of political calculations by the man-child Cuomo (a coward), this project is now being delayed by the state. Will it have the same fate as the Constitution?

New York Pipeline New-Market-Project-20151021

Here’s the press release announcing the petition filed with Cuomo:

Consumer Energy Alliance (CEA), the Business Council of New York State and New York State Laborers’ today submitted a petition with more than 10,000 signatures of New York state citizens to Gov. Andrew Cuomo asking him to grant the permits needed to begin work on the New Market Project, which would enhance reliability and improve access to natural gas to National Grid customers in upstate New York.

“By permitting the New Market Project, New York will see an influx of private investment, tax dollars, and much-needed job creation,” CEA President David Holt said. “More importantly, homeowners, retirees, businesses and those of us living on fixed incomes, will enjoy lower utility prices. For these reasons, CEA – and its tens of thousands of consumer members — have always strongly supported a robust natural gas pipeline network throughout the country and the Northeast. Pipelines are also the safest, most efficient and most environmentally friendly method for moving energy resources to market – and this certainly fits the bill.”

Rather than build a new line, the project would add natural gas pipeline capacity through an existing line in order to provide much-needed natural gas to National Grid customers in New York. The additional new supply of natural gas will further serve customers in Albany, central New York, and the greater New York City areas by allowing for greater supply to affordable natural gas. This will encourage job growth and economic development.

Additionally, the project will allow consumers to save an estimated $20 million in the first 10 years of the project’s life. New York localities will also receive about $4.4 million in annual property tax payments, allowing the state to further invest in municipal service like roads, schools, firefighters, and snowplows.

“The Business Council of New York State is pleased to join with New Yorkers from all walks of life in support of the New Market Project. The Dominion Project would address the growth in natural gas demand in the Capital Region and ensure that New York City customers would have access to new sources of reliable and affordable natural gas,” said Heather C. Briccetti, president and CEO of The Business Council of New York State, Inc. “The project will not only relieve upstream supply constraints, it will also play a key part in New York’s energy future by providing New York consumers with enhanced access to affordable and clean natural gas.”

During peak construction, a New York-based contractor will hire an estimated 320 new employees to construct the new facilities. The project, in total, represents $158 million in private investment, much of which will be spent within New York’s borders.

“On behalf of 39,000 hardworking LiUNA members that call New York their home, the time has come for the Cuomo Administration to approve this project that will bring more jobs to New York State and lower the utility bills of New York State residents,” said John Hutchings, Director of the New York State Laborers’ Organizing Fund. “The working men and women of New York urge the administration to end the needless delays in approving this utility reliability project that benefits upstate and downstate New Yorkers.”

Editor’s Note: Yet again, the pipeline industry is so far behind the curve as to almost be on the other side. It’s excruciatingly painful, as a supporter of this and other pipeline projects, to read these pablum news releases from the industry. Who gets paid to write this stuff? What will it take for pipeline company officials to rise from their slumber, realize what’s really going on in New York rise and fight back against the corrupt and tyrannical Cuomo regime with tactics that actually work? Neither petitions, nor appeals to good government, wise energy policy and jobs are going to do anything to move a governor hopelessly indebted to gentry class fractivists and extremists who are committed to destroying the oil and gas industry.

There is apparently another New York pipeline debacle in the works and nothing will alter its inevitable course other than taking on these opponents head-on with lawsuits and effective political force. LIUNA support for the project is wonderful and we love the Consumer Energy Alliance but it isn’t flowery statements that are going to influence Cuomo. The problem is that Cuomo takes LIUNA for granted – that they will, in the end, vote for him regardless of what decision he makes on any particular project. If the union really wants the jobs it needs to take those votes away once and show him they are tired of being used.

Likewise for the pipeline company and the Business Council. Playing ball with a corrupt emperor such as Cuomo, as if this was just the normal political process, is a completed failed strategy guaranteed to produce another New York pipeline debacle; which is exactly what Cuomo wants so he can, once again, appease his gentry class puppet masters and radical environmentalist constituencies at no real cost. What Dominion and the Business Council should be doing is telling the world what’s really going on here and laying down the legal and political gauntlet. The failure to do so reflects an industry living in the dark ages. 

For more great articles on the subject of natural gas development every single day, subscribe to Marcellus Drilling News using this convenient link.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

4 thoughts on “Another New York Pipeline Debacle in the Works?

  1. Like I been sayin all along, there,s a lotta dogs in the hunt for those energy markets! Cash talks, honesty walks.


    How many people running for office right now in ny state or elsewhere are anti natural gas pipeline movement politicians like zephyr teachout for example who recently got the thumbs up from the nytimes editorial board? It seems a little off to me to attribute the anti pipeline and natural gas thing to Cuomo alone as for years he was the target of the antifracking pipeline movement and the politicians who support or seem to represent that movement.

    Moving on what did the dnc platform folks hear about fracking and natural gas, perhaps pipelines, just this weekend? Were the people testifying or speaking credible?


    I guess one could watch the video. Unfortunately I recognize people involved in the port ambose lng export conspiracy theory fiasco as well as organizations that produced form letters in the docket and mutliple people testifying from the antifracking pipeline resistance movement. And that is on top of the platform committee featuring an antifracking natural gas pipeline movement leader bill mckibben. Mckibben was formerly best known as a climate movement person as someone who wrote about global warming for a long time. Now, like quite a number of influential people in environmental circles, he is anti natural gas, fracking and infrastructure.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *